Majora's Mask
DePauw University | Winter Term 2015 | Prof. Chaz Evans
Showing posts with label Brannon Hamm. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Brannon Hamm. Show all posts
Thursday, January 22, 2015
Thursday, January 15, 2015
Draft Pages - Brannon Hamm
Brannon Hamm
Professor Evans
Video Games in Relation to Art History
15 January, 2015
Draft Pages
Audience: The audience of my paper is
basically anyone that is interested in video games and in what ways they are
artistically distinct from other media.
There won’t be too much jargon or confusing wording; my goal is for my
paper to be understandable to anyone who wants to understand it.
Functions of critical writing: With my paper I will endeavor to do the
following: show relations between works of different ages, give a reading of Majora’s Mask, and throw light upon the
relation between art and life.
Thesis: Majora’s Mask succeeds in depicting the fluid nature of time in
ways that previous forms of media could only dream of because of its inherent
nature as a video game.
Outline:
1.
Introduction/framework
a.
Description of Majora’s Mask, including plot/mechanics
and specific gameplay points that I wish to discuss.
i.
Restarting the 3 day
cycle.
1.
Choosing when to do
so.
ii.
Slowing down time.
1.
Speeding up time.
2.
Relation of MM to other
works
a.
Works of Salvadore Dali—how
MM succeeds compared to Persistence of
Memory
b.
Memento—how Nolan endeavors to
use the medium itself to mess with audience perception of time.
c.
The Sound and the Fury—how Faulkner
used jittery prose in an effort to temporally disconcert the reader.
3.
Drawing conclusions
a.
MM creates a feeling in
the participant that they have truly experienced the nonlinear nature of time
because of its vicarious nature. Support
Interpretation: My
interpretation of the inherent artistic worth of MM isn’t as relevant as my
evaluation of it in a meta context, for it is its meta nature as a game that is
the foundation of my point. What the
game is trying to convey can be discussed and might even help build the point,
but it will not be central. Centrality
belongs to its unique status as a game in the art world, and how that status
allows it to convey an age-old message in a new and possibly superior way.
Analysis: Using Galloway’s work on
the nature of video game realism, I will show that the attitudes and ideas of
the people playing the game can cause a game to be “realist”, at least relative
to them themselves. This means that it
reflects their lives in a meaningful way, and can perhaps change their
perceptions, because of its nature as a participatory, choice-based experience. This will lead into a discussion of how
vanilla western perceptions of time would be challenged by Majora’s Mask in an
active way, creating discomfiture and ultimately epiphany in its participants—a
feature that the comparative pieces lack.
One comparison: Memento and Majora’s Mask. The two works
are similar in that they both endeavor to use the conventions of the genre to
skew the audience’s perception of linear time.
Memento uses a narrative
technique that places the individual “segments” of the movie in reverse order;
while everything happening on screen is moving chronologically forward, every
time the protagonist goes to bed the story picks up the morning of the day
before. The movie begins with the last day. It is in some ways inferior to MM in that the medium mechanics that
exist for MM are inherently much more
potent. Because of its nature as a game,
it allows for the choices of time manipulation to be placed in the player’s
hands. If the cycle restarts, or time
slows to a crawl, it is because of the player’s doing—because of this, they can
eventually “figure it out” and use it to their advantage, eventually arriving
at a greater understanding than can be achieved through Memento.
Reading Response - Brannon Hamm
It is a depressing topic to examine the effects of video
games on the real world. For many, they
represent an escape—an area in which one need not concern oneself with the dull
banalities and, often, the macabre truths of reality. But it would be naïve to assume that games
are created in a vacuum, and in that way it is intuitively obvious that the
social context of video games be acknowledged and even studied.
Mead’s article is mostly a history; a description of the
inception of video games in the belly of the military-industrial complex. In that way there is little to say about
it. Matters of simple history bear
little in the way of discussion.
Galloway, however, founded his writing on a more interesting, if morbid
premise. He proposed the idea that video
games are blessed and cursed with another level of realism than other forms of
art—while other works are restricted to realism of narrative and imagery, video
games also depict realism of choice, a realism that relies on participant
interaction moreso than any other kind.
It is because of this “realism of choice” that Galloway believes gamers
are perhaps more affected by their preferred art than any art consumers of the
past. Video game realism can project
ideas onto actual reality better than any other medium because the fundamental
reality of consumer choice remains intact.
Galloway’s ideation is referenced obliquely in the work of Dyer-Witheford,
Nick, de Peuter, and Greig on video games and global hypercapitalism. Central to their musings is the idea that
video games are the “paradigmatic” art expression of economic empire—an idea
that is inherently nonsensical without an acknowledgment that video games
undoubtedly have various effects on their political and social climate. On a brighter note, they also suggest that
video games are simultaneously the best artistic vehicle for criticism of that
selfsame system.
Monday, January 12, 2015
Reading Response 3 - Brannon Hamm
The expansion of the avant-garde video game has, according to
Schrank, pushed the limits of what video games can do. His definition of “avant-garde” is one that I
found very illuminating—I like the idea that the term “avant-garde” is merely a
descriptor applied to games that violate the understood contract between the
game creator and the game enjoyer. In
that sense there are many games that I myself have played (and enjoyed!) that
could be considered avant-garde. This is
surprising to me because the label has always been one of derogatory artistic
elitism as I have known it, and the idea that it has merit as a descriptor with
no implication toward a game’s artistic value is interesting to me.
Dark Souls is
exemplary of the phenomenon I describe; it is not political or self-indulgent,
so when I played it I didn’t think of it as avant-garde. But it artistically violates the
creator-player contract in interesting and innovative ways, and in that way it
falls within Schrank’s paradigm. It
doesn’t give the player direction, it gives the player tools; if the player can
figure out the story and finish the game, good for them. It makes discovering the fact of the game’s
story a part of the game itself, thereby pressing the bounds of what video
games are.
It’s always interesting to me when the ideas I previously
held about a given word are challenged.
I believe in the inherent value of all words, and to be frank the
definition that I understood avant-garde to possess dissatisfied me. I’m happy to attribute Schrank’s definition
to it because it now can take an interesting place in any art-critic’s lexicon,
as opposed to being merely a tool used to put down works for being perceived to
be too self-indulgent.
Wednesday, January 7, 2015
Reading Response 2 - Brannon Hamm
Anthropy and Nooney both discuss an aspect of video game
culture that has been irrevocably intertwined with its very existence since the
creation of the medium: its niche, elitist, socially-eschew nature. Nooney discusses the social isolation of the
game community through an examination of its much more exaggerated past;
Anthropy endeavors to criticize the modern state of video game culture on
similar grounds.
I myself see more merit to the discussion that Nooney
offers. He takes a piece of history, a
terrible ero-game entitled the oh-so-innovative “Softporn”, and uses its example as an indication of the social
history of the game industry. There are
many features of the game that he finds representative: its earnest attempts to
entertain; its obvious latent misogyny; its limp, inward humor. He sees it as symptomatic of a culture that
is composed of introverts, a burgeoning culture that reacts negatively to
outside interaction and poorly understands society at large. In short, 80s “gamer” culture—male, outcast,
bitter losers. To be frank, there is a
lot of truth in his words.
Anthropy has a much more nonsensical argument. She claims that video games in their entirety
are made by and are composed of a single worldview—the implication being this
worldview is that of a middle-class, socially-awkward, heterosexual, white
male. She then uses this assumption to
springboard into her fantasy: that games be created by everyone, for
everyone. In order to claim that this is
how it should be, she ignores a very important point: creating video games is
hard. One must learn to code mountains
and mountains of data and arrange them in a perfect way. Much to what I imagine to be the chagrin of
Anthropy, this is in fact expert knowledge.
One must train themselves for years before one can perform with
competence the tasks necessary for making a good video game that people will
want to play. Moreover, there is nothing
in the industry itself that inhibits anyone from pursuing the training
necessary to create games—in that way, Anthropy is living in her own paradise
and she doesn’t even know it.
Tuesday, January 6, 2015
Reading Response 1 - Brannon Hamm
Both IGN and KillScreen touch on a systematic theme in their
respective discussions of 1998’s eminent video game, The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time—but only when viewed in the
meta context of a modern-day analyst returning to their aged work. Their childlike wonder at mechanics that
would be deemed simple by today’s standards reveal the source of what some call
“nostalgia goggles”. The game was
released when the medium was new and revolutionary, when creative minds had
free reign with burgeoning technology to innovate and astound with immediately
recognizable leaps and bounds in video game presentation. In short, the nature of the young genre of
video games lead to a fast-paced, rapidly-improving reality that even a layman
could appreciate and be shocked by.
This had widespread effects, especially on the generation
that was adolescent at the time. They
came of age in a world where artificial realities were interactive in a way
that previous generation could never have imagined. Where their parents made do with literature
or film, the generation of Zelda
shaped and earned their own fantasies using nothing but a gamepad. In the years since 1998 gamers have become
accustomed to realistic simulations of wildlife and picture-perfect textures
with ridiculously detailed tessellation, but when OoT was released, the
addition of an intricate fishing minigame was enough to warrant mention in an
IGN review. The ability to ride a horse
boggled the minds of professional video game critics. A deep, meaningful story rocked the video
game world, and “set a new standard”.
In short, OoT represents the pinnacle of an era where many
professed “gamers” thought anything was possible. It signifies a mythical time that many long
for to this day, when technology promised a world that was perhaps better than
our own; if not as detailed, then at least more rewarding.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)