Monday, January 5, 2015

Reading Response 1 - Charlotte DeLay

Both the IGN review and Kill Screen’s article for The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time are able to provide insight about the franchise as a whole. Although one talks more about the surface of the game and its gameplay, the other takes a deeper approach to truly analyze the narrative that the game’s story weaves. Their main arguments are both trying to analyze the integrity of the game and how it has been different from that of others in the Legend of Zelda franchise. However, it must be noted that both articles are highly opinionated and praise Ocarina of Time because of its difference from other Zelda games.

IGN and Kill Screen are essentially complimenting the same core parts of the game to support their arguments, but what differs is the depth of the analysis of these core aspects. The IGN review is simply gliding over the surface of the Ocarina of Time to give players a brief preview of the game, while Kill Screen decides to talk about how the game immerses the player in order to live through the journey of adulthood by playing as Link. By taking certain sections of the narrative to analyze, Kill Screen is able to create a coherent and meaningful piece than that of IGN. IGN on the other hand, is able to review Ocarina of Time in such a way that not only shows the positive and awe-struck position they have, but also allows them to sell Ocarina of Time. Kill Screen expects its readers to know about Ocarina of Time to a certain extent, while IGN simply nods to those that have, but introduces the game to an audience that hasn’t heard much about it. IGN’s positive feedback allow readers to believe that Ocarina of Time is worth the score that is received at the end of the review because of how much the reviewer builds upon his own excitement for the game.

However, both the arguments from IGN and from Kill Screen are flawed in certain aspects. Kill Screen expects readers to already know much about Ocarina of Time and the Legend of Zelda franchise. It is able to summarize certain points of the narrative for first-timers to understand the story of Ocarina of Time, but fails to explain properly how it “comes closest to making Link a dynamic character” compared with that of other Zelda games. Kill Screen assumes that readers have played other Legend of Zelda games in order to validate its claim. In order to properly prove its positive opinion, Kill Screen should compare other Legend of Zelda games to show how undeveloped of a character Link is. Not only would this amplify Kill Screen’s assertion, but also boost its opinion on why Ocarina of Time is able to  break out of the mold from other Zelda games.

As for IGN, its flaw is the sheer amount of positive opinions that it projects from its review of Ocarina of Time. It doesn’t allow for many negative comments, and tries to convey the overall enjoyment that the reviewer had, rather than what flaws might be present in the game itself. If the reviewer was able to take away this bias, his review would be more balanced. As a way to still show the uniqueness of Ocarina of Time, IGN could have been able to have a personal thoughts section so the other sections weren’t overloaded with bias. This way, those sections could be more fleshed out while still being able to have the reviewer portray his own opinion on Ocarina of Time.

No comments:

Post a Comment