Monday, January 5, 2015

Reading Response 1 - Brandon Wright

Both of the articles for the reading were reviews of “The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time”. One article was from IGN.com written by Peer Schneider, and the other from Kill Screen Magazine by L.B. Jeffries and even though they were reviewing the same exact game, they took completely different looks at the game.

The article in IGN was the stereotypical game review with critiques of the graphical capabilities of the game, the smoothness of the game play, the inventiveness of new mechanics, etc. Although I wouldn't necessarily call it a critique of anything. It almost seemed as if IGN was attempting to write an advertisement for the game. There was almost nothing negative said about the game in the entire review. It could do no wrong in the eyes of Mr. Schneider, or if there was a flaw it was a “little flaw” or “annoying”. For all I know, however, IGN is right. I have never played Ocarina of Time but from a readers standpoint that would be thinking of buying the game, I would be slightly perturbed by the amount of praise and lack of criticism. The author does openly state “I have to confess that I'm a long time fan of the Zelda series.”

On the other hand there is Kill Screen, “Childish Ambitions” (The Articles actual title) is not a standard game review, it really isn't one. It is an interpretation of the events of the game to show a narrative of “The Journey to maturity – and back” as the article is sub-titled. However, without an understanding of the Ocarina of Time before reading this article, many of the events and scenes that the article mentions is unknown. I don't know how accurately Mr. Jeffries is portraying the scenes mentioned but his connection of maturity and the weapons used by young Link and old Link, and the Items you gain access to when aged is an interesting mechanic in the game. It is similar to a leveling system or a progression lock on items but makes the player feel much more accomplished in earning the ability to use the item than just “You are level 4 now, you may use this item.”

Kill Screen and IGN both take a look at the Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time, but Kill Screen ultimately ends up just doing better, even from my ignorant perspective. Kill Screen really fleshed out the underlying themes of the game and even showed some of the mechanics present, such as the item progression after aging 7 years. IGN was just TOO overtly positive and came across as sounding like obsessive fans attempting to sway a new customer to buy their favorite game.

No comments:

Post a Comment