Wednesday, January 14, 2015

Reading Response 4- Charlotte DeLay

In the first article by Matthew Broderick, the argument is in a semi-narrative style rather than a formal style commonly associated with works pertaining to historical instances. It is from this that his argument stems into one that has readers identify on a more personal level with what is written. From this, certain important figures are able to seem more interesting to the reader while the history of video games in the military is approached. However, even though this does help bring in interest to the reader, it can also be a double-edged sword for the writer. There were some instances that seemed less credible because it was written too much like a narrative. Certain instances would be like with Zyda’s attempt to have the entertainment industry and the military work together. Although the history of these attempts happening are true, certain aspects involving the narrative make it seem questionable on some of the finer details. Because of this, other quotes that have been used in Broderick’s argument feel less credible that what they could have been. By no means does it mean that the history isn’t true, but based on how he had written his arguments, the narrative style showed a bias for certain key figures in the history of military video games, as well as the credibility for some of the actions.

The next read involving the third chapter of the book, Gaming: Essays on Algorithmic Culture by Alexander Galloway structures its arguments on the realism of video games vs. the extent that video games present a realist aspect. From there, Galloway describes what would be considered realist compared to realism and looks to how people can interpret that type of violence. It is through certain examples, like that of military video games, that Galloway is presenting some of his main arguments on how the game is heavily realist-based or has a great deal of realism is affecting the player. Galloway uses this main argument and goes onto other topics involving violence and how these separate ideas can have possible rebounding capabilities. Because of the nature of a video game’s interactive experience, Galloway argues that video games present a realism that can’t be experienced in other forms of media. With that said, the way that Galloway bases his argument leads to some holes. He mentions only two video game types - the games with realism/a realistic approach, and those that don’t convey those ideas. However, from there, Galloway mentions some games that are in the category of some sort of middle ground. It has one of the attributes but not the other. Because of this, it seems as if there should be other types of categories not mentioned. What about games that take a semi-realist approach with realism in the game? Would a type of game like that be in the same sort of category?

In the final reading, the author, Dyer-Witheford, talks about the dominance of video games and how through it, we have a sort of “empire” built from video games. From this, Dyer-Witheford bases his argument through his intro, trying to make the prompt seem more personal by having it seem as if ‘you’ are actually dealing with certain scenarios. He goes onto talking about the dynamics of online games such as Second Life, or America’s Army. Through these, he shows how both simulate certain aspects that furthers a claim about video games that is flawed. By claiming that video games are medias used by the Empire, Dyer-Witheford is taking a big leap. He claims that the video game industry was able to be the only form of media that has succeeded, however, there are other forms of media out there that have dominated over similar scenarios. Film could be mentioned for instance. Although it is fair to say that the video games market has become a corporate giant, so too have other forms of media that have made a name longer than that of the video game industry.

No comments:

Post a Comment