Wednesday, January 7, 2015

Reading Response 2 - Brannon Hamm

Anthropy and Nooney both discuss an aspect of video game culture that has been irrevocably intertwined with its very existence since the creation of the medium: its niche, elitist, socially-eschew nature.  Nooney discusses the social isolation of the game community through an examination of its much more exaggerated past; Anthropy endeavors to criticize the modern state of video game culture on similar grounds. 
I myself see more merit to the discussion that Nooney offers.  He takes a piece of history, a terrible ero-game entitled the oh-so-innovative “Softporn”, and uses its example as an indication of the social history of the game industry.  There are many features of the game that he finds representative: its earnest attempts to entertain; its obvious latent misogyny; its limp, inward humor.  He sees it as symptomatic of a culture that is composed of introverts, a burgeoning culture that reacts negatively to outside interaction and poorly understands society at large.  In short, 80s “gamer” culture—male, outcast, bitter losers.  To be frank, there is a lot of truth in his words. 

Anthropy has a much more nonsensical argument.  She claims that video games in their entirety are made by and are composed of a single worldview—the implication being this worldview is that of a middle-class, socially-awkward, heterosexual, white male.   She then uses this assumption to springboard into her fantasy: that games be created by everyone, for everyone.  In order to claim that this is how it should be, she ignores a very important point: creating video games is hard.  One must learn to code mountains and mountains of data and arrange them in a perfect way.  Much to what I imagine to be the chagrin of Anthropy, this is in fact expert knowledge.  One must train themselves for years before one can perform with competence the tasks necessary for making a good video game that people will want to play.  Moreover, there is nothing in the industry itself that inhibits anyone from pursuing the training necessary to create games—in that way, Anthropy is living in her own paradise and she doesn’t even know it.

No comments:

Post a Comment