Showing posts with label Reading Response 4. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Reading Response 4. Show all posts

Thursday, January 15, 2015

Reading Response 4 - Joel Kauth

Corey Mead's article Shall we play as game?: The rise of the military-entertainment complex provides a structured layout of the upcoming of the link between entertainment and defense when it comes to videogames. I thought the way that the narrative which was set up was intriguing, as Mead's recall of history kept telling of a nerdy small group of guys who could accomplish tasks with an astronomically smaller amount of money and time needed. Yes, this was the actual history, but Mead's decision to deliver his article this way provided a perspective favoring the smart, clever programmers compared to the naive government officials who were willing to dish out insane amounts of money just to insure that their simulators were the best that they could possibly be. I never thought that Disneyworld would be a model to how the armed forces desired to have their soldiers trained, but the "wow factor" behind Disneyworld's simulations proved to be just enough.

Alexander Galloway's chapter on Social Realism in his book Gaming: Essays on Algorithmic Culture focuses on the effects of realism in videogames, along with the presence of historical information.  The interpretation of realism was depicted in one example through the videogame Under Ash, a game that was aimed at young palestinian boys who witness the war around them everyday. The game is a simulation of the siege against Israel progressing from stones to guns. By providing the game to those who are experiencing the game-like situations around them, the game is able to take on a different essence as the palestinian playing group, "Is in fact able to depict it own "restricted code" in a shooter game. By doing this, the game differs only slightly from our perspective as we don't witness the war around us everyday as the palestinians do.

Reading Response 4 - Jake Hagan

“The technologies that shape our culture have always been pushed forward by war.” As much as I do not want to believe this to be true, it is very evident. If we look at history, war has surged many new inventions and technologies. Is this problematic in any way? Well as it comes to video games, no it is not directly problematic, but if we look at it from an anthropological standpoint, it could be a problem. Later in the article they talk about how the government funded the entertainment industry $100 million so that it would, “Give the army direct access to the game and virtual environment…” This is a scary statement showing just another example of how our government has borderline questionable control in our country.
            One of the theories I found quite intriguing in the second piece we read was when the author was talking about how video games can increase a person’s reflexes. As a young child who grew up playing video games while my mother badgered me sometimes about it, my counterargument was always, “It helps my reflexes and hand-eye coordination.” Now reading this article, it gives me a little extra joy inside knowing that what I was saying was actually correct.

            Our final read posed much room for thought and worry. Is our technology advancing too much in the world of games? Should we be wary of where we are going in the future? With the realistic simulators they have out nowadays, people are concerned that they are becoming too realistic and that people can start to get in bad situations because of the realness of these simulators. In the end, I think people should just be cautious about how much they invest in video games or simulators or anything really. Nothing we do should consume so much of our life that it would be us in bad situations that could possibly arise.

Reading Response - Brannon Hamm

It is a depressing topic to examine the effects of video games on the real world.  For many, they represent an escape—an area in which one need not concern oneself with the dull banalities and, often, the macabre truths of reality.  But it would be naïve to assume that games are created in a vacuum, and in that way it is intuitively obvious that the social context of video games be acknowledged and even studied. 
Mead’s article is mostly a history; a description of the inception of video games in the belly of the military-industrial complex.  In that way there is little to say about it.   Matters of simple history bear little in the way of discussion.  Galloway, however, founded his writing on a more interesting, if morbid premise.  He proposed the idea that video games are blessed and cursed with another level of realism than other forms of art—while other works are restricted to realism of narrative and imagery, video games also depict realism of choice, a realism that relies on participant interaction moreso than any other kind.  It is because of this “realism of choice” that Galloway believes gamers are perhaps more affected by their preferred art than any art consumers of the past.  Video game realism can project ideas onto actual reality better than any other medium because the fundamental reality of consumer choice remains intact. 

Galloway’s ideation is referenced obliquely in the work of Dyer-Witheford, Nick, de Peuter, and Greig on video games and global hypercapitalism.  Central to their musings is the idea that video games are the “paradigmatic” art expression of economic empire—an idea that is inherently nonsensical without an acknowledgment that video games undoubtedly have various effects on their political and social climate.  On a brighter note, they also suggest that video games are simultaneously the best artistic vehicle for criticism of that selfsame system.

Wednesday, January 14, 2015

Reading Response 4- Charlotte DeLay

In the first article by Matthew Broderick, the argument is in a semi-narrative style rather than a formal style commonly associated with works pertaining to historical instances. It is from this that his argument stems into one that has readers identify on a more personal level with what is written. From this, certain important figures are able to seem more interesting to the reader while the history of video games in the military is approached. However, even though this does help bring in interest to the reader, it can also be a double-edged sword for the writer. There were some instances that seemed less credible because it was written too much like a narrative. Certain instances would be like with Zyda’s attempt to have the entertainment industry and the military work together. Although the history of these attempts happening are true, certain aspects involving the narrative make it seem questionable on some of the finer details. Because of this, other quotes that have been used in Broderick’s argument feel less credible that what they could have been. By no means does it mean that the history isn’t true, but based on how he had written his arguments, the narrative style showed a bias for certain key figures in the history of military video games, as well as the credibility for some of the actions.

The next read involving the third chapter of the book, Gaming: Essays on Algorithmic Culture by Alexander Galloway structures its arguments on the realism of video games vs. the extent that video games present a realist aspect. From there, Galloway describes what would be considered realist compared to realism and looks to how people can interpret that type of violence. It is through certain examples, like that of military video games, that Galloway is presenting some of his main arguments on how the game is heavily realist-based or has a great deal of realism is affecting the player. Galloway uses this main argument and goes onto other topics involving violence and how these separate ideas can have possible rebounding capabilities. Because of the nature of a video game’s interactive experience, Galloway argues that video games present a realism that can’t be experienced in other forms of media. With that said, the way that Galloway bases his argument leads to some holes. He mentions only two video game types - the games with realism/a realistic approach, and those that don’t convey those ideas. However, from there, Galloway mentions some games that are in the category of some sort of middle ground. It has one of the attributes but not the other. Because of this, it seems as if there should be other types of categories not mentioned. What about games that take a semi-realist approach with realism in the game? Would a type of game like that be in the same sort of category?

In the final reading, the author, Dyer-Witheford, talks about the dominance of video games and how through it, we have a sort of “empire” built from video games. From this, Dyer-Witheford bases his argument through his intro, trying to make the prompt seem more personal by having it seem as if ‘you’ are actually dealing with certain scenarios. He goes onto talking about the dynamics of online games such as Second Life, or America’s Army. Through these, he shows how both simulate certain aspects that furthers a claim about video games that is flawed. By claiming that video games are medias used by the Empire, Dyer-Witheford is taking a big leap. He claims that the video game industry was able to be the only form of media that has succeeded, however, there are other forms of media out there that have dominated over similar scenarios. Film could be mentioned for instance. Although it is fair to say that the video games market has become a corporate giant, so too have other forms of media that have made a name longer than that of the video game industry.

reading response 4 - Kevin Feller

In the first article they talk about how agencies like the department of defense and other military departments were some of the first people to start use the coding on the first computers ever made. I love the comparison to them movie “War Games”. These agencies were just the first to figure out and develop simulated games. It had to be known that other people would figure out how to make and develop games similar to those that the military found first.
            In the article about capitalism where they talk about how much money is required in playing a certain games. While I was looking at the numbers I was shocked about how much money is used on video gaming.  The reason that they are making so much money is because of the game designers who make the games. Most college graduates make 45,000 dollars a year with some making around 90,000 dollars a year. Blizzard and Activison are two major companies that show success. They are worth 18.9 billion on the market value.
            What this makes me want to talk about is how much videogames affect culture today with the amount of money some companies have been making. It seems that many young adults and children of todays age have the past time for videogames, where as the generation before those children have a past time of more active physical nature. These large video game companies are making more and more money because of the generation that is upcoming. Children will want games and not bats and balls. The companies therefore are able to create better versions of the game that are more appealing. This seems like a clear technological change from the last generation to the next

Reading Response 4 - Jacob Boudreau

These articles focused on the realistic nature of certain video games and the impact of these realistic games. The two most common game types mentioned were first-person-shooters and real-time strategy games. I have absolutely no experience in RTS games, so I will focus on my specialty, FPS games.

Two articles talked about the military and capitalism in games. Both articles, however, talked about the military and its part in video games. The main issue was that the violent FPS’s are a way of prepping people for the military. The article in Salon talked about the way the military used Doom and Doom II to train Marines. Charles Krulak, the general in charge of MCMSO said that they “believed that PC-based war games held great potential for teaching Marines critical decision-making skills”. Notice how he said that it was the critical decision-making that was being trained. I’m going to declare that video games and simulations are two entirely different things. I have played FPS’s since I can remember and played them competitively in 2008 with Halo 3 and Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 in 2009. Modern Warfare 2 is the more realistic out of the two, but it is far from a simulation of war. The issues with Modern Warfare 2, and most call of duty games, is that they are very unrealistic, despite the graphics. Sure it may look like real war, but it is far from it. The guns don’t jam, you always reload on the first time, there is no fatigue, there are no ballistics in COD, the blast radii of explosions are diminished, and the list goes on. The only thing that is accurate in the Call of Duty is the military jargon in the campaign. A cool fact that most people don’t know is how stressful a competitive game can get. If you were to listen in on our team-speak during a match you would hear what sounds like chaos. Six players simultaneously shouting out positions, deaths, marked men, help, and more. I guess that can simulate real-time battle confusion. I think that FPS games are not being used to train or prepare players for military service, that’s what boot camp is for.

The excerpt from the book on the game empires talks about video games and violence. It brings up the Columbine Shooting and the possibility that violent video games were the reason behind it. I love video games, especially FPS’s, which, in most cases, are considered violent, so I will defend them. People seem to think that there is a link between playing violent video games and becoming violent. I would just like to put a few points out there. In Call of Duty: Black Ops, as of 2010, 6.9 billion people were killed. Halo 3’s final stats, here, show that over 136 billion people were killed. These are just two games, and yet the murder rate has decreased, shown here. If games had any real effect on the players then would the murder rate go up, even the slightest. I mean 136 billion people is roughly twenty times the Earth’s population.


Now what does this have to say about social realism? I think that just because games look like real life doesn’t mean that they are realistic or show realism. I think that it is hard to think of something as real when I am looking at it on a flat screen. One thing that is an issue is that video games are interactive. When you want to kill someone in Call of Duty, you have to physically push a button. There is a physical connection, but it is very different than actually killing someone. To knife someone in Call of Duty, you, usually, click the right stick in. That is a very different feeling than actually thrusting a knife into a person. Sure games can get really close to realistic, but the fact that they are on a screen and the physical actions do not match up, to me, makes it hard to see the realism in games. 

Reading Response 4 - Sam McManus

                It’s amazing what kind of influence the military industrial complex has had over the advancement of technology over the past handful of decades. It kind of makes sense that video games would stem from technology created for military purposes, but that fact that it has come full circle and is being used for military simulations is even more baffling. From early flight simulators to modern day simulations like Arma III, it’s amazing just how reliant on current technology is. The entertainment industry is also pushing the bars with what is desired by consumers, which in turn drivers the military’s ability to acquire more modern technology. It’s also amazing from a consumer standpoint just how involved in the idea of military games we have become. Yearly releases of games like Call of Duty, and other popular shooters like Battlefield and Counter-Strike just pay testament to this idea.

                In some instances though, I don’t see the angle. When President Reagan claimed that the next generation of soldiers would be trained on video games, it was a bold statement. While it is true that some games are used for military purposes, to accurately reenact military scenarios, those are for already highly trained soldiers. No amount of Call of Duty will prepare someone to take the life of another human being. Plus, thinking of this generation becoming our nation’s future protectors scares me. I don’t know if you can realistically 360 YY claymore no-scope a terrorist while jumping off a ladder, and that may be hard to tell some of those kids. Video games are an excellent means for recruiting and basic training skills, but nothing can truly replace actual field experience until we manage to develop something like the holodeck from Star Trek, which based on these articles will be funded by a defense contract. It’s exciting knowing we live in a time where our entertainment gets funded by national defense. I’d also like to mention that Commandant Charles Krulak is a friend of my grandparent’s and lives down the street from them in Florida.

Reading Response 4 - George Grayson

In the Mead article, “Shall we play a game? The rise of the Military – Entertainment Complex”, I have learned that video games were around much earlier than I thought. Civilians may never have known this, but the United States military has always been involved with video games. This is surprising, and risky, because there was a lot of tension between nations around the time of the use the military’s digital technology to make what was essentially the first digital video game. The military’s advancements in computer graphics and programming since the end of WWII may have been the foundation for the entire video game industry as we know it. Spacewar!, “the first digital game” as Mead discussed, utilized these advancements in computing not for defense or national security, but solely for entertainment. With the constant pressure of nuclear war or another totalitarian country on the brink of global domination, I was utterly astonished that the military’s technology spent time to develop a video game. Granted, the game did have elements of that were relevant and appropriate for the time period, but the game still sounds very enjoyable. It is interesting to see the extent of the influence of video games. Apparently, the last people that I would think to play video games were actually developing one themselves.
            The Galloway chapter, “Gaming: Essays on Algorithmic Culture (Chapter 3)”, is not too contrasting to the Mead article. Essentially what Galloway is saying in this chapter is that the realism of video games are beneficial to the players. Gamers actually improve their cognitive reflexes and become familiarized with the world, though in a simulated setting. What I found interesting about this chapter was the difference between realistic narrative and realistic representation. Galloway views realistic narrative as simple things within games that anybody can do, such as an action in The Sims. Ordering a pizza, going for a walk, etc. are all things that we as humans can do whenever we wish. Realistic representation is something that not everybody can do, but is still depicted as a realistic action. Galloway’s example of storming an enemy base in a game like SOCOM or Call of Duty are spot on in my opinion. No matter how you interpret it, I think that the comparison of these two forms of realism are essential for all gamers to understand.

            In the final reading by Witheford and de Peuter, “Games of Empire: Global Capitalism and Video Games”, the purpose of video games is taken to a new level. The main argument revolves around the game Second Life, which is a virtual world simulator game much like The Sims. The controversy about Second Life was that players have the ability to manage their own income and, in some instances, players are able to make a fortune and become vastly wealthy. According to both Witheford and de Peuter, there has been speculation from entrepreneurs that real profit can be made from this game. Unfortunately for these entrepreneurs, the game is so realistic that players can actually become bankrupt as well. This shows just how realistic video games have become, especially simulator games such as this. Real-world people attempting to mimic the strategies of these realistic games to make a profit may prove to be dangerous.

Reading Response 4 - Brandon Wright

The Salon reading by Corey Mead Shall we play a game? Talks of the history of video games and the United States military, while Galloway's “Gaming: Essays on Algorithmic Culture” talks more of the realism that can come from video games, but does speak of the US military attempting to create a realistic game, while Dyer-Witheford and de Peuter both speak more on the history of realism in video games and how people reacted to them.

In the Salon reading, not much is really contestable about the history of the Video games and their intertwining with the United States military. Corey Mead presents the facts in a clear manner and while I knew some information about how the military used game developers and video games for the basis of simulations, I didn't realize that the military started the idea of video games with “Spacewar!” and would later use DOOM and DOOM II for simulation mods. In addition, the budget numbers and cost of the simulations developed by the military compared to what was created commercially was a very interesting comparison.


With Galloway however has more room to talk about and explore what he is saying with his writings. In the third chapter of “Gaming: Essays on Algorithmic Culture”, which is titled “Social Realism”, Galloway attempts to look into and explain what makes a game “realistic” and how to define what realism actually is. He immediately discounts the look of the game. Just because the game looks real, and has an extremely high polygon count in the models does not make the game “realistic”. Instead Galloway tries to proposition that it is through a feedback loop that a game is realistic. The setting has to be something the user can see themselves in. such as an American playing America's Army, but not a Palestinian since they are not American. On page 84 he writes “the challenge is not only to capture the social realities of the disenfranchised but also to inject the game back into the correct social milieu of available players where it rings true.”

Tuesday, January 13, 2015

Reading Response 4 - Erin Lupardus



            I don't have a problem with the FPS genre. I see it as what it aims to be--a game. However, somehow the idea of any military actually using these games for training purposes is oddly chilling to me. It is a perfectly reasonable transition considering most first-person shooters revolve around the military and "shooting the bad guys;" as Mead explains, the U.S. military even funded and encouraged the development of such games for training purposes. Yet, the enhanced realism of preparing to actually shoot people casts a dark shadow on the genre in my eyes. War is not a game. There are no respawns, automatic healing powers, or high scores.
            If games aim for realism, why does the reality that they convey become haunting when real life actually interacts with them? Maybe we all look to video games as a way of escaping our own lives--perhaps reliving them in a more exciting yet realistic way. Dyer-Witheford and de Peuter bring up the idea that video games are "recession proof" because when the economy makes life difficult, people turn to a fun activity that they can control (xviii). Second Life has been used for money laundering and business meetings, very real-life (albeit illegal in some cases) activities. Because of Toywar, Etoy actually succeeded in bringing down eToys; thus, a video game's influence had real-life consequences. No wonder Galloway points out Sony's realism "fetish" (70). Video games really are more "methectic" than "mimetic" (72).
            However, realism can go so far as to override reality, and reality can shatter the fun of realism. America's Army uncomfortably mixes "militainment" (xi) and foreign policy. Shoot a "terrorist" in the virtual face and maybe it will mean less when you actually kill him. A Korean couple became so involved in their virtual Prius lives that their real-life baby starved to death. Where does the line between pleasurable and overbearingly evocative realism lie? There is nothing inherently harmful about the premises of America's Army, Second Life, or any other "realistic" game, but sometimes the strive for social realism reveals and encourages the pitfalls of reality.