Friday, January 9, 2015

Reading Response 3 - Brandon Wright

In Avant-Garde Videogames: Playing with Technoculture Brian Schrank makes the argument that videogames are not just art, but there are multiple avant-garde movements in this medium that challenge the status quo and sometimes even the definition of the medium itself.

To start off though, Mr. Schrank talks about the avant-garde he says it isn't “about negation, and presumably, the more critical and offensive it is, the better, or at least the more avant-garde.”He quotes Hal Foster disputing “... the assumption that “one theory can comprehend the avant-garde.” Schrank continues on to talk about classifications of avant-garde strategies and even includes a very nice graph with some big names that people know of to give them frameworks of where something might lie on the graph. These strategies are formal, and political which he sub divides into radical and complicit. This results in a square graph not unlike a Dungeons and Dragons alignment chart.

In the illustration provided by Schrank, Political is the left wall of a square, Radical the top, Complicit the bottom, and Formal the right, with a portion of the bottom right corner shaded in and labeled “Mainstream” and therefore not avant-garde this includes things like EVE Online, Nintendo and Jesper Juul.

According to Schrank, formal avant-garde games “manifest the irreducibility of play that lives beyond the familiar flow.” they challenge conventional goals and game play through a raw, more essential experience. However Schrank warns that some enthusiasts think that the player has to be able to read intentions or the artists expression in the work but argues “Perhaps the more that formal games are able to “speak” for themselves, the more provocative the experiences of playing them can be.”


The other “form” of avant-garde, Political, is more denial based. Schrank even says “Historically, political avant-garde artists played with the category of art itself, frequently denying that the work they were making could even be categorized as art” and even talks about game artists that don't claim their work is a game.

After explaining the type of avant-garde and their subdivisions and showing where larger names in the artistic fields would lie on Schranks graph I was honestly put off by his placement of Minecraft, I may be biased towards the game itself as I was a backer of the game during its beta development, but I saw it as being at least defined as somewhat avant-garde. During a craze of pushing games into photorealism, Minecraft was released that challenged goal oriented gameplay and photorealism. Instead it decided to drop you into a world with only a few tooltips on how to do things, and then told you to do whatever you wanted. And at the same time represented it in a pixelated form quite the opposite from the current craze.

No comments:

Post a Comment