Showing posts with label Charlotte DeLay. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Charlotte DeLay. Show all posts

Friday, January 16, 2015

Game Presentation- Charlotte DeLay

https://drive.google.com/a/depauw.edu/file/d/0B8So5cwC4ZLGbG5rb1FIcl9qWTA/view?usp=sharing

Thursday, January 15, 2015

Draft Pages - Charlotte DeLay

Bioshock and Amnesia: A Machine for Pigs
Compare:
-        -  Views on society (Destructive, Self-Creating = Destruction)
-         - Rapture and The Machine
-         - Who’s the monster?
-         - Playing God
      - Jack’s and Oswald’s Journey (Also going to be a part of the contrast)
Contrast:
-          - Gameplay
-         -  Implications of technology of both societies
-          - Time-period (How it views mankind during the current standing)
-          - Jack’s and Oswald’s Journey (How Jack didn’t create the actual downfall of Rapture, unlike Oswald who did, creating a different final meaning)
References:
-          - Animal Farm
-         -  Frankenstein
-          - Atlas Shrugged
-          - Fritz Lang’s Metropolis (1927)
Outline:
Thesis- When comparing both Bioshock and Amnesia: A Machine for Pigs, a common link is found on how both games interpret mankind.
1st paragraph (Introduction): Talk about both games and what they are. Summarize the story and introduce the characters. Mention the environments and how both show a type of dystopian atmosphere. Talk about the types of comparisons necessary as well as the contrasts listed above. Then present the thesis.
2nd paragraph (Body): Talk about 1st comparison (Views on society). Talk about the environments as a part of this comparison. Use a pic of either a destroyed Rapture, Journal Entry from Oswald, or a screenshot of some part of Machine for Pigs (possibly the part where the manpigs are released onto the city). Finish off with a segway on how this can further expand into comparing Rapture and the Machine.
3rd paragraph (Body): Talk about Rapture and the Machine and how they compare in creation. Talk about how they are characters in and of themselves and are able to also portray a message over society. Talk about Ryan’s fallen dream (dream was about creation and achieving something that couldn’t be created with the means from other countries) and how this provides a similar message from that of the machine. Oswald created the machine for trying to better society, much like Ryan created Rapture for wanting to create his own better society.
4th paragraph (Body): Talk about the creations that both the Machine and Rapture harbor. Show a picture of both (or one) to help illustrate what they look like for analysis. Talk about the grotesque nature on how they look and what they are, but then mention how it could still be possible for the player to look just as bad. Oswald and Jack’s faces are never shown due to the fps style. Use this to help illustrate that this can be a mechanic to show that you could also be playing as a monster. In the case of Jack, he was trained to be a monster by Atlas (Fontaine) and kill his father, Andrew Ryan…although the choice to change yourself from being a monster is up to the player due to the karma system, the intention of the player playing as the monster is still present. As for Oswald, he would be looked at as a monster because of his actions in creating the machine and the actions he would take in making the actual monsters. Many of these people that were turned were homeless people under the notion that they would actually be helped. They had no idea that what would befall them is turning into an experiment where their DNA would fuse with machinery and a pig’s body, only to be taken to a cage and treated like an animal.
5th paragraph (Body): Use that tidbit of information to go into how playing god is what led to the destruction of the society in the first place. In the case of Oswald, it was from creating the manpigs and the machine. By offering a part of his soul to create something god-like, it ultimately created something that would have created the downfall of society. Talk about Bioshock by showing the intentions that Ryan had with the city: Letting scientists run free and create what they want. This ultimately led to creations like Adam and Eve where people were altered. This alteration started the downfall of those who became drug addicts and ultimately becoming splicers. Talk about how splicers were one of the ways that Rapture was thrown into the state that it’s in. This shows how playing god can cause destruction.
6th paragraph (Body): Both Jack and Oswald’s journeys are similar in that they both go through a dystopian society. In the case of Oswald, it involves the machine and the London streets, for Jack, its Rapture. For both Jack and Oswald, they must overcome these dystopian worlds and see how it had come to such a state.
7th paragraph (Body): Gameplay is very different from both games. While Amnesia is more of a puzzle, horror game, Bioshock is a first person shooter- adventure game. Even though both have some horror elements, Bioshock leaves this element rather quickly to go for a more action-based style of gameplay. With this mechanic present, the style of presenting the story also changes. Talk about how this is so into greater depth. Mention the importance of this difference because it shows a different overall meaning that is given from both games. Although both display the same view of mankind, the meanings differ on what can be done with that view.
8th paragraph (Body): The implications of both technologies are different from the two different games because of the society that they are in. This can also relate to the time period because of the viewpoints that others would have on technology for that. For Amnesia, London’s industrialization and the implications that had come during the time of its corporate gain gave it a bad reputation for factories and such. Meanwhile, Rapture was trying to escape and expand on technology without the political issues that were going on in the rest of the world. Because of the time period, many people were touchy on expanding on certain types of technology, like what would later be developed in Rapture. As for Amnesia, because of the rapid movement for technology, it also caused issues because of how expanding throughout the world would cause negative outcomes (talk about machine claiming to be the city during a part of the game). This is trying to show the negative implications that industrialization was having on the masses. What the cost was for such an industrialized nation.
9th paragraph (Body): Going back to Jack and Oswald’s journey. Mention as a segway that it is from Oswald’s creation of the machine that would illustrate the same type of issues going on industrialization. Then mention the journey again and say how this causes a difference in relation to Jack’s journey. Because of the fact that Oswald created the Machine, it implies a different type of meaning for the player to gain from playing the game. As the creator, he has more responsibility. Compare him to someone like Andrew Ryan that had the same goal in mind of the creation of Rapture. Mention how Jack never created Rapture and how because of this, there is also a different meaning to be gained from the story. Because of the fact that Jack was simply fighting his way through Rapture and not having to deal with any of the implications from the creation of it, he has less of a burden than that of Oswald in that sense.
10th paragraph (Body): After all is said and done about comparing and contrasting Bioshock with Machine for Pigs, go on to talk about other forms where messages have been similar. Talk about Animal Farm, Frankenstein, Atlas Shrugged, and Metropolis and describe what each of their meanings were. Use these meanings to tie into how they relate to the analysis.

11th paragraph (Conclusion): Go on to reiterate how the comparisons are strengthened when looking at what is contrasting. Mention how those elements are very present in both and how through this, the claim that was made through the thesis can be prevalent. This claim is only strengthened by the elements that both games share. Clearly state the claim and what it is.  

Wednesday, January 14, 2015

Reading Response 4- Charlotte DeLay

In the first article by Matthew Broderick, the argument is in a semi-narrative style rather than a formal style commonly associated with works pertaining to historical instances. It is from this that his argument stems into one that has readers identify on a more personal level with what is written. From this, certain important figures are able to seem more interesting to the reader while the history of video games in the military is approached. However, even though this does help bring in interest to the reader, it can also be a double-edged sword for the writer. There were some instances that seemed less credible because it was written too much like a narrative. Certain instances would be like with Zyda’s attempt to have the entertainment industry and the military work together. Although the history of these attempts happening are true, certain aspects involving the narrative make it seem questionable on some of the finer details. Because of this, other quotes that have been used in Broderick’s argument feel less credible that what they could have been. By no means does it mean that the history isn’t true, but based on how he had written his arguments, the narrative style showed a bias for certain key figures in the history of military video games, as well as the credibility for some of the actions.

The next read involving the third chapter of the book, Gaming: Essays on Algorithmic Culture by Alexander Galloway structures its arguments on the realism of video games vs. the extent that video games present a realist aspect. From there, Galloway describes what would be considered realist compared to realism and looks to how people can interpret that type of violence. It is through certain examples, like that of military video games, that Galloway is presenting some of his main arguments on how the game is heavily realist-based or has a great deal of realism is affecting the player. Galloway uses this main argument and goes onto other topics involving violence and how these separate ideas can have possible rebounding capabilities. Because of the nature of a video game’s interactive experience, Galloway argues that video games present a realism that can’t be experienced in other forms of media. With that said, the way that Galloway bases his argument leads to some holes. He mentions only two video game types - the games with realism/a realistic approach, and those that don’t convey those ideas. However, from there, Galloway mentions some games that are in the category of some sort of middle ground. It has one of the attributes but not the other. Because of this, it seems as if there should be other types of categories not mentioned. What about games that take a semi-realist approach with realism in the game? Would a type of game like that be in the same sort of category?

In the final reading, the author, Dyer-Witheford, talks about the dominance of video games and how through it, we have a sort of “empire” built from video games. From this, Dyer-Witheford bases his argument through his intro, trying to make the prompt seem more personal by having it seem as if ‘you’ are actually dealing with certain scenarios. He goes onto talking about the dynamics of online games such as Second Life, or America’s Army. Through these, he shows how both simulate certain aspects that furthers a claim about video games that is flawed. By claiming that video games are medias used by the Empire, Dyer-Witheford is taking a big leap. He claims that the video game industry was able to be the only form of media that has succeeded, however, there are other forms of media out there that have dominated over similar scenarios. Film could be mentioned for instance. Although it is fair to say that the video games market has become a corporate giant, so too have other forms of media that have made a name longer than that of the video game industry.

Sunday, January 11, 2015

Reading Response 3 - Charlotte DeLay

In Shrank’s novel involving video games and the avant-garde of video games, Shrank talks about what defines a video game and how it should be considered a work of art. He claims that there are many ways that video games are able to express an artistic view and how players are able to experience an immersion that is as impactful as other works of art unrelated to video games. With that said, it should be noted that there are some points in his argument that don’t exactly match with his claim. For instance, although now it’s more possible as an outlet for an artistic statement, it should be noted that not all games should be considered ‘art’ based on his definition. There are some games, like pong, which have little to no meaning. Back during the times of early development of video games, there were many people that didn't even know exactly what to do with the outlet. Many were experimental in terms of trying to appeal to the public, but not as an art statement. What should also be made apparent is that the intention of a video game's creator should be put into perspective. Although glanced on by Shrank involving the Sims, there were still others that had little purpose other than to copy a competent movie franchise, or to appeal to an emerging group interested in the medium of video games. By no means does this mark out all video games as being some form of art, but Shrank did neglect to exactly mention those types of games involved to help strengthen his point over how he feels video games should be treated and looked upon.

The other post involving Barnet is able to show the type of reviewing and analyzing style to use for artworks. Although it doesn't mention anything involving video games, it can be applicable for analyzing video games as an artwork as well. In fact, based on the read, it seems as if Shrank from the other reading used these aspects for his novel involving video games as an artwork. Barnet’s book is able to give prime examples on how to examine and analyze a piece of artwork. Through this, many other reviews of what could be considered artwork could be used for analysis, although not what was initially expected of the writer. Both articles are able to correlate to one another because of this common link involving the analysis of artwork.

Wednesday, January 7, 2015

Reading Response 2- Charlotte DeLay

While Rise of Videogame Zinesters by Anna Anthropy talks about how hard of a time it is for a person with no formal training to produce a game that appeals to a variety of audiences, the other article involving the first pronographic game by Laine Nooney would also bring up controversial themes. Anthropy’s main argument involves how video games are challenged to evolve due to industry and how it keeps a narrow mindset on what would be deemed “game-worthy” and bases these arguments throughout the two chapters assigned. From there, she constructs her argument to mention how she is also a minority and how she has found it wrong that video games aren’t able to stretch its wings to a broader set of audiences. Anthropy also mentions how this is an issue because of the fact that many people are under the misconception that there is no way making video games can become a hobby without prior knowledge to coding. The way that Anthropy structures her argument leads from her own dilemmas involving the expanding game industry to that of how gaming has forced its way into a niche crowd due to its complexity. She sees video games as a potential way to express storytelling and provide outlets similar to that of how Youtube has become to others. Anthropy wanted to have an individual interested in creating a video game to make it a personal experience.

Meanwhile, Nooney’s article over the first pornographic video game sets up an argument discussing the implications of creating a video game that is out of the norm for its time, leading to controversy. Although the game’s actual content was mentioned, what was expressed more was the overall controversy involved a new use of the microcomputer. This argument transformed and developed into something more of a conflict involving certain cultural issues during the time, over that of the game. What allows the two articles to correlate involves the methods from which this pornographic game was produced and how it was developed by someone on their free time. Anthropy might not have agreed with the subject matter, or the fact that it was still under a narrow mindset, however, the fact that it was freely made from a hobby and became a personal experience allows for both articles to connect in some way.

Both Nooney and Anthropy’s works are able to form solid arguments, and in a sense, show how the progress of gaming has developed. Nooney’s article shows the prime basis for the progression of corporations later appealing to a certain audience as to not get lashback from them. Meanwhile, Anthropy shows the negative sides of corporations abiding to a target audience because of the feedback that can arise from something that is deemed unfit for that audience.

Monday, January 5, 2015

Reading Response 1 - Charlotte DeLay

Both the IGN review and Kill Screen’s article for The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time are able to provide insight about the franchise as a whole. Although one talks more about the surface of the game and its gameplay, the other takes a deeper approach to truly analyze the narrative that the game’s story weaves. Their main arguments are both trying to analyze the integrity of the game and how it has been different from that of others in the Legend of Zelda franchise. However, it must be noted that both articles are highly opinionated and praise Ocarina of Time because of its difference from other Zelda games.

IGN and Kill Screen are essentially complimenting the same core parts of the game to support their arguments, but what differs is the depth of the analysis of these core aspects. The IGN review is simply gliding over the surface of the Ocarina of Time to give players a brief preview of the game, while Kill Screen decides to talk about how the game immerses the player in order to live through the journey of adulthood by playing as Link. By taking certain sections of the narrative to analyze, Kill Screen is able to create a coherent and meaningful piece than that of IGN. IGN on the other hand, is able to review Ocarina of Time in such a way that not only shows the positive and awe-struck position they have, but also allows them to sell Ocarina of Time. Kill Screen expects its readers to know about Ocarina of Time to a certain extent, while IGN simply nods to those that have, but introduces the game to an audience that hasn’t heard much about it. IGN’s positive feedback allow readers to believe that Ocarina of Time is worth the score that is received at the end of the review because of how much the reviewer builds upon his own excitement for the game.

However, both the arguments from IGN and from Kill Screen are flawed in certain aspects. Kill Screen expects readers to already know much about Ocarina of Time and the Legend of Zelda franchise. It is able to summarize certain points of the narrative for first-timers to understand the story of Ocarina of Time, but fails to explain properly how it “comes closest to making Link a dynamic character” compared with that of other Zelda games. Kill Screen assumes that readers have played other Legend of Zelda games in order to validate its claim. In order to properly prove its positive opinion, Kill Screen should compare other Legend of Zelda games to show how undeveloped of a character Link is. Not only would this amplify Kill Screen’s assertion, but also boost its opinion on why Ocarina of Time is able to  break out of the mold from other Zelda games.

As for IGN, its flaw is the sheer amount of positive opinions that it projects from its review of Ocarina of Time. It doesn’t allow for many negative comments, and tries to convey the overall enjoyment that the reviewer had, rather than what flaws might be present in the game itself. If the reviewer was able to take away this bias, his review would be more balanced. As a way to still show the uniqueness of Ocarina of Time, IGN could have been able to have a personal thoughts section so the other sections weren’t overloaded with bias. This way, those sections could be more fleshed out while still being able to have the reviewer portray his own opinion on Ocarina of Time.