Wednesday, January 14, 2015

Reading Response 4 - Brandon Wright

The Salon reading by Corey Mead Shall we play a game? Talks of the history of video games and the United States military, while Galloway's “Gaming: Essays on Algorithmic Culture” talks more of the realism that can come from video games, but does speak of the US military attempting to create a realistic game, while Dyer-Witheford and de Peuter both speak more on the history of realism in video games and how people reacted to them.

In the Salon reading, not much is really contestable about the history of the Video games and their intertwining with the United States military. Corey Mead presents the facts in a clear manner and while I knew some information about how the military used game developers and video games for the basis of simulations, I didn't realize that the military started the idea of video games with “Spacewar!” and would later use DOOM and DOOM II for simulation mods. In addition, the budget numbers and cost of the simulations developed by the military compared to what was created commercially was a very interesting comparison.


With Galloway however has more room to talk about and explore what he is saying with his writings. In the third chapter of “Gaming: Essays on Algorithmic Culture”, which is titled “Social Realism”, Galloway attempts to look into and explain what makes a game “realistic” and how to define what realism actually is. He immediately discounts the look of the game. Just because the game looks real, and has an extremely high polygon count in the models does not make the game “realistic”. Instead Galloway tries to proposition that it is through a feedback loop that a game is realistic. The setting has to be something the user can see themselves in. such as an American playing America's Army, but not a Palestinian since they are not American. On page 84 he writes “the challenge is not only to capture the social realities of the disenfranchised but also to inject the game back into the correct social milieu of available players where it rings true.”

No comments:

Post a Comment