DePauw University | Winter Term 2015 | Prof. Chaz Evans
Showing posts with label Game Criticism Essay. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Game Criticism Essay. Show all posts
Tuesday, January 27, 2015
Thursday, January 22, 2015
game criticism essay - Kevin Feller
Kevin Feller
Mr. Evans
Winter term
22 January 2015
Stereotypes
Between Horde and Alliance
World
of Warcraft is a part the biggest videogame franchise of this era. Blizzard
entertainment really succeeded on the way that they developed the game and its
two sides, horde and alliance. The horde and the alliance factions has been a
huge talk for World of Warcraft players ever since the game was created. It has
seemed that over my many years of playing world of warcraft a lot of players
and I have noticed this one part of the game more than anything else. Being a
member of the horde faction, players find the alliance side to be the bad guys
of the game. There are many players that play on the alliance side that think
vise versa. I have concerns about why players have the hatred for the two sides
and ways that this is shown in culture today.
World
of warcraft is a massively multiplayer online role-play game and the most sold
videogame of all time. It is a free roaming game that does not have a true
ending point. There are many different ways that World of warcraft can be
played. Each character goes through a leveling process from one through one
hundred. Once you get to the maximum level you can do the player versus player
matches or you can do the player versus environment scenarios. There are also role-play
realms where you take on a more life like aspect of the game where you can have
a family and things similar to that.
Millions of people
have played world of warcraft and the major questions hits you right as you log
in for the first time. You are given the task of choosing a character and there
are clearly two sides to choose from. At first glance it looks like a simple
red versus blue scenario, but once you look deeper into the screen you can
recognize that one is Alliance (blue), which is full of the hero type
characters such as humans, dwarfs, night elves, and gnomes. The other side, the
horde (red), is full of the more gruesome characters such as orcs, trolls,
tauren, and goblins. During the time that this game came out many young players
wanted to be a more hero like character so the obvious choice in this situation
would be an alliance character. Children were watching Lord of The Rings and
other movies that had characters such as the ones on the alliance side. They
were seen as the good players. This left the alliance with way more players
than the horde faction as the game first was released. The thing that the horde
players liked though were the ability to win the player versus player
battlegrounds. This made many alliance player versus player players mad. This
was the beginning of the horde and alliance stereotype that the alliance is
full of young kids and raiders and the horde is full of serious older pvp’ers.
The
one problem that world of warcraft had towards the beginning was how the horde
were seen as bad guys. This was also the lord of the rings thinking on how the
bad guys were trolls, goblins, and orcs. Blizzard realized this problem and did
all that they could to make it so the horde was not seen as evil characters or
the bad guys. Blizzard had trouble at first but finally based the next
expansion more off of horde characters than the alliance characters. This gave
the horde a more honorable look rather than the bad guys. The physical look of
the horde character could be seen as bad but the way that blizzard dealt with
this in-game situation was very helpful for the more even amount of players on
both faction sides. Another problem was that in the first expansion the
alliance only had the paladin class. The paladins are seen as the fighters of
the light and the light was only on the alliance side at that time. This made
horde players think that the creators of world of warcraft were favoring the alliance
side. Most of these misconceptions were thrown out as the burning crusade
expansion was released. This expansion gave the horde faction to the ability to
become paladins.
The
way that you can compare the horde and the alliance is by the rivalry that they
share. The rivalry would be much like a sports team rivalry. It is also good to
compare this to a certain type of republican versus democratic debacle. You as
a republican/democrat agree with the side that you are on. This then leads you
to dislike the views of the other side. That is the same for world of warcraft.
Each side is almost the same but each player has his or her own view of the
opposite side that they don’t play for. Neither side is bad or good.
There
actually has been a sort of transition since the game came out and where it is
now. The first vanilla expansion had the alliance as the raiding faction and
horde as the Player versus player. After then next expansions came out the two
factions started to get good teams of both. The expansion Warlords of Dreanor
actually has more top player versus player top guilds as alliance and the best
raiding guild is horde. This is an example that world of warcraft may have
started with two different sides with different roles in gameplay, but now there
is a very even or switched role for this expansion.
The
fact that the two factions are closer now in player versus player makes the
in-game player more competitive and fun. The main place that the horde and
alliance rivalry takes place is during battlegrounds. Battlegrounds are ten or
more people who try to capture a flag or hold bases and get more points than
the other team. During these battlegrounds it is always a horde team versus an
alliance team. Many people will rage quit if beat by the other team. Sometimes
these rivalries go to far though. In the normal world some player can camp the
other faction and keep killing them. This does not allow that player to play
the game for as long as they are being killed. This in many players perspective
is going too far because it is ruining another players gaming experience.
Killing someone so they cannot play the game seems to ruin the fun of being
able to do whatever you want.
This
rivalry even made it into the entertainment industry when American Chopper had
a special series on the competitiveness between the horde and the alliance. It
was an eight-week competition on which two teams could make the better
motorcycle to depict the horde and the alliance. This was the first time that
blizzard had ever done something of this nature. An out of game contest that
shows the true nature of how these two sides really see each other. The coolest
part about this was that at the end of the series they let the players vote for
which chopper was the coolest and that chopper would be given to that faction
for free. The horde players ended up winning and many of the alliance players
were furious. They thought it was an unfair vote due to the fact that there are
more horde players overall than alliance players. This just shows another example
of how one side thought their side was less than the other, when in totality
they are the same thing, just with different colors and characters.
The
horde versus alliance rivalry started as just a simple good versus bad
misconception, but most players feel that it has grown since then. The game has
gotten more and more players that learn from the rest of the players in game
that they are the better faction and that the other faction is the opposite.
This rivalry will never go away but most players feel that is a good thing.
Without this rivalry the game would not be as successful as it is today. If
this rivalry were not in game then player versus player would not exist. The
world of warcraft franchise made a rivalry that no other game can compare
to.





Desat,
Marla. "Azeroth Choppers Reveals Winning World of Warcraft
Motorcycle." The Escapist. Defy Media, 5 June 2014. Web.
"Thread:
Stereotypes of Horde and Alliance Players." MMOChampion RSS.
N.p., n.d. Web. 22 Jan. 2015.
"World
of WarcraftĂ‚®." Where Did Ally/Horde Stereotypes Start? N.p.,
n.d. Web. 22 Jan. 2015.
Game Criticism Essay - Sam McManus
Samuel McManus
Professor Chaz Evans
Video Games in Art
Historical Context
January 19, 2015
Fallout 3: Morality of the Wastelands
[1] You stand alone in on barren plain, a score of
dilapidated houses scatter the sunlight on the horizon when suddenly a gunshot
rings out, and a rock several feet from your feet explodes into tiny fragments. [2]You decide that shot came from a
sniper in one of those houses, and decide to investigate. As you get nearer and
nearer, you discover the houses are surrounded by landmines, a defensive
perimeter has been setup to keep the likes of you out. You disarm a few and
save them for later, who knows when they might come in handy. As you move from
house to house, you discover an old man wielding a .308 sniper rifle taking
potshots at passerbyers, clearly insane from years of isolation in the Capital
Wasteland. You put a few mercy bullets in the man’s skull, knowing he can no
longer do damage to those unlucky enough to meander past his miserable abode;
well except for those landmines scattered about. As he keels over, you take his
sniper rifle and test it by dispatching the lead man of a traveling caravan in
the distance. A small icon appears in the upper left hand portion of your HUD,
“you have lost karma!”.
[3]
This type of scenario is common place in the world of Fallout, a
retro-futuristic post-apocalyptic role playing game heavily influenced by the
style and culture of 1950’s America, and its fixation with the potential of the
atom. The game takes places years after nuclear catastrophe has wiped the Earth
clean of almost all life, with only a fraction of a percentage of the
population surviving Armageddon, hidden away safely inside large bomb shelter
communities called vaults, waiting to reemerge and repopulate the world. This
plan does not prove to be all as successful as was intended, as now the
wastelands are inhabited by both small, self-governed communities, and bands of
raiders looking to survive by any means necessary. Many inhabitants took
shelter in the cities underground metro system, allowing them to survive but
searing the flesh from their bones and driving them insane, leaving scores of
feral ghouls lurking in the shadows of the underground. Even within the
confines of the game issues of morality plague the world. The vaults meant to
keep a select few safe from the impending nuclear disaster were used as social
and scientific experiments [4]. One
had an intentionally faulty nuclear power reactor, which would force its
dwellers topside prematurely in an attempt to find parts to fix their only
means of survival. Two separate vaults had one male and nine hundred and ninety
nine females and vice versa, while another distributed a mutagen gas to its
inhabitants in an attempt to see if it would create humans better adapted to
the irradiated outdoors, which instead created unstable super mutants that
prove to be powerful adversaries. [5]
These breeches of morality and humanity demonstrate how even seemingly innocent
attempts to save humanity are wrought with unseen consequences, and nobody is
above sacrificing lives for the apparent betterment of society.
As
you scour the Capital Wasteland for supplies to aid you on your journey, you
will encounter all different types of survivors, from those who need your help,
to those willing to help you, to those who would gladly slaughter you for fun.
As you become an expert wasteland survivor, you must make the decision of
morality [6]. You can play the role
of protector, helping those less fortunate than yourself; wasteland villain,
stealing and leaving a trail of destruction and bodies in your wake, either for
the satisfaction or the loot; or simply remain neutral, helping when and where
you see fit, but not unwilling to put your needs above those of others if it
offers greater benefits, a sort of wasteland mercenary. If you choose to ramp
up the difficulty of game, these decisions become even more vital, as real-life
necessities like food, water, and sleep become required in-game, and you must
act accordingly. Bones can be broken and crippled, and addictions can be
acquired if the player isn’t careful enough, forcing them to seek treatment
from even the most dilapidated of facilities. The game toys even further with
the idea of morality by using permanent NPC death, so if you kill off a certain
character, a chain of events might not be unlocked, and you’ll be unable to do
certain tasks. So if you blow up a quest NPC with a landmine, that series of
events is forever blocked off in that save.
Quests
are often open ended in their regards to the player’s karma, allowing them to
complete it with good or bad intentions. In one particular instance, you are
asked by a village dweller to aid her by rescuing her brother from a clan of
vampires (Yes, vampires). When you find their hideout deep underground, you
discover her brother has voluntarily joined their ranks, and must either be
persuaded to go back home, or be allowed to remain. If the player chooses not
to dispatch The Family as they are called, they can instead choose to strike a
deal between The Family and the town. This deal aids all parties involved, as the
town receives protection by the clan in exchange for doses of blood, and allows
the player to unlock a perk that gives them extra health from blood packs (adopting
some of the vampire’s traits). The Family can also be persuaded to use blood
packs instead of taking from a living human, which further compliments your
negotiating skills, a win-win for everyone.
[7] However, the
most testing of all the decisions you will make while playing Fallout 3 is the
decision of Megaton. You are approached by a shady man in a bar, and he offers
you a large sum of money to rid the Capital Wasteland of Megaton. You may
either choose to accept his offer, or decline by defusing the bomb, killing
him, or reporting him to the town’s authority. Should the player choose to
destroy the town, all of its inhabitants are killed in the ensuing blast, [8] save one particularly annoying survival
expert, who survives as a ghoul, flesh seared from her bones [9]. This particular choice influences
how many characters interact with you for the duration of the game. Radio
broadcasts condemn you for your inhumanity, and after you find you missing
father, he simply cannot come to terms with the fact that you could have done
something so atrocious. If you decide to defuse the bomb, the residence of
Megaton are grateful, and offer you a home with a robot butler and aid on your
journey. You may also bask in the praise of numerous individuals, and listen to
the exploits of your good deeds on your radio.
[10] The setup
of Cormac McCarthy’s The Road is very
similar to that of Fallout 3’s, in that the world no longer has overarching
laws to abide by, the social order has collapsed, and people must form mutual
trust relationships and communities in an attempt to survive. In The Road, an unnamed father and his son
must venture across an America that has been destroyed by an unknown
catastrophe, although it is heavily implied that nuclear war has brought about
this disaster, much like Fallout. As the inevitable nuclear winter closes in on
our protagonists, they decide to venture south in an attempt to escape the
oncoming cold. During their journey, they encounter a variety of survivors,
many of whom are unfriendly, and who are willing to do whatever it takes to
survive, even resort to cannibalism. In one instance, the pair are walking down
a destroyed street in a town when an arrow strikes the man’s leg. A small
firefight ensues, ending with the man killing his one of his assailants with a
flare gun, then proceeding to stitch up his wounded leg using nothing but a
bottle of vodka and a sewing kit. Similar situations arise in Fallout, as any
crippled limb does not heal with time, but rather must be tended to by a doctor
or fixed by the player with the proper tools. In another instance, the pair are
robbed; all of their supplies stolen by another man. When they catch up to him,
the man makes their would-be burglar return their stolen goods, as well as give
them all of his clothes. While he stands there naked an afraid, the boy begs
his father to return the man’s clothes, as he will freeze to death otherwise.
This instance of compassion, even for those who would harm them, by the boy is
one of the few examples of honor in a lawless society. They had every right to
kill the man if they had so pleased, but the boy insisted on preserving both
his and his father’s humanity, something many of the wasteland dwellers lack,
both in The Road and Fallout. You
have the choice of killing nearly every NPC in the game if you so wish, and
being the victim of highway robbery is not uncommon. You can attempt to handle
it peacefully like the boy, or kill your attacker like the father would have.
As
the player continues to explore the wastelands they will encounter scores of
survivors, some of whom are friendly, some who only look after their own. [11]You will encounter vicious monsters,
mutated and feral from exposer to the lingering radiation. You must find means
to defend yourself and continue on your quest to preserve the Wasteland’s. [12] As you do so, you must make moral
decisions regarding the lives of others, whether you will help them, or use
them as a means to an end, pickpocketing and stealing or just killing them
outright. How you choose to play the game impacts how the world changes around
you, as character interactions, quests, and perk availability change based on
player actions. As you become more radical either one way or the other, more
radical perks become unlocked, such as allowing you to cannibalize your foes
for health, or sell the fingers of Wasteland baddies for caps. Neutral perks
allow the player to exploit others for increased benefits to dialogue stats.
This dynamic and ever-changing world truly allows the player to become
engrossed in the game, making decisions more along their own guidelines, making
decisions to join factions attempting to instill good, or prowling the
wastelands for hapless victims. The game give the player a unique experience
tailored to their preferences, and the world realistically reflects their
choices. [13] And finally, I leave
you with this badass picture of a Brotherhood of Steel soldier.
https://docs.google.com/a/depauw.edu/presentation/d/1IGWkHKFkkqTOGYhtY9eCKu00i1M9BzongKH53hKmVR4/edit?usp=sharing
Wednesday, January 21, 2015
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)