Monday, January 5, 2015

Reading Response 1 - Joel Kauth

The IGN and Kill Screen reviews of The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time differed in the way that the game was presented. The IGN review provided insight regarding the incorporation of Link's adventure into the N64 format, while also comparing and contrasting the gameplay of different N64 video games (specifically Super Mario 64). The Kill Screen review instead explicates the story line in the game, emphasizing on Link's coming of age near the conclusion as well as Link's differing perspectives from his youth and adolescent self.

The IGN review was comparable to a teenager showing a "The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time virgin" the game for the very first time. While being very careful not to reveal the secrets of the game, Schneider explained the controller layout as well as the differing nuances compared to other games. On multiple occasions, Schneider continues to reaffirm his stance on why The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time was the best available N64 game at that time by an incredibly large margin. I think that the review can't be considered a critique, as there is no balance between positive and negative aspects of the game, and the author himself seem a tad biased as he continually gushes over the game.

Kill Screen's L.B. Jeffries explored the depths underneath the flash and look of the game, and by doing so uncovered the recurring themes that are present throughout the game. Link jumps between his child and adolescent self throughout the game, and Jeffries identifies the different techniques used to emphasize his his perspective at a certain age. I found this very intriguing, since the last time I played this game was in the first grade. At the time, I was mentally incapable of interpreting this very profound theme, but now I can reminisce on my memories of gameplay and recall the very examples that Jeffries uses.

Playing this game as a first grader, I can distinctly remember the fear that struck me while encountering the challenges of the night during Link's youth. While Jeffries discussed the theme of Link's coming of age, I thought the player's age during gameplay could have been discussed as well, since the game obviously can't be experienced without a person playing it.


No comments:

Post a Comment