Sunday, January 11, 2015

Reading Response 3 - Jake Hagan

The piece by Brian Schrank is one that caused me to start asking many questions about what video games actually are and the way we view them. One of the first pieces of the text that sparked this influx of queries in my mind was on page eight after Schrank had just finished talking about the Pollock paintings and Alberti, Denis, and LeWitt. The question that really got me thinking was, “Are paintings illusions, materials, concepts, or something else still?” One question I asked was: Who is to say that all of these characteristics cannot describe what a painting is? I believe that the piece almost seems to try and confine the boundaries of what this art of video games can be. Why is it necessary to try and put a cap on what exactly “games” are? In my mind, it is not necessary. In order for new “avant-garde” games to be created, there needs to be no limit on what defines a game. This could only cause harm to the art form that is games that many have come to enjoy.

 It is easy to see that there is not one single form of “video game” out in the world today. This provides a pathway to the possibility of a greater variety of games that gamers can choose from. The model also located on page eight is one that could cause a little bit of a stir though. The model incorrectly eliminates many different forms of games/video games that do not follow the six guidelines that define a game that Juul’s model depicts. I am not disputing that her six characteristics in fact do not follow what a game is, rather that she is not leaving much room for the different types in the world. In all honesty, I do not see why it is even needed in the first place that people try and argue about what defines a game and what does not. In the end, what does it matter what exactly we call the game (or “not game”)? Personally, if people enjoy interacting with the media then I do not feel it necessary to go any further than that. Who cares then at that point whether it is considered a game or not? It is not like we see Pollock, DaVinci, or Dali disputing what exactly their art is; all they know is that they enjoyed interacting with the medium they chose to work with.

No comments:

Post a Comment