Sunday, January 11, 2015

Reading Response 3 - Jacob Boudreau

This was a great read. It is the most academic read that we have done so far. The premise that Schrank is putting forward is that video games are an art form, specifically an Avant-garde art. Avant-garde is an experimental or an innovative way of doing something related to culture. In this case, video games are the next Avant-grade art.

Schrank makes some pretty compelling cases for video games being Avant-grade art. The most compelling case for me was the September 12th game. Schrank compares it to Heavy Weapon: Atomic Tank and how each one, just as art, comments on a specific point in history. September 12th takes a simple shooter, like Heavy Weapon: Atomic Tank, and critiques America’s war on terror. This made me really think about my stance. I understood that video games critiqued real-world events, such as the Grand Theft Auto games, but to pin those games against another game that doesn’t really do much in the effort of critique is really compelling. Both games were fun but one was an Avant-garde art. September 12th actually uses real life consequences for doing certain things. Like how killing innocents will increase the spite of others. This made me really think about games and whether they are an art form or not.

With Schrank’s compelling evidence of Avant-garde art and video games I think that there is a split in video games. My big counter to Anna Anthropy was that she changed the definition of the word games for her own argument. She left out that games are for pleasure, not experience. Schrank does not openly talk about the nature of games but he does talk about what makes up a game. On page nine, he uses a chart by Jesper Juul that explains what a game is. I agree with all of what Juul says makes a game a game, but I do think he left something out. He left out that a game is played for pleasure. This is where the split is. Games are for leisure while art is an obligation. Bolter says in the forward that art is considered a way of cultural enrichment. If video games are art, then why do some many people say the exact opposite? I cannot tell you the number of times my mother has told me that video games are destroying my mind. Why do people have such an opposite view? I think that there is a split in the things we call games. Schrank uses charts in pages 20, 22, and 25 to show what video games classify under. In each one he labels the mainstream games, such as Nintendo and Minecraft. There is a distinct difference between what is considered a game and what people like Schrank want to be a game. This is where I draw a line, literally. I think those mainstream games are the only games and avant-grade games, like September 12th and the others Schrank mentions, are a new art form. They are not games they are something else. This is not saying that games cannot be art, it is saying that those games that are considered art are not games. There is a split and I think it is where pleasure changes to emotional connection. Games are meant to be played and have fun playing, despite the profanity being shouted from the patrons. Art is not limited to just pleasure. A good pieces of art will not only make you feel happy but also sad, upset, nervous, and everything else.


Video games are just that, video games. Those that are made for the sake of art are something else. I suggest that they be called art, because that is what they are. That game that I played over the weekend, The Entertainment, was not a game. I felt like it should have been in my American Lit class in high school. It was just a story being told through the eyes of a bar patron. It was not a game, but a virtual story. 

No comments:

Post a Comment