Sunday, January 11, 2015

Reading Response 3 - Sam McManus

Video games as art has been a matter of debate for some time now, with many well established critics both siding for and against the notion. Even some of my friends have had input on the matter, although most agree that video games are not yet an art form. The first article, Playing with Technoculture plays with the idea of video games being a sort of avant-garde art form, something that is new and not yet established, and therefore not widely recognized. To argue this point, author Brian Shrank looks at the subcultures that form around and inside video games, much as previous art forms had their own unique subcultures. Because video games have matured along a similar path as other art styles, and the idea of elite and popular cultures have all but completely fused, it’s hard to distinguish between what can and cannot be classified as art.  Being relatively new to the art scene, only time will tell if video games will eventually be allowed into the exclusive club of art.

The second article, aptly titled A Short Guide to Writing about Art by Sylvan Barnet, is a guide to writing academically about art. Because we have not yet defined video games as art, this is more of a preemptive piece if deciding to write about video games as an art form. It makes itself absolutely clear that when writing about art, there really can’t be one concrete analysis, and it is up to interpretation, “which merely represents an opinion” (Barnet 13). It continues to assess how art is to be analyzed; much like literature, art must be scrutinized, paid close attention to, and be observed from multiple angles, and why it creates meaning within itself. Techniques used are essential in determining the artistic nature of the piece, and how it conveys itself and its style. Much like art, video games possess characteristics that set them apart from each other, even if they appear to be similar at face value.

No comments:

Post a Comment