According to
the Oxford English Dictionary, the avant-garde is "the pioneers or
innovators in any art in a particular period." Given Schrank's analysis of
the current progression of video games, avant-garde games challenge the
"prevailing paradigm of flow" (7), but I believe there comes a point
when too much revolutionizing creates an entirely new art form. For example, some digital paintings and more traditional mediums mimic similar subjects, but they do not belong in the same category because different tools are used to create them. Yes, they are both works of art and can have the same effect, but just because digital paintings test the boundaries of traditional art does not mean they can still be considered traditional art. Schrank refers to Jackson Pollock's art as an example of paintings that challenged painting itself. However, Pollock did not break the definition of painting; rather, he used the tools of painting to create a different result than what was expected. Schrank aims to explore the "broadest" (7) definition of games as possible, but arguing semantics avoids the idea that video games may have evolved into something new entirely.
Video games can be interactive art, but not all interactive art are video
games. Schrank includes Juul's diagram of what can be considered games and what is not, but he finds the definition too exclusive. I would argue that Juul's definition is correct. Games have "fixed rules, a variable outcome, valorization of outcome, player effort, player attachment to outcome, and negotiable consequences" (9). Interactive art such as "The Entertainment" and "Dys4ia" are thought-provoking, powerful outlets for storytelling, but they are not games. "The Entertainment" has no rules, negotiable consequences or variable outcome. It is essentially a play with a different art style and optional order of observing. "Dys4ia" lacks similar qualities. This does not diminish their effectiveness, but classifying them as video games in order to prove a point is incorrect. "The Stanley Parable" and "How Do You Do It" are both games and art because they have all the qualities of a game along with a unique, beautiful, and interesting message to share. Anna Anthropy similarly argued about the definition of video games in Rise of the Videogame Zinesters, but definitions are important. It is a shame that "literally" literally means "figuratively" now because of the people's misuse of the word in everyday language. Yes, there are avant-garde examples of true video games, but art forms evolve and need not stick to their roots in order to make a point.
No comments:
Post a Comment