Tuesday, January 13, 2015

Reading Response 4 - Erin Lupardus



            I don't have a problem with the FPS genre. I see it as what it aims to be--a game. However, somehow the idea of any military actually using these games for training purposes is oddly chilling to me. It is a perfectly reasonable transition considering most first-person shooters revolve around the military and "shooting the bad guys;" as Mead explains, the U.S. military even funded and encouraged the development of such games for training purposes. Yet, the enhanced realism of preparing to actually shoot people casts a dark shadow on the genre in my eyes. War is not a game. There are no respawns, automatic healing powers, or high scores.
            If games aim for realism, why does the reality that they convey become haunting when real life actually interacts with them? Maybe we all look to video games as a way of escaping our own lives--perhaps reliving them in a more exciting yet realistic way. Dyer-Witheford and de Peuter bring up the idea that video games are "recession proof" because when the economy makes life difficult, people turn to a fun activity that they can control (xviii). Second Life has been used for money laundering and business meetings, very real-life (albeit illegal in some cases) activities. Because of Toywar, Etoy actually succeeded in bringing down eToys; thus, a video game's influence had real-life consequences. No wonder Galloway points out Sony's realism "fetish" (70). Video games really are more "methectic" than "mimetic" (72).
            However, realism can go so far as to override reality, and reality can shatter the fun of realism. America's Army uncomfortably mixes "militainment" (xi) and foreign policy. Shoot a "terrorist" in the virtual face and maybe it will mean less when you actually kill him. A Korean couple became so involved in their virtual Prius lives that their real-life baby starved to death. Where does the line between pleasurable and overbearingly evocative realism lie? There is nothing inherently harmful about the premises of America's Army, Second Life, or any other "realistic" game, but sometimes the strive for social realism reveals and encourages the pitfalls of reality.

No comments:

Post a Comment