Wednesday, January 7, 2015

Reading Response 2 - Jacob Boudreau

The article about “Softporn” was a fun read. I had no clue there existed a text-based erotic game on a, aptly named, floppy disk. This idea is funny because text-based games are like reading a book. I also thought how funny it was trying to get an ad. The magazine company told them that they did not want the children to be exposed to adult content on the computer, which, in this time, is extremely ironic. This article also went into detail the creation of the cover for the game. The article was really an enjoyable read, a perfect thing to read after the first article.

Games and gaming has been a huge part of my life. I’ve been playing games since the PC was bigger than the microwave and when our mouse had a ball in it. They are just as much a part of my life as art is to an artist, so I will defend this culture that I have been molded by. Anna starts off by saying games are bad. Her reason for this is that there are no games that are tailored to her, that being “a queer transgendered woman in 2012” (Anthropy 7). She argues, from this point, that “Mostly, videogames are about men shooting men in the face. Sometimes they are about women shooting men in the face. Sometimes the men who are shot in the face are orcs, zombies, or monsters”, and that video games don’t have a large enough scope of experiences. Well, yeah. Video games, as much as she tries to make them an art, are a business first. When a game is made it is made for profit, so they are going to try to appeal to the most people, and, most gamers are people, men and women alike, who like those type of games. Why would they produce a game that only applies to a small fraction of gamers? Anna says that games are an art form which doesn’t help her case. If games are an art, then what right does anyone have to determine what others create? She blames the big designers for making the same game type over and over again, but that is what makes money and want to make games that make money. Some creators also like those games and want to make those types of games. This is also why the games she wants are all indie games or self-made games, like her Annie Catastrophe game. Big gamer companies will not pick up the titles because there is no money in them, which is perfectly fine since the number one rule in capitalism is profit. 

Her logic is flawed in the third chapter, and that puts the whole chapter on thin ice. The situation in question is where she re-defines video games. Anyone can form a pretty convincing argument if they change definitions of things. She changes the definition of game for her own argument. This is equivocation and is a logical fallacy. The whole point of an argument is when people argue with the same definitions, that way we are all talking about the same thing. In Anna’s argument, her definition of games is different from everyone else’s. The Merriam-Webster definition HERE is very different than Anna’s. Anna’s definition drops pleasure and replaces it with experience, which, completely changes the definition and why she thinks Gang Rape is a game. When is rape ever a game? It is a serious and tragic event in someone’s life and should not be diminished in seriousness to the level of a game. With that change in definition anything that has rules and gives and experience is a game, even when the experience is bad. This method of arguing her points diminishes other, serious, experiences.


Well that was a long rant about why I disagree with Anna’s proposals. I am not saying that there shouldn’t be games about transgender and other peoples, in fact, I think some of those games would be cool, I am saying that she should not blame gamers for not wanting a game like that and the companies for making the majority what they want, and they want RPG fantasy, FPS, many other acronyms, and a mixture of them. When did the smaller fraction of gamers suddenly dictate what the majority want? I am getting tired of people attacking the gamer culture. In middle school I was made fun of for being a gamer and not playing football, in high school I was made fun of for playing games and not having a girlfriend, despite going to an all boy school, and now, as a college student, my culture is yet again under attack by more people who want everything to change for them. 

No comments:

Post a Comment