DePauw University | Winter Term 2015 | Prof. Chaz Evans
Showing posts with label Jacob Boudreau. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Jacob Boudreau. Show all posts
Wednesday, January 21, 2015
Friday, January 16, 2015
Thursday, January 15, 2015
Draft Pages - Jacob Boudreau
Wander No More
Killing giant rock colossi,
traversing a vast open world, saving the maiden, it sounds like the stuff that
makes up legends, or gods. In Team Ico’s amazing fantasy video game, Shadow of the Colossus, puts the player
in the shoes of a god. The Shadow of the
Colossus is a fantasy action-adventure game released for the PlayStation 2
in 2005. It is played through third-person-over-the-shoulder perspective with a
changeable camera position. The playing style almost mimics The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time
with the third-person view and a first-person perspective when firing the bow
and arrow. Despite being a game from 2005, the graphics are astonishing and
breath-taking. It really puts the player in the world. The game immerses the
player not only through the graphics but the story itself also draws the player
in. The entire game has a religious undertone that is conveyed through symbols,
allegories, and references to multiple religions the point to player playing
god.
Shadow of the Colossus starts
out with a long cut scene showing Wander, the player, on his horse Argo holding
Mono. Mono was sacrificed by her tribe because it was believed she has a cursed
destiny, so Wander sets out to bring her back from the dead. The entire intro
cut scene is just Wander making his way to the Forbidden Land and into the
Temple of Worship. When he arrives he places Mono on the altar and then a
disembodied voice speaks to him. This is Dormin, the entity that can control
the souls of the dead. Wander tells Dormin that he wants to revive Mono. Dormin
agrees to this, but on one condition. Dormin says that there are sixteen
colossi that roam this land, kill each one and Mono will be brought back from
the dead. After that, the game starts. There is no other intro, no other
characters, it is just Wander, Dormin, and Mono. There is also little to no
dialogue between the characters. The rest of the game is played in silence,
well except for when you call your horse, but other than that there is no more
real dialogue. The game also offers no real tutorials. It does have a short
tutorial on how to swing the sword, attack, jump, stuff like that, but for each
battle against a colossus, there is no information given. Victory comes from a
whole lot of trial and error. This is a gist of the game, however; there is
much more to it than just slaying some colossi.
The Shadow of the Colossus is
filled with religious symbolism, allegories, references, and parallels. There
are so many small symbols in the game in just the beginning cut scene. There is
a temple and an altar, which is a very common in many religious buildings and
holy places. In the beginning there is a parallel to real world religions.
There is also a reference to idols, especially in reference to the Aztec or
other Middle American cultures, through the sixteen stone idols of each
colossi. These references are made in the first few minutes of the game. There
is also the disembodied voice of Dormin that is a direct reference to a god. An
interesting thing about Dormin is that the voice is an overlay of both a male
and female voice actor, according to Team Ico. This gives Dormin a dual nature
on gender and essence. Dormin uses the plural pronouns to describe themselves.
This is almost a direct reference to the Judeo-Christian deity that is both
male and female.
The references do not just stop
there with Dormin. Dormin’s name is a play on words. Dormin backwards is
Nimrod, who happens to be a king in the old testament of the Bible. Nimrod was
no ordinary king. The Bible passage states “He was a mighty hunter before the
Lord: wherefore it is said, Even as Nimrod, the mighty hunter before the lord”
(Genesis 10:9). Here is a direct connection to a religious text, the
Judeo-Christian text to be specific.
Another small symbol found
throughout the game is the weak point of the colossi. The colossi cannot be
killed just by hitting them with a few hundred arrows or slashes from your
sword, they have to the stabbed in a very specific point. This point is marked
by a glowing blue sigil. The image on the last page is the sigil. This sigil is
not just some made up assortment of curves and circles, it comes from Jewish
mysticism. Ciccoricco says the weak spots “are revealed to the in the form of
the sigils, which are derived from Jewish mysticism and the Kabala” (Ciccoricco).
Team Ico could have picked anything to denote these weak points. They could
have used a circle, a small pillar of light, a target, anything, but they chose
a symbol based in religious mysticism. The whole notion of a weak spot is also
a religious or mythological reference to Achilles. Achilles was a Greek hero in
the Trojan War who was immune to damage because of a blessing of the gods. His ankle
was the only par on his body that could be hurt. This is due to his mother
holding his ankle as he was submerged into a river blessed by the gods to give
Achilles immunity to harm. The same goes for the colossi. They cannot be hurt
unless that specific spot is attacked, just like Achilles.
Another reference to Greek
mythology is with Perseus and the Pegasus. Perseus had a trusted Pegasus that
would ride him into battle just as Argo is Wander’s trusted steed. Both animals
would fearlessly ride into battle with their masters. Also, Perseus killed a
giant beast called the Kraken in order to save the city of Argos. Funny how
Wander’s horse is named Argo. There is also a Biblical connection to David.
David, not only was he the King of Judea, but he is also the kid in the tale of
David and Goliath. David, a young man, went up against Goliath, a giant.
Goliath killed many soldiers and was laughing at David, but David killed him.
Wander is just like David. Wander is a young man who is going up against these
giant colossi by himself. There is a parallel here to David of the Bible.
Those relationships help
strengthen the fact that there is a religious undertone to Shadow of the
Colossus.
Wednesday, January 14, 2015
Reading Response 4 - Jacob Boudreau
These
articles focused on the realistic nature of certain video games and the impact
of these realistic games. The two most common game types mentioned were
first-person-shooters and real-time strategy games. I have absolutely no
experience in RTS games, so I will focus on my specialty, FPS games.
Two
articles talked about the military and capitalism in games. Both articles, however,
talked about the military and its part in video games. The main issue was that
the violent FPS’s are a way of prepping people for the military. The article in
Salon talked about the way the military used Doom and Doom II to train Marines.
Charles Krulak, the general in charge of MCMSO said that they “believed that PC-based war games held
great potential for teaching Marines critical decision-making skills”.
Notice how he said that it was the critical decision-making that was being
trained. I’m going to declare that video games and simulations are two entirely
different things. I have played FPS’s since I can remember and played them competitively
in 2008 with Halo 3 and Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 in 2009. Modern Warfare 2 is the more realistic
out of the two, but it is far from a simulation of war. The issues with Modern
Warfare 2, and most call of duty games, is that they are very unrealistic,
despite the graphics. Sure it may look like real war, but it is far from it.
The guns don’t jam, you always reload on the first time, there is no fatigue,
there are no ballistics in COD, the blast radii of explosions are diminished, and
the list goes on. The only thing that is accurate in the Call of Duty is the
military jargon in the campaign. A cool fact that most people don’t know is how
stressful a competitive game can get. If you were to listen in on our team-speak
during a match you would hear what sounds like chaos. Six players
simultaneously shouting out positions, deaths, marked men, help, and more. I
guess that can simulate real-time battle confusion. I think that FPS games are not
being used to train or prepare players for military service, that’s what boot
camp is for.
The excerpt from the book on the game empires
talks about video games and violence. It brings up the Columbine Shooting and
the possibility that violent video games were the reason behind it. I love
video games, especially FPS’s, which, in most cases, are considered violent, so
I will defend them. People seem to think that there is a link between playing
violent video games and becoming violent. I would just like to put a few points
out there. In Call of Duty: Black Ops, as of 2010, 6.9 billion people were
killed. Halo 3’s final stats, here, show that over 136 billion people were
killed. These are just two games, and yet the murder rate has decreased, shown
here. If games had any real effect on the players then would the murder rate go
up, even the slightest. I mean 136 billion people is roughly twenty times the
Earth’s population.
Now what does this have to say about social
realism? I think that just because games look like real life doesn’t mean that
they are realistic or show realism. I think that it is hard to think of
something as real when I am looking at it on a flat screen. One thing that is
an issue is that video games are interactive. When you want to kill someone in
Call of Duty, you have to physically push a button. There is a physical connection,
but it is very different than actually killing someone. To knife someone in
Call of Duty, you, usually, click the right stick in. That is a very different
feeling than actually thrusting a knife into a person. Sure games can get
really close to realistic, but the fact that they are on a screen and the
physical actions do not match up, to me, makes it hard to see the realism in
games.
Sunday, January 11, 2015
Reading Response 3 - Jacob Boudreau
This
was a great read. It is the most academic read that we have done so far. The
premise that Schrank is putting forward is that video games are an art form,
specifically an Avant-garde art. Avant-garde is an experimental or an innovative
way of doing something related to culture. In this case, video games are the
next Avant-grade art.
Schrank
makes some pretty compelling cases for video games being Avant-grade art. The
most compelling case for me was the September
12th game. Schrank compares it to Heavy Weapon: Atomic Tank and how each one, just as art, comments
on a specific point in history. September
12th takes a simple shooter, like Heavy Weapon: Atomic Tank, and critiques America’s war on terror. This
made me really think about my stance. I understood that video games critiqued real-world
events, such as the Grand Theft Auto games, but to pin those games against
another game that doesn’t really do much in the effort of critique is really
compelling. Both games were fun but one was an Avant-garde art. September 12th
actually uses real life consequences for doing certain things. Like how killing
innocents will increase the spite of others. This made me really think about
games and whether they are an art form or not.
With
Schrank’s compelling evidence of Avant-garde art and video games I think that
there is a split in video games. My big counter to Anna Anthropy was that she
changed the definition of the word games for her own argument. She left out
that games are for pleasure, not experience. Schrank does not openly talk about
the nature of games but he does talk about what makes up a game. On page nine,
he uses a chart by Jesper Juul that explains what a game is. I agree with all
of what Juul says makes a game a game, but I do think he left something out. He
left out that a game is played for pleasure. This is where the split is. Games
are for leisure while art is an obligation. Bolter says in the forward that art
is considered a way of cultural enrichment. If video games are art, then why do
some many people say the exact opposite? I cannot tell you the number of times
my mother has told me that video games are destroying my mind. Why do people have
such an opposite view? I think that there is a split in the things we call
games. Schrank uses charts in pages 20, 22, and 25 to show what video games
classify under. In each one he labels the mainstream games, such as Nintendo and
Minecraft. There is a distinct difference between what is considered a game and
what people like Schrank want to be a game. This is where I draw a line,
literally. I think those mainstream games are the only games and avant-grade
games, like September 12th and the others Schrank mentions, are a
new art form. They are not games they are something else. This is not saying
that games cannot be art, it is saying that those games that are considered art
are not games. There is a split and I think it is where pleasure changes to
emotional connection. Games are meant to be played and have fun playing,
despite the profanity being shouted from the patrons. Art is not limited to just
pleasure. A good pieces of art will not only make you feel happy but also sad,
upset, nervous, and everything else.
Video
games are just that, video games. Those that are made for the sake of art are
something else. I suggest that they be called art, because that is what they
are. That game that I played over the weekend, The Entertainment, was not a
game. I felt like it should have been in my American Lit class in high school.
It was just a story being told through the eyes of a bar patron. It was not a
game, but a virtual story.
Wednesday, January 7, 2015
Reading Response 2 - Jacob Boudreau
The
article about “Softporn” was a fun read. I had no clue there existed a
text-based erotic game on a, aptly named, floppy disk. This idea is funny
because text-based games are like reading a book. I also thought how funny it
was trying to get an ad. The magazine company told them that they did not want
the children to be exposed to adult content on the computer, which, in this
time, is extremely ironic. This article also went into detail the creation of
the cover for the game. The article was really an enjoyable read, a perfect
thing to read after the first article.
Games
and gaming has been a huge part of my life. I’ve been playing games since the
PC was bigger than the microwave and when our mouse had a ball in it. They are
just as much a part of my life as art is to an artist, so I will defend this
culture that I have been molded by. Anna starts off by saying games are bad.
Her reason for this is that there are no games that are tailored to her, that
being “a queer transgendered woman in 2012” (Anthropy 7). She argues, from this
point, that “Mostly, videogames are about men shooting men in the face.
Sometimes they are about women shooting men in the face. Sometimes the men who
are shot in the face are orcs, zombies, or monsters”, and that video games don’t
have a large enough scope of experiences. Well, yeah. Video games, as much as
she tries to make them an art, are a business first. When a game is made it is
made for profit, so they are going to try to appeal to the most people, and,
most gamers are people, men and women alike, who like those type of games. Why would they produce a game that only applies to a small
fraction of gamers? Anna says that games are an art form which doesn’t help
her case. If games are an art, then what right does anyone have to determine
what others create? She blames the big designers for making the same game type
over and over again, but that is what makes money and want to make games that make money. Some creators also like those games and want to make those types of games. This is also why the games
she wants are all indie games or self-made games, like her Annie Catastrophe
game. Big gamer companies will not pick up the titles because there is no money
in them, which is perfectly fine since the number one rule in capitalism is profit.
Her
logic is flawed in the third chapter, and that puts the whole chapter on thin
ice. The situation in question is where she re-defines video games. Anyone can
form a pretty convincing argument if they change definitions of things. She
changes the definition of game for her own argument. This is equivocation and
is a logical fallacy. The whole point of an argument is when people argue with
the same definitions, that way we are all talking about the same thing. In Anna’s
argument, her definition of games is different from everyone else’s. The
Merriam-Webster definition HERE is very different than Anna’s. Anna’s definition
drops pleasure and replaces it with experience, which, completely changes the
definition and why she thinks Gang Rape
is a game. When is rape ever a game? It is a serious and tragic event in
someone’s life and should not be diminished in seriousness to the level of a
game. With that change in definition anything that has rules and gives and
experience is a game, even when the experience is bad. This method of arguing
her points diminishes other, serious, experiences.
Well
that was a long rant about why I disagree with Anna’s proposals. I am not
saying that there shouldn’t be games about transgender and other peoples, in
fact, I think some of those games would be cool, I am saying that she should
not blame gamers for not wanting a game like that and the companies for making
the majority what they want, and they want RPG fantasy, FPS, many other acronyms, and a mixture of them. When did the smaller fraction of gamers suddenly dictate what the majority
want? I am getting tired of people attacking the gamer culture. In middle
school I was made fun of for being a gamer and not playing football, in high school
I was made fun of for playing games and not having a girlfriend, despite going
to an all boy school, and now, as a college student, my culture is yet again under
attack by more people who want everything to change for them.
Monday, January 5, 2015
Reading Response 1 - Jacob Boudreau
No doubt that The Legend of Zelda series is an amazing series
for both content and mechanics, but it also has one of the most interesting and
confusing official timelines, which adds to the awesomeness.
The articles are both about The Legend of Zelda: The Ocarina
of Time, but both talk about the title in very different terms.
The first article was written by Peer Schneider, an
employee of IGN. This article had mix content of a traditional game review as
well as some personal experiences of the game. Peer went into in depth detail
about many of the aspects of the game. He talked about the graphics, mechanics,
and story, and in each of these he talks about how different they are from other
games. Super Mario 64, GoldenEye, F-Zero
X, and Banjo-Kazooie are all compared to Ocarina. Peer doesn’t simply talk about
how the game is, he also talks about how it was embraced at IGN. He talks about
seven-teen hour gaming sessions and their jaws dropping to the floor. It is a
typical review article with a small twist.
The second article, written by L. B. Jeffries, takes a
different path from the first. This is more of an essay than the first, but it
is still an article in KillScreen issue 0. This article talked about the idea
of maturity and how age played a major role throughout the game. I myself have
never played Ocarina of Time due to my grandmother running over my Nintendo 64
power cable with the vacuum and my parents not wanting to spend the money on
another one. Despite that, I still know of the game, and this article painted
it in a new light. I would have never seen the phallic nature of Ganon’s tail
and how the final battle is a battle of masculinity. This article brought about
new thoughts to an old game.
My one question is why did Jeffries not include all of
the controversy that came along with Ocarina? Despite the game being a
masterpiece, there was a lot of controversy about how the game used Islamic
symbols and songs in an insensitive way. One of the biggest issues is about the
chanting in the Fire Temple. The chanting comes from the holy song Adhan, or
the call to prayer. By using the song in this way, the song is being disgraced.
Gaijin Goombah explains the issue in detail in this video (2:30). For such a big game,
I do wonder why neither author talked about the controversies involved with the
game.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)