Showing posts with label Reading Response 2. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Reading Response 2. Show all posts

Wednesday, January 7, 2015

Reading Response 2 - Joel Kauth

Rise of the Videogame Zinesters started out as an aggressive front regarding how the author, Anna Anthropy, has a very minimal amount of videogames available to her that capture the queer transgender experience. Further into the first chapter, she forms her argument into why games can't be less focused on shooting men in the face, but rather be able to provide a vast collection of differing experiences that apply to everyone? Before the article, I had never devoted much of any thought to the reason of why videogame themes seem to be constant, as well as their storylines. The parallel she drew with the printing press established the credibility I needed to take her absolutely seriously, as the tone leading up to that point was slightly playful in her argument. But seriously, what exactly will be the printing press for video games?

The Odd History of the First Erotic Computer Game was pretty laid back in it's approach. The article was introduced as a "History", and it was just that. The article was laid out as if Nooney was telling a tale rather than the history of something. Rhetorically, the photos taken were meaning to introduce a type of game that had never been seen before in a exaggerative way. I found the perspective of the male finding the computer to be a "sexless tool" and the women instructing computer literacy classes to be very interesting and refreshing since I come from a generation where men exploit computers for sexual relief and women tend to stray away from computers.

The question that bothered me was why didn't Anthropy didn't provide a structure to how global game making could be revolutionized so that all genres and interests could be represented. She was incredibly passionate in her argument, yet all she could do was compare her idea to youtube. Much of her article was spent trying to sway the audience from the norm, yet her idea is the video game version of something that already exists.

Reading Response 2- Charlotte DeLay

While Rise of Videogame Zinesters by Anna Anthropy talks about how hard of a time it is for a person with no formal training to produce a game that appeals to a variety of audiences, the other article involving the first pronographic game by Laine Nooney would also bring up controversial themes. Anthropy’s main argument involves how video games are challenged to evolve due to industry and how it keeps a narrow mindset on what would be deemed “game-worthy” and bases these arguments throughout the two chapters assigned. From there, she constructs her argument to mention how she is also a minority and how she has found it wrong that video games aren’t able to stretch its wings to a broader set of audiences. Anthropy also mentions how this is an issue because of the fact that many people are under the misconception that there is no way making video games can become a hobby without prior knowledge to coding. The way that Anthropy structures her argument leads from her own dilemmas involving the expanding game industry to that of how gaming has forced its way into a niche crowd due to its complexity. She sees video games as a potential way to express storytelling and provide outlets similar to that of how Youtube has become to others. Anthropy wanted to have an individual interested in creating a video game to make it a personal experience.

Meanwhile, Nooney’s article over the first pornographic video game sets up an argument discussing the implications of creating a video game that is out of the norm for its time, leading to controversy. Although the game’s actual content was mentioned, what was expressed more was the overall controversy involved a new use of the microcomputer. This argument transformed and developed into something more of a conflict involving certain cultural issues during the time, over that of the game. What allows the two articles to correlate involves the methods from which this pornographic game was produced and how it was developed by someone on their free time. Anthropy might not have agreed with the subject matter, or the fact that it was still under a narrow mindset, however, the fact that it was freely made from a hobby and became a personal experience allows for both articles to connect in some way.

Both Nooney and Anthropy’s works are able to form solid arguments, and in a sense, show how the progress of gaming has developed. Nooney’s article shows the prime basis for the progression of corporations later appealing to a certain audience as to not get lashback from them. Meanwhile, Anthropy shows the negative sides of corporations abiding to a target audience because of the feedback that can arise from something that is deemed unfit for that audience.

Reading Response 2 - Jake Hagan

The article about looking anthropologically at video games and the themes they do/don’t portray is one that intrigues me.  Having taken a anthropology class this previous semester in my first year here, it opened my eyes to a lot of differing viewpoints and angles. One of the things I learned from class though, was that looking at a topic from too many angles could be a bad thing sometimes. While the article itself contains many valid points supporting the argument, I believe it opens up a whole different realm of separate issues that could be argued against video games.
I did however; find what came later, in the same chapter, to be a very valid point about the creating of new video games and how many new findings could be on the horizon for the world of games. This part of the argument provides very strong points that really benefit the argument, such as, “I like the idea of games as zines: as transmissions of ideas and culture from person to person…”
The second article was a change of pace from the first one quite noticeably.  These two articles stacked up against each other provide an interesting chance for debate. I think that is one author was asked about the others article, there might be some tension in the ensuing discussion. I do not believe that Miss Anthropy would be too pleased to hear about the game that our other author, Nooney wrote about. The second article is kind of arguing that people took this game too seriously and said that the games creator even himself said is was a satire and was meant to even be a joke in the first place. I found it intriguing that the game itself wasn’t going to be released until the creator’s friends played the game and told him he should publish it. A lot of uproar about video games might’ve been avoided if it never had been published!

             

Reading Response 2 - Jacob Boudreau

The article about “Softporn” was a fun read. I had no clue there existed a text-based erotic game on a, aptly named, floppy disk. This idea is funny because text-based games are like reading a book. I also thought how funny it was trying to get an ad. The magazine company told them that they did not want the children to be exposed to adult content on the computer, which, in this time, is extremely ironic. This article also went into detail the creation of the cover for the game. The article was really an enjoyable read, a perfect thing to read after the first article.

Games and gaming has been a huge part of my life. I’ve been playing games since the PC was bigger than the microwave and when our mouse had a ball in it. They are just as much a part of my life as art is to an artist, so I will defend this culture that I have been molded by. Anna starts off by saying games are bad. Her reason for this is that there are no games that are tailored to her, that being “a queer transgendered woman in 2012” (Anthropy 7). She argues, from this point, that “Mostly, videogames are about men shooting men in the face. Sometimes they are about women shooting men in the face. Sometimes the men who are shot in the face are orcs, zombies, or monsters”, and that video games don’t have a large enough scope of experiences. Well, yeah. Video games, as much as she tries to make them an art, are a business first. When a game is made it is made for profit, so they are going to try to appeal to the most people, and, most gamers are people, men and women alike, who like those type of games. Why would they produce a game that only applies to a small fraction of gamers? Anna says that games are an art form which doesn’t help her case. If games are an art, then what right does anyone have to determine what others create? She blames the big designers for making the same game type over and over again, but that is what makes money and want to make games that make money. Some creators also like those games and want to make those types of games. This is also why the games she wants are all indie games or self-made games, like her Annie Catastrophe game. Big gamer companies will not pick up the titles because there is no money in them, which is perfectly fine since the number one rule in capitalism is profit. 

Her logic is flawed in the third chapter, and that puts the whole chapter on thin ice. The situation in question is where she re-defines video games. Anyone can form a pretty convincing argument if they change definitions of things. She changes the definition of game for her own argument. This is equivocation and is a logical fallacy. The whole point of an argument is when people argue with the same definitions, that way we are all talking about the same thing. In Anna’s argument, her definition of games is different from everyone else’s. The Merriam-Webster definition HERE is very different than Anna’s. Anna’s definition drops pleasure and replaces it with experience, which, completely changes the definition and why she thinks Gang Rape is a game. When is rape ever a game? It is a serious and tragic event in someone’s life and should not be diminished in seriousness to the level of a game. With that change in definition anything that has rules and gives and experience is a game, even when the experience is bad. This method of arguing her points diminishes other, serious, experiences.


Well that was a long rant about why I disagree with Anna’s proposals. I am not saying that there shouldn’t be games about transgender and other peoples, in fact, I think some of those games would be cool, I am saying that she should not blame gamers for not wanting a game like that and the companies for making the majority what they want, and they want RPG fantasy, FPS, many other acronyms, and a mixture of them. When did the smaller fraction of gamers suddenly dictate what the majority want? I am getting tired of people attacking the gamer culture. In middle school I was made fun of for being a gamer and not playing football, in high school I was made fun of for playing games and not having a girlfriend, despite going to an all boy school, and now, as a college student, my culture is yet again under attack by more people who want everything to change for them. 

Reading Response 2 - Brannon Hamm

Anthropy and Nooney both discuss an aspect of video game culture that has been irrevocably intertwined with its very existence since the creation of the medium: its niche, elitist, socially-eschew nature.  Nooney discusses the social isolation of the game community through an examination of its much more exaggerated past; Anthropy endeavors to criticize the modern state of video game culture on similar grounds. 
I myself see more merit to the discussion that Nooney offers.  He takes a piece of history, a terrible ero-game entitled the oh-so-innovative “Softporn”, and uses its example as an indication of the social history of the game industry.  There are many features of the game that he finds representative: its earnest attempts to entertain; its obvious latent misogyny; its limp, inward humor.  He sees it as symptomatic of a culture that is composed of introverts, a burgeoning culture that reacts negatively to outside interaction and poorly understands society at large.  In short, 80s “gamer” culture—male, outcast, bitter losers.  To be frank, there is a lot of truth in his words. 

Anthropy has a much more nonsensical argument.  She claims that video games in their entirety are made by and are composed of a single worldview—the implication being this worldview is that of a middle-class, socially-awkward, heterosexual, white male.   She then uses this assumption to springboard into her fantasy: that games be created by everyone, for everyone.  In order to claim that this is how it should be, she ignores a very important point: creating video games is hard.  One must learn to code mountains and mountains of data and arrange them in a perfect way.  Much to what I imagine to be the chagrin of Anthropy, this is in fact expert knowledge.  One must train themselves for years before one can perform with competence the tasks necessary for making a good video game that people will want to play.  Moreover, there is nothing in the industry itself that inhibits anyone from pursuing the training necessary to create games—in that way, Anthropy is living in her own paradise and she doesn’t even know it.

Reading Response 2 - Sam McManus

In Fallout: New Vegas, a character tells you “too many people have opinions on things they know nothing about. And the more ignorant they are, the more opinions they have.” Now I’m not saying that these articles are totally ignorant or lack any valid points, but they go about their agenda in the complete wrong way. The article entitled The Problem with Video Games panders to the individual, the minority. I’m not intending to discredit what she has to say, but she doesn’t seem to grasp the idea behind some games, she only comprehends that her distinct needs aren’t being catered to, which upsets her. I understand this, people look for certain qualities in games that seem appealing to them, but to lash out and attack AAA games that have a distinct target demographic for not appealing to someone else is unreasonable. Plus, with the recent explosion of indie games it’s not uncommon to see the more bizarre or risky titles she mentions being put out on the market. There are plenty of people who fall into minority categories that enjoy games for the “straight white male”, and just because an even smaller minority groups doesn’t like the way things are being handled, doesn’t mean they have the right to receive change. Games are difficult to make from scratch, and require hundreds of man hours to create, and even then that doesn’t guarantee anything, so pushing an industry to create products that don’t appeal to a broad audience is irrational.
The second article is much more tolerable to read, although I still find that the way it is written shows ignorance towards the media, due to archaic terminology and examples of video games. The gist of this article is that video games are essentially a more convenient and open ended version of their predecessors. Because games allow the player to complete the task according to the rules, but however they see fit within the games parameters, they achieve the same end goal of regular games, but offer the player more freedom. The nuances of video games are also determinants of player’s skill, as games generally ramp up the difficulty as they progress. This creates a more dynamic experiences not possible on tabletop board games. As a side note, the author’s use of gender specific pronouns as opposed to gender neutral pronouns decreased credibility, and was annoying.

The Odd History of the First Erotic Computer Game is the most interesting article of the bunch mas it presented an unbiased view of the chauvinistic topic. A research article about an erotic (not by todays standards) text based adventure, it was a prime example of word-of-mouth prosperity in the early days of the internet, especially considering the nature of the product. It indirectly had a hand in the expansion of the distribution of games, since adult themed games were not generally permitted to be sold at retail stores. Adult, yet childish in nature, this game based on the exploits of someone just looking for a good time had a much larger impact on the world of games than anyone could have possibly imagined.

reading response 2 - Kevin Feller

            Chapter one really talks about what video games have transformed into today. There is the talk about how it is just about a bunch of men who are shooting each other in the face or monsters in the faces. Video games to me are much more than that. The people that think this is teaching children to steal cars and other sorts of bad habits are wrong. Yes, a small amount of kids do end up doing things such as that but don’t you think that there is more than just video games that are making them do these things?
            Another portion of this chapter talks about how its not “what video games need” its more about what the consumer wants to see in these video games. Video games are a means of entertainment and the ones that are selling the best are the ones about war and shooting. Video games are all in good fun and yes some have a deeper artful meaning while others are just about plain death and destructions. It is all about what you as the consumer thinks in this situation.

            The third chapter brings up the great point about why people who are not true video game designers make games. It is about the means of what people find enjoyable. I love the comparison of the game tag in how one person is it and everyone tries to get away from that certain person. There also is many ways to play this game all around the world. An example that I thought of was sharks vs. Minos. This game can be played just for fun, but also I have seen kids doing this game who are practicing soccer. By just adding a ball to your feet you now have a different form of the game that is actually helping children practice a sport. This shows that it is not bad to change the rules of games or in video games to change the setting or the characters. Yes, there are many games that seem to have to same type of play but it gives you the opportunity to have a different back-story to put your mind on instead of the same old story line.

Reading Response 2 - George Grayson

George Grayson
Professor Evans
Video Games in Art Historical Context
7 January 2015
Reading Response #2
After reading the very descriptive two chapters in “Rise of the Videogame Zinesters” by Anna Anthropy and the interesting content in “The Odd History of the First Erotic Computer Game” by Laine Nooney, I can honestly say that I am stuck in the middle of two very contrasting opinions. In Anthropy’s chapters, it is clear that she feels uncomfortable about video games not representing her lifestyle choices. She goes on about how certain games only portray men killing other men, or men being killed by some other creature, or occasionally women killing men. I think she does make a great point about how video games can turn children into sociopaths, because that is very possible. However, she does not care a great deal about who video games cater to as opposed to what is in the content of certain video games. Anthropy claims that she hates video games because they mostly contain the same material and she feels that games should have a broader spectrum of content. She is trying to represent a population of people like herself that are subjected to playing games that do not represent who they are as a person.

In Nooney’s article, she takes Anthropy’s point in a completely opposite direction.  As Anthropy’s point geared more towards defending women against the prejudice of video games, Nooney introduced a game that objectifies women entirely with what was apparently the first pornographic video game. In a way, I kind of felt sympathetic towards Anthropy after reading Nooney’s article because it goes against everything that Anthropy stood for. This game that Nooney discusses completely tarnishes the idea of feminism, and someone like Anthropy would be very disappointed if the video game industry put more of these games on the market. 

Reading Response 2 - Erin Lupardus



            Laine Nooney's "The Odd History of the First Erotic Computer Game" and Anna Anthropy's "Rise of the Videogame Zinesters" explore the predominantly male-centric nature of mainstream video games.
            I agree with Anthropy that the major gaming companies mainly produce one type of game for one type of audience. However, I don't really see this as a problem. As she points out, there are thousands of independent game developers creating what they want to see created. Steam and online flash game hosting sites allow these new ideas to be distributed and consumed. It is unlikely that mainstream game producers will change their current formula, and why should they? It works and is profitable for them. As long as there are other options for hopeful game developers to distribute their work, there is no sense in trying to change a lucrative, popular system.
            I see Softporn as a fun, creative satire just as Benton originally intended it to be. The "gawkiness" that Nooney describes fits Benton's aim perfectly. Despite the game's provocative cover art, Nooney clarifies that there is no "actual obscenity" in the game, and this is an important detail. It is fascinating that the naked hot tub women on the cover are all company employees. It is possible to argue that this suggestive setting diminishes the women's contributions to the game, but I disagree with that notion. They volunteered to participate in the photo shoot. Posing naked is not inherently sexist or damaging to women. Feeling sexy can be empowering, and pornography does not always degrade women.
            Interactive fiction such as Softporn is usually quite difficult both to play and write. They rely entirely on the author's ability to create a compelling interactive text with enough clues for the player to figure out what to do next. However, the cover art does not explain exactly what kind of "adventure game" it is. Perhaps the lure of an erotic video game was enough to convince people to purchase the game for a whopping $29.95 ($77.81 when accounting for inflation.) I doubt there will ever be a time when sex no longer sells.

Questions: Do you think independent game developers will eventually influence major gaming companies in terms of game content? Is their influence necessary?

Reading Response 2 - Brandon Wright

The readings assigned covered an interesting topic, mainly innovation in the art form of video games. Rise of the Videogame Zinesters covers this topic in an interesting manner, notably calling out the current corporations making videogames on their practice of not innovating nearly enough. While the second article “The Odd History of the First Erotic Computer Game” from The Atlantic looks at the release and design of the first erotic computer game that was commercially sold, along with its back story and a few quotes by the actual designer.

The First Reading Rise of the Videogame Zinesters by Anna Anthropy takes a larger overview of the entire industry and its, in her words, lack of innovation. She makes the declaration that videogames are only created by a small group of people, for their small group of people. The group of people being young, predominantly male, adults. Ms. Anthropy talks about how the larger publishers of games don't wish to truly try to innovate because of the inherent risk in doing so. They innovate as little as possible so that they can squeeze out as much profit as they can. She likens this monopoly of creative power to that of the church and the creation of the printing press. Before the printing press was invented and distributed the only way to get a book was through the monks of the church. Afterward, the dissemination of literature skyrocketed because a larger number of people could write and create books.

The printing press for videogames is actually pretty close to a printing press as well. The original Gutenberg press used a series of blocks for each letter, and then to print you would dip the blocks in ink, set them in the press and then push them onto the vellum/paper to type out the sentences. This didn't require calligraphy lessons, and was less time consuming as well to produce large quantities. For videogames this revolutionary new technology comes in the form of software specifically designed to help design games. Things such as GameMaker and Scratch can let someone with the desire to make a game, but no programming knowledge to make a game. Instead of hand writing a book, they modularly snap together pieces to get the proper end product. Will it look as beautiful as something hand made, either calligraphy or programming? No, but it will be able to get its point across and innovate.

The second article “The Odd History of the First Erotic Computer Game” was much shorter, and lived up to its title, as the history of Softporn, I couldn't believe that was the actual name, is very odd. Softporn was released, in a magazine for $29.95, in 1981 for the Apple II computer. It was contained on a single floppy disk and was entirely Text based. The game was created as a programming exercise by a single person, whose friends told him to try and sell it. Which he did, but had a hard time trying to find companies that would actually sell the game. Until he met the president of On-Line Systems, which would later be renamed Sierra Entertainment most known for the Kings Quest series and the spiritual successor of Softporn, Leisure Suit Larry. On-Line Systems agreed to take on the title, and get it into distribution. In September of 1981 an advertisement for Softporn was ran in the magazine Softalk. This one advertisement started the trend of magazines becoming more accepting of adult-themed software, and thus sparking a large controversy of sex in the sphere of the “Sexless computer”.


These two articles both take a look at innovation and talk about them in slightly differently lights. Anna Anthropy's work speaks of Innovation as something that must happen or the industry will stagnate even more and become more and more exclusive. While the article from The Atlantic didn't view innovation in either a positive or negative light in the industry, but merely stated what happened when a company decided to take a very large risk with the first erotic game and the ensuing controversy.

I found it odd that in Rise of the Videogame Zinesters there is no mention of the smaller programming teams that, while they are technically the same group of young white males in the larger companies, are innovating drastically with games like Dwarf Fortress, Minecraft, and Kingdom of Loathing.