Tuesday, January 6, 2015

Reading Response 1 - Erin Lupardus



            Although I personally have never played any of the Legend of Zelda franchise, after reading both articles, I better understand the importance of the series and how revolutionary Ocarina of Time truly was in multiple aspects. Peer Schneider of IGN approaches the game from a typical review standpoint, breaking down the game's accomplishments in gameplay, data management, graphics, sound, and replay value. However, his review includes his own emotions playing the game for the first time; his preconception of the game's excellence before even playing could be considered a bias, but it reflects the franchise's overwhelmingly positive acclaim. L.B. Jeffries of Kill Screen focuses specifically on Link's character development and the game's theme of maturity. According to Jeffries, the game demonstrates that "Maturity is not just about being older and bigger, and only by learning to appreciate being Young Link, to appreciate your past and your youth, do you finally attain this status."
            Both authors explore the game's soundtrack. Schneider praises the game's marvelous soundtrack, but seems overly preoccupied with Koji Kondo's decision not to include the "legendary" Zelda Overworld theme. If the gameplay is as revolutionary as Schneider claims it to be, why must the music be restrained by previous musical ideas? Abandoning dated tunes does not condemn the game at all--rather, new music reinforces the game's definition of maturity. Jeffries emphasizes the effect of the changing ocarina melodies based on Link's age, and this design is incredibly subtle yet significant. He also discusses the disparities between Link's weapons as a child and adult, but because the Ocarina is unchanging throughout time, the different melodies highlight Link's maturing mind--he is the sole creator of these melodies from his own imagination. However, Schneider points out that the game does feature old favorites such as the Adagio in Kakariko town. Kondo's choice to incorporate familiar tunes proves Sheik's comment that “A thing that doesn’t change with time is a memory of younger days.” Link grows older, wiser, and stronger, but childish imaginativeness and pluck will always live within him.

Questions: How important is music to the overall impact and experience of a game? Can music history and art history fit in the same category?

No comments:

Post a Comment