DePauw University | Winter Term 2015 | Prof. Chaz Evans
Tuesday, January 27, 2015
Thursday, January 22, 2015
Final Essay - Ryan Grizzard
Ryan Grizzard
Professor Evans
Art Historical Context in
Video Games
January 20, 2015
Tetris!
Tetris. What makes this simple game so hard to stop
playing? Tetris has been around for a little over 30 years and yet still to
this day, it is enjoyed by players old and young. But we are all wondering,
what keeps us so attracted to it. Tetris has a lot to offer but there are some
main features of the game that make it so compelling to play. One feature that
Tetris has to offer is the simplicity of playing the game. By the game being so
easy to play, it is available for players of all ages. Another key feature that
most people do not know about the game are the beneficial health effects that
it has on humans. It helps improve brain functions in a variety of ways
including memory. Last but not least, the game itself is just of fun. Just by
playing it once you will understand how compelling it is and why millions of
people love it!
On June 6th, 1987 a computer programmer from the
USSR named Alexey Pajitnov released the popular game we all know today called
Tetris. Tetris is derived from the Greek word tetra which means “four” and the
reasoning behind the naming of the game is because each piece is composed of
four blocks. There are seven different block variations and that’s how the
different shapes of the pieces are formed. Tetris was inspired by the game
Pentominoes and the objective of Pentominoes is to assemble 12 different pieces
into a rectangular box without pieces overlying or leaving empty spaces. Pajitnov
wanted to find a way to incorporate the fundamentals of Pentominoes into a
computer game. He did this successfully with a few changes such as: having
pieces fall from the top of the screen and being able for lines to disappear once
it has been cleared.
The rules of Tetris are quite simple actually. The
objective of the game is to make as many horizontal lines as possible by
strategically placing the falling figures. 1 out of 7 different figures falls
from the top of the board and you can see what shape is going to appear next by
checking the “up next” section which is usually on the upper right part of the
screen. You are able to rotate each piece either clockwise or counterclockwise and
move it left or right in order to place it where you would like it to go. Once
a horizontal line has been made, it will disappear and any pieces above that
layer will move down a row. Pieces begin to fall faster every ten lines you
clear increasing the difficulty of the game. The game is over when your pieces
pile up and touch the top of the game board. Your high scores will be saved and
you can play at a later time to try and beat them.
So, it sounds pretty simple right? Basically just fit the
pieces in the gaps to form horizontal lines and not make them reach the top of
the board. This is the mindset of many people who play Tetris. But there are
different strategies to go about when play Tetris. There are the options of
Vertical Stacking or Horizontal Stacking. Also by not fast dropping the pieces
to save more time to plan out your next move. Well however the game is played
it is amazing because of its simplicity and it allows people of all ages to
enjoy this game. Tetris has a wide variety of players since it can be played by
children, adolescents, adults and even the elderly. The objective of the game
is easy to learn by younger and older audiences which makes it easier for
players to understand. Not all people can learn how to play a complex video
game such as Call of Duty in a matter of two minutes since there is just so
many things going on that you need to pay attention to. Tetris simply focuses
on the board and the only movement you get from the game are the pieces when
they are falling, moved, or rotated. Even the structure of the gameplay is
simple with basic two-dimensional graphics that are not hard to look at and
focus on. This is makes it a distinctive than other video games that are being
released because there is not much motion or any flashing graphics which could
cause seizures in people who have epilepsy.
With that being said, Tetris has been proven to show many
health benefits on the human body (more specifically in the brain.) In 2009 Dr.
Richard Haier conducted and experiment to research the effects of Tetris on the
brain. He had 26 adolescents play Tetris for about 30 minutes per day for a 3
month period and he compared their brain power to another adolescent group who
had not been playing Tetris. The research showed that the adolescents who
played Tetris for the 3 month period had an increase in brain efficiency and also
an increase in grey matter in the cerebral cortex. Dr. Richard Haier was quoted
saying, “What we found was a change in the brain after playing Tetris, the
thickness of the cerebral cortex actually increased, by less than half a
millimeter.” The cerebral cortex is in charge of memory, attention, language
and perception. So by playing Tetris you will be able to increase all these
factors of your brain. Oxford University stated that by playing Tetris, it
helps with Post Traumatic Stress Disorder and reduces flashbacks experienced by
people with it. In 2014, Science Direct published an article claiming that
playing Tetris helps you avoid cravings including smoking, food or alcohol.
Psychology professor Jackie Andrade says that looking at colorful shapes and
trying to fit them into gaps occupies the same space in your brain as trying to
imagine the food or item you are craving. The brain cannot process playing
Tetris and craving needs at the same time, so while playing the game the brain
cancels out the craving needs. There are also some downfalls to playing too
much Tetris. A common old saying is, “too much of anything is never good.” This
applies to Tetris as well because playing it for too long can lead to what is
called The Tetris Effect. The Tetris effect is when you see Tetris pieces in
your everyday life and you dream about the shapes in your sleep. Though this is
not as common, it does happen sometimes but that does not stop people from
playing it and this helps emphasize that moderation is the key.
With Tetris being such a simple game, what makes it so
compelling? Dr. Stafford from the University of Sheffield proposes an
interesting theory as to why he believes Tetris is so addicting. He believes
that it is addictive to complete mini tasks while still being able to achieve more.
By this he means that there are different things to accomplish all at the same
time. The mini tasks are rotating the pieces or checking to see what piece is
going to appear next. Achieving more applies to clearing lines and not losing
the game. Since there are many components to focus on, it keeps you occupied
and wanting to keep playing the game. Dr. Stafford also believes in the Zeigarnik
Effect which means that people tend to remember interrupted or incomplete tasks
rather than tasks already completed. In a video Dr. Stafford is quoted saying
that it is “Easier to think with the game than about the game.” This statement
is relevant because in other video games you try to figure out how to beat the
game but in Tetris you can’t ever beat it. The game has no real final ending
and the objective at the end of the day is to set the highest score you can
get. There is no story line or set outcome of the game because the whole game
is based off of your decisions which is a key reason many people love Tetris.
In conclusion, Tetris has many components that can factor
into why it is the amazing game it is today. People may like to play it just
because it is easy to play and they don’t have to learn advanced controls.
Based on the new research and study suggestions some players will be attracted
to play this old school game for the health benefits. Knowing that it could increase
brain efficiency and help with everyday skills is a good reason to play a video
game. Maybe it is a mixture of all the factors that makes Tetris the game it
is. It is intriguing how such a simple game can have so many complex components
that come along with it. One without the other would change the structure of the
game and it would not be the legendary game that it is today.
Final Draft- Natalie Santiago
Natalie
Santiago
Videogames in AHC
Videogames in AHC
Professor
Evans
January 21, 2014
January 21, 2014
What
Lies Beneath the Surface
Tim Schafer, the creator of Psychonauts [1] wanted to represent the
condition of the human psyche in the digital world. According to Freudian
belief, the mind contains three different levels of consciousness, one of them
being the unconscious mind. Since our brain limits our focus and awareness to
one thing at a time, all of the things we cannot focus on and all of the
memories we have stored, but cannot access, go to this limbo-like state of
mind. Moments repressed and things forgotten do not reach the level of
awareness required for us to recall a particular event because sometimes they
are too threatening to acknowledge. These powerful subconscious entities and
desires stir away with in the walls of our unconscious, affecting our daily
lives without us ever really realizing it or understanding why. This game
demonstrates how the unconscious mind is affected by emotional baggage [2].
To begin, Psychonauts is a psychological video game about a boy named Raz and
his quest to becoming a psychic spy who uses his abilities to fight evil. On
this journey, he travels through the minds of his friends and camp counselors to
help them overcome traumatic experiences, expose the skeletons in their
closets, and confront stressors. The objective of the game is to pass through
levels of training and exercise to save the world from psychic domination.
While uncovering some of the character’s traumas, we begin to see how the human
psyche [3] can unravel and attack itself, causing us to be insecure and
question our existential status.
Emotional baggage is considered to
be a detrimental unresolved issue hidden within our psyche that causes us to be
distraught in someway or other. According to Freud, we use defense mechanisms
to avoid the inner conflicts with which we refuse to let surface. He compares
our unconscious mind to “the tip of an iceberg,”(McLeod, 2013) [4], with the
conscious part being the level above the surface that we are aware of, and the
bottom level being the information we keep hidden and at bay. Characters in the game are stricken with
insanity because of these hidden events that inevitably lead to their unsteady downfalls.
One character in particular, Fred
Bonaparte [5], uses regression as his defense mechanism, and has a slight personality
disorder. Fred is a descendent of the
great Napoleon Bonaparte and is in an insane asylum due to his constant mental
battle with his genetic memory of Napoleon. He backs out of his
responsibilities and surrenders to his problems as soon as they arise, causing
him to be insecure and question whether or not he can live up to the standards
of his famous ancestor. He displays random phases of regressions while shifting
between the personalities of his shy ordinary self, and his inner Napoleon.
When Raz enters Fred’s unconscious mind he discovers his emotional baggage and
convinces him to confront it by aiding his people in battle against the “real
Napoleon”. Once Fred conquers the image of his late relative, he finds his
sanity, stops having physical outbursts, and is able to grasp reality.
The unconscious mind also copes with
traumatic experience through showing symptoms of bodily injuries that either nonexistent,
or have no physical source of outbreak. In the case of Anna O [6], she suffered
from hysteria and would endure physiological symptoms such as the inability to
comprehend or speak her language, paralysis, restricted vision, aversion to
nourishment, and a severe nervous cough. Gloria Von Gouton [7] is an example of
a character that, like Anna, developed physical discomfort and mood swings. Along
with Fred Bonaparte, she too was a patient of Thorney Towers insane asylum. The
way her unconscious mind adapted to her emotional baggage was by creating a brassy
critic inside her mind that lead her to believe she was never good enough for
the entertainment industry. She developed this psychosis soon after experiencing
the death of her mother who jumped off the catwalk of a theater. Raz enters her
mind and defeats the critic by showing her that she is better star than she
gives herself credit for.
Traumatic emotional experiences can take a
toll on the unconscious mind and alter someone’s perception of themselves, and
others. As Gregory Mitchell puts it, “Freud
maintained that the unconscious was composed of repressed, traumatic childhood
experiences that involved the clash of emerging instinctual needs and the
oppressive reality of the family and society,” (Harvey, 2012). In Psychonauts, Raz is only a ten year old
child dealing with oppressive family issues of his own. He ran away from his
family circus to Whispering Rock Summer Camp to pursue his dream of becoming a
psychonaut; something he felt his father hated him for. He wanted to escape the
thought of being different and unacceptable. His father was an acrobat who
surprisingly turns out to be psychic himself and uses this ability to contact
his son in the final round of the game.
The final round is The Meat
Circus [8] where Raz is forced to confront his emotional baggage with his
father and his projection of his father. The projection of his father is
demanding, expectant, and unaccepting. This enforces Raz’s inner conflict with
himself that he thought he was never good enough for his father and was
becoming the very disappointment his father expected him to be. His real father
sees this projection and tells his son that he does not hate him and just wants
him to be happy. He gives Raz his psychic abilities and Raz becomes this figure
used to defeat the paternal mutation that is in his mind.
An interesting concept that
was brought up during discussion was the fact that the creators of the game
came up with the neurosis for each character. Based on what kind of traumatic
experience the character was dealing with would determine how to help them
overcome that emotional baggage. When you know what the problem is, it becomes
that much easier to confront the problem, but what if the game was not as
simplistic? If Psychonauts were a
game about creating the traumatic experience before overcoming it, a lot of
depth would have been added to the objective of the game, and probably would
have boosted sales records. To create the psychosis further introduces and
shows the player a walk through of how people approach psychological issues and
get past them. To add this to the game would demonstrate more of the
psychological aspect behind the game and what point they were trying to
emphasize with that in mind.
In the depths of the
unconscious mind, the creators of Psychonauts [9] formulate
their own interpretation of the human psyche and demonstrate how it can become
distorted through traumatic experience. The content that buries
itself away from our subconscious-recall is stronger than our ability to bring
it to the surface, making it that much harder for us to access it and get past
it. When Raz enters his own unconscious mind he discovers the true challenge of
having to confront your own demons, and over powering them to take back control
of your emotional well-being. The incorporation of psychedelic colors, figments
of imagination, and abnormal location all represent the unexpected elements of
a world within your mind separated from your consciousness. From defense
mechanisms to physiological manifestations, Psychonauts
indicates how the unconscious mind is affected by emotional turmoil, and how we
attempt to find what is hidden beneath the surface.
WORKS
CITED
·
McLeod, Saul. N.p., 2013. Web.
2015.
·
"Anna O Case by Freud." Anna
O Case by Freud. N.p., n.d. Web. 20 Jan. 2015.
·
Harvey, Jonathan. "Unitarian
Universalist Church of Palo Alto." Confronting Our Shadow Self with
Jung and Buddha: The Ugly, the Bad and the Good. N.p., 12 Aug. 2012. Web.
21 Jan. 2015.
![]() |
| Figure 3 Human Psyche |
![]() |
| Figure 7 Gloria Von Gouton |
![]() |
| Figure 5 Frank Bonaparte |
![]() |
| Figure 8 The Meat Circus |
![]() |
| Figure 1 Psychonauts |
![]() |
| Figure 9 Psychonauts |
![]() |
| Figure 2 Emotional Baggage |
![]() |
| Figure 4 iceberg |
Final Essay - Jake Hagan
Jake Hagan
1-19-15
Professor Evans
Final Essay
Grand Theft Auto V: A Joke Gone too Far?
Grand Theft Auto V provides for us a
pathway to make an example out of. Some people claim that the entirety of the
game is a satire anyway. But is this satire taking things too far? We could sit
and debate the satirical aspects of the game, but in the end, when people are
interacting with the game and seeing the gameplay, they might not be looking at
it in a joking manner. GTAV has one very
questionable scene from a mission in the game that should not be taken lightly.
The effect of these “over the top scenes” is what I am going to get into,
looking from a psychological standpoint. Grand Theft Auto V has many elements
that would concern people to point to desensitization to violence,
crime-related incidents, etc. but the game takes the issue of a “harmless”
enjoyable game too far with the torture mission. While I do not believe the
playing of the game, or others like it, induces violent acts, I do believe that
this part of the mission could have been omitted and pushes the boundaries of
what should be included in games being played for entertainment. The media we
view, whether we are aware or not, does have an effect on our behavior and we
need to be cautious of taking games played for pleasure too far.
The psychological aspects of these
violent scenes, like the torture scene, have an effect on people that has been
shown through psychological studies and experiments searching for answers to
why they is correlations between violence and violent media. The first study I
am going to highlight is one done by researchers from the University of
Michigan, VU University Amsterdam and Iowa State University. Their aim was to
test the theory that exposure to violent media reduces aid offered to people in
pain. The first of their two tests made participants play a violent or
nonviolent video game for 20 minutes. The participants were tested separately
and played Carmageddon, Duke Nukem, Mortal Kombat, or Future Cop for violent
games, or Glider Pro, 3D Pinball, Austin Powers, or Tetra Madness for
nonviolent games. They were then asked to fill out lengthy questionnaires but 3
minutes after being done playing their game, a audio recording of a fight was
played outside the room. The researcher was testing how long it would take the
participant to assist one of the people who had been “hurt” in the recording. The
results of this first study show that those who played violent video games took
up to 73.3 seconds longer to respond to the victim than those who had just
played a nonviolent video game. This adds up to upwards of 450% longer time
than those who played the nonviolent game. Participants were also asked to rate
the severity of the fight, and those who played the violent game rated the
fight as being not as serious.
In the second study that the
researchers conducted, participants were observed at a movie theatre either
before or after seeing a violent or nonviolent film. The researchers used a
confederate, someone who assists the researchers and knows what is happening,
to fake a fall because they had an injured leg and were walking with crutches.
The researchers were testing how much time it took for the participants to
react and help the fallen confederate in need of assistance. There was no real
difference in the amount of time it took people to react before seeing the
movie, but the results after having seen the movie were intriguing. Those who
had just seen a violent movie on average took up to two seconds longer than
those who had just seen a nonviolent movie. This means that the violent
moviegoers took 26% longer to respond.
What does this research say about
GTAV, more specifically the torture scene in the game? This research shows that
exposure to violent media has an effect on those who view it, and it affects
helping delay and reaction to violent situations. But what does this mean for
those who claim that Grand Theft Auto V in itself is entirely a satire and that
it’s just a game and should not be taken seriously? To those people, I claim
that even though the game itself might be a joke with numerous examples of
different criticisms of the world we live in today like our political system,
criminal justice system and so on an so forth, but that is not the point here.
Imagine you are playing Grand Theft
Auto V for the first time, or even it is the first video game you have ever
played. You have not read anything previously about the game, nor have any
prior knowledge of the game. Playing the game now would not be taken as a joke.
In order to view and play the game in a satirical way means that one has prior
knowledge of the work being a satire. In my personal experience, I had no
knowledge that the game was meant to be a satire. While I did not believe
everything in the game to be real or that I should attempt anything that
happens in the game, I was still affected by the gruesome torture scene in one
of the missions of the game.
You are Trevor Phillips, one of
three main characters available to play with during gameplay of GTAV. Trevor is
a “redneck/hillbilly” white male, who lives in the rural part of the city in a
trailer park like living area. Has aggression issues and has a long criminal
record. He is the most aggressive and unremorseful character in the game. He
has a quick temper and is not afraid to cross anyone who is in his way. On this
specific mission, Trevor and the other two playable characters have teamed up
with a federal agency in order to track down a large criminal organization and
its leader. There has been a man that was captured and taken into custody of
the federal agency and this man was brought to an abandoned warehouse scene,
tied with ropes to a chair in the middle of the room. You get orders from the
federal agent with you, “Choose your instrument, and go to work on him.” The
man tied in the chair pleads with you he does not know what you are talking
about, to let him go, and so on. Then pops up the possible “tools of torture”
available to use on this man in order to get him to talk and reveal an address
that will assist the feds in shutting down the criminal organization. You can
select one of four instruments; these tools ranging from pliers, used to yank
out teeth, an electric battery, used for electrocution, a large wrench, used
for beating the man senseless, and lastly a jerry can full of water, used for
water boarding. If you so choose to use all for instruments, this scene can
last up to around 15 minutes of constant torturing of this man in order to get
him to speak. Does this seem like a joke now? While those who argue on the side
that this scene is a satirical representation of what is being done by the USA
in regards to Guantanamo Bay, I do not dispute that. But so what if it is? Just
because something is meant to be taken as a joke, does not mean it will be
taken that way because regardless if that is the truth or not, the fact is that
the gamer still sees and has to physically torture a man with buttons on the
controller. I have not found any research on anything having to do with this
phenomena of the gamer actually having to cause the violence directly, but my
hypothesis would be that it only intensifies the effect it has on the
desensitization to violence.
With the realness of the graphics,
this scene and the violence in the game in general, can be compared to other
violent games of the sort. Using another example from a game, Call of Duty
Modern Warfare 2 campaign mode has a mission in it that requires the player to
load up with large amounts of armor, high-powered weapons, and effectively shoot
up an airport terminal (which is also used in the online multiplayer as a map).
Many people were outraged at this mission and caused quite a stir with some
people in remembrance of 9/11 and other terrorist attacks that have happened in
this country. But the main and crucial difference between these two games is
quite simple actually. Before this mission in Call of Duty Modern Warfare 2,
there is a pop-up on the screen asking the player if he or she wants to
continue with this mission because of the graphic nature of the mission. The
player must then select yes or no and choose whether or not to play the
mission. There are no consequences for choosing not to play the mission. This
crucial difference is one we do not see in GTAV the torture mission. It would
not be possible to continue the story mode of the game without playing this
mission and going through this scene, thus essentially, the player must play
the mission or be punished by not being able to finish the story mode. While I
am not stating that there should be a screening before every mission or scene
of the game, there should be some sort of way that the player is able to know
exactly what he or she are going to encounter during the game. Whether that be
by putting it in the rating on the case or some other manner, each and every
player has the right to know what they are playing.
Going along with other related games
having questionable scenes, the game “The Last of Us” portrays a way that GTAV
could have done it differently. In this scene from “The Last of Us”, the player
is not in control of the actual torturing and only sees a portion of violence
before the scene cuts out and goes onto the next screen. This game effectively portrayed
that people were being tortured without the player themselves having to conduct
all of the torturing process and without moving the controller to torture. This
is one example of a way that GTAV could have gone at its torture scene differently,
they could have shown a little bit of violence while at the same time giving
the same message to the player without having the same effects that come from
GTAV.
People have been playing these types
of what some would call “senseless” violent games for years, which causes no
concern for those who can distinctly discern what is clearly “just a game” vs.
“I can do this in real life”. What could be done to avoid people from becoming
desensitized to violence is omitting these up-close, in your face scenes, such
as physically torturing a man to get him to talk. The makers could have kept
some people from discrediting the game along with violent media as a whole by
taking out this scene. It puts the integrity of the game in jeopardy and many
people could have social and political issues with a scene like this.
Even though some may claim the game
is just a joke, I do not see having to torture a man during the game as a joke.
The player still has to torture the guy to get him to talk. The fact that the
player must choose his torture technique and then actually move the analog
sticks to pry a tooth out, electrocute, etc. is one that puts the player in the
shoes of this character who is completely unbothered by this experience of
torturing someone and feels no remorse whatsoever. What kind of message does
this send to those playing? Whether gamers everywhere want to accept it or not,
violence does have an effect on our behaviors, not to the extent some make it
out to be, but at the same time, we must be wary of our developments into more
realistic games that can cause greater issues in the future for us.
Works Cited
Comfortably Numb. S.l.: Book On Demand, 2013. Web.
"Desensitizing the Mind to Violence - Dave
Grossman, Author."Desensitizing the Mind to Violence - Dave Grossman,
Author. N.p., n.d. Web. 22 Jan. 2015.
Dictionary.com. Dictionary.com, n.d. Web. 22 Jan. 2015.
"Grand Theft Auto 1." GTA
Wiki. N.p., n.d. Web. 20 Jan. 2015.
Joel
Kauth
Professor
Evans
Videogames
in Art Historical Context
17
January 2015
Life is not a Game
The human race has thrived in this
universe that we inhabit based on not success, perfection, or predictability.
Humanity’s most valuable assets have been the flaws, haphazardness, and
miscalculation that have been accounted for throughout our existence. The
videogame: The Sims2 as
well as the movie: The Truman Show1
are both examples of media where the unpredictability and free will of humans
is excluded from their production which negates their ability to successfully
or accurately simulate humanity. In each form of media, the Sims that one is
able to command or the protagonist in The
Truman Show can stray away from outcomes desired by the omniscient source of
direction for them. The game and movie show similarities in how the characters’
free will pulls them away from the results desired. To set up this comparison,
parallels as well as relating themes will be connected to support the argument
that humanity cannot be simulated or manipulated.
The
Sims is a computer game designed by Will Wright, whose initial purpose
was
“to create a virtual dollhouse after losing his home during the Oakland
firestorm of 1991”. The game consists of dictating “Sims”, or simulated people,
to interact with themselves, household objects, and computer controlled Sims. The
player looks down on their Sims’ family lot, which typically consists of a
house, throughout the entirety of the game, and can control whether the walls
of the house are transparent or not. This omniscient sense of visibility is
similar, yet superior to that of The
Truman Show. The Truman Show is a movie about a thirty-year-old man named
Truman, whose entire life has actually been a nonstop “reality” show. Adopted
by a production company at birth, with the whereabouts of his actual parents
unknown, Truman grows up in Seahaven, a television production set created
inside an arcological dome4. Scarred by his father’s tragic death in
boating accident, Truman never seeks to venture outside of Seahaven until he
begins to become suspicious of his surroundings. This suspicion of Truman’s
provides a roar of enthusiasm for the TV audience, as his struggle to find out
the truth becomes the main focus of the show. Christof, the show’s creator and
producer, made it nearly impossible to not see what Truman is up to.
Watching from his command post located in
the Dome’s “sun”5, Christof, as well as the production crew, keep
tabs on Truman by constantly scanning over monitors that are being fed live
feed from five thousand cameras all over Seahaven. From Truman’s bathroom
mirror to his car, his surroundings are always under watch. Although Truman is
able to escape Christof’s surveillance temporarily near the end of the movie,
Christof’s ability to constantly monitor Truman from a bird’s eye view is
nearly identical to playing The Sims
from the isometric perspective. Both instances of monitoring can also conclude
that Christof, in addition to the player of The
Sims, both assume the role of God in their respective scenarios.
The
Sims is an isometric-view3 sandbox style computer game with no
absolute end or completion of the game. The game is played by commanding
“Sims”, or simulated people, to perform specific actions by manipulating their
environment or interacting with fellow Sims. An important aspect to the game
are the Sim’s needs levels, which are the meters that display the type of satisfaction
a particular Sim possesses with eight different needs: hunger, comfort,
bladder, energy, fun, social, hygiene, and environment. These eight needs are
the keys to one’s Sims to execute the actions that were commanded. If one or
more of the need levels are shockingly low, the Sim is able to cancel out a
command and perform whatever action is necessary to bring the need level back
up. Yes, The Sims’ ability to
replicate the basic needs for happiness and satisfaction is impressive, but so
many factors that lead to being content are absent from the game. One can’t
limit the factors that go into supplying happiness to just eight needs, yet
those are the only ones present in the game. There is an infinite amount of
factors that play into happiness, as well as an infinite amount of factors that
could satisfy each need. By limiting the Sims’ needs as well their options to
satisfy these needs, the game is not able to simulate humanity. Lucian Ghinda
created a list online of factors that could lead to happiness. A staggering
fifty-four possibilities were listed, and that’s barely scratching the surface.
In The Truman Show, Truman always followed the path that Christof made
for him until a stage light came crashing down from the ceiling of Seahaven’s
dome. He begins to become suspicious of his surroundings, and slowly begins to
stray away from Christof’s image of the show. On his way to work, Truman spots
a homeless man6 who looks exactly like his deceased father who had
died when he was a boy. As Truman attempts to pursue the homeless man, numerous
obstacles and groups of people slow down Truman. The homeless man is eventually
taken away on a public bus, and Truman’s suspicions continue to grow. Truman
refused to be lured by the distractions presented by Christof, and by doing so
exhibited his free will taking charge against the simulated environment of Seahaven.
Later in the movie, Truman speaks out against
his “wife” when she advertises a drink for the show as a form of product
placement in the middle of their conversation. He proceeds to take away the
peeler that she then pulls on him, and puts her in a lock hold. Christof
urgently sends Marlon, Truman’s best friend, to diffuse the situation. This act
of aggression against his wife, Meryl, was a direct challenge to whatever the
force was that Truman suspected of controlling his environment. Although he
still didn’t know who or what was manipulating his environment, Truman
continued to become more suspicious due to these strange events.
In The
Sims, Sims are reliant on commands by the player in order to perform any
actions. Yet, when given commands while their needs levels are down, Sims have
the ability to cancel out actions in order to satisfy their neglected needs.
Possibly, someone commanded a Sim to watch TV while his or her hunger level was
very low. Typically, the Sim would nix the command, and replace it was the
command of going to the refrigerator to eat some food. This ability to abandon
the player’s commands in order to satisfy their personal needs is a prime
example of a “simulated person” exercising their free will. By doing so, it
supports the fact that humanity can’t be simulated or manipulated since Sims
are able to stray away from desired outcomes, just like how Truman begins to
stray away from the path that Christof has laid out for him throughout his
entire life.
The
Truman Show is set in
Seahaven, the “city” that is inhabited by Truman, and hired actors and
actresses. Of the actors and actresses, there are multiple races represented,
for example: Truman’s neighbors that are African-American. Yet throughout the
movie, mental illnesses, disorders, medical disorders, and physical disorders
are not present. The movie fails to represent these different categories, and
by doing so is leaving out a huge part of the human race. Dwarfism,
schizophrenia, Down syndrome, as well as being disabled (just to name a few)
are all aspects of daily human living. Our genetic and mental makeup are each
essential pieces to how we make decisions, and in part by leaving these out,
takes away from the credibility of how Truman grew up in a perfect environment.
Christof is quoted saying, “Seahaven is the way the world should be.” By
negating any instabilities or disabilities from the Seahaven community,
Christof wipes out any chance that he could possibly be simulating humanity.
Yes, he is manipulating everything that Truman interacts with, but all he is
doing is simply manipulating an artificial environment.
The
Sims shares the same
flaw when considering if the game successfully simulates humanity. When customizing
your Sims7, there is not an option whether to make your Sim a little
person. As far as mental disorders, illnesses, and physical disorders go, there
are no examples from the game where it is made apparent that a Sim has any of
these. Yes, Sims may exhibit mood tendencies that could point to any certain
mental illness or disorder, but it is not a theme in the game. The game
excluding these possible qualities of human life is a major shortcoming when it
comes to trying to reproduce humanity.
While playing The Sims, the player will confront situations where censorship
occurs. While enjoying a shower or using the toilet, a shroud of blurred colors
covers the Sim. Although I agree that this is a good feature for younger
players of the game, this aspect to the game adds to it’s inability to simulate
humanity. A similar scenario arises in The
Truman Show. Truman’s wife, Meryl, attempts to take his mind off traveling
to Fiji by suggesting they should conceive their first child. While the scene
moves to their bedroom, the camera shot transforms into a loop of a curtain
blowing in the wind. This is an example of censorship since the scene of Truman
and Meryl having sex was replaced with the blowing curtain. Reproduction is
essential to survival, so if every time sex instead turned into a curtain
blowing in the wind, the human race would be wiped out within two hundred
years. By enforcing censorship, both examples of media take away from their
ability to attempt to simulate humanity.
The
Sims and The Truman Show are two similar forms of
media that attempt to replicate the human experience of reality. While both
take clever angles to make their simulations legitimate, they both lack key
principles that are necessary when attempting to simulate or manipulate
humanity.
Works Cited

1.

2.

3.

4.

5.

6.

7.

Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)








