Tuesday, January 6, 2015

Reading Response 1 - George Grayson

George Grayson
Professor Evans
Video Games in Art Historical Context
5 January 2015
Reading Response #1
       Based on the articles I have read, “Review: The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time” by Peer Schneider and “Childhood Ambitions: The Journey to Maturity and Back” by L.B. Jeffries, it is safe to say that The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time was an extremely influential and well-developed video game. In Schneider’s article, he absolutely praises the game. He does not cease to discuss every aspect and element of it, because in his opinion, every detail is executed flawlessly. There were minor hiccups about the game that got irritating, but he quickly overlooked them. In a historical sense, Schneider begins the article with a comparison of the enjoyment of playing this game to the enjoyment of playing the original Zelda game on the NES in 1987. He then compares some of the gameplay to other classic N64 games, but still boasts about the originality and creativity that went into this game’s production. He goes on to explain the new features that are available for the player to experiment with and he makes a point about the improvement of the overall Zelda franchise and how far it has come based on this game alone. While reading this article, this game truly seemed to be revolutionary for its time period and Schneider did not shy away from discussing the strengths of every feature in its adventurous setting.
       In Jefferies article, his view of the game is slightly contrasting. He in no way says anything negative about the game, he just feels it conveys a slightly deeper message compared to Schneider’s views. If you have played this game, which I personally have not, then I am certain you would no doubt connect to the game on a more personal level after reading this article. Jefferies frequently emphasizes how the aging of Link allows the player of the game to reminisce on his/her childhood and reflect on times in their lives when they felt both inferior and superior to others. This article is more along the lines of a synopsis of the game rather than a review, because Jefferies never explained how he felt about the gameplay, graphics, sound, etc. However, his emphasis on the theme of growing up from adolescence while explaining the plot of the game helped me understand how a frequent player of the game would connect with it on a personal level. I think this shows just how influential this game is, and not only that, it seems extremely well-made and entertaining.
       Questions that arose from both articles:
Schneider – Does comparing some of the elements in this game to games that came before it make it seem like this game cheated off features that have already been utilized in past N64 games?

Jeffries – Does writing an article connecting this game on a personal level market it better with people who have not played it? Or, does it spoil the feeling of playing it for the first time because people are already familiar with the game’s deeper message of adolescence and growing up? 

No comments:

Post a Comment