In Shrank’s novel involving video games and the avant-garde of video games, Shrank talks about what defines a video game and how it should be considered a work of art. He claims that there are many ways that video games are able to express an artistic view and how players are able to experience an immersion that is as impactful as other works of art unrelated to video games. With that said, it should be noted that there are some points in his argument that don’t exactly match with his claim. For instance, although now it’s more possible as an outlet for an artistic statement, it should be noted that not all games should be considered ‘art’ based on his definition. There are some games, like pong, which have little to no meaning. Back during the times of early development of video games, there were many people that didn't even know exactly what to do with the outlet. Many were experimental in terms of trying to appeal to the public, but not as an art statement. What should also be made apparent is that the intention of a video game's creator should be put into perspective. Although glanced on by Shrank involving the Sims, there were still others that had little purpose other than to copy a competent movie franchise, or to appeal to an emerging group interested in the medium of video games. By no means does this mark out all video games as being some form of art, but Shrank did neglect to exactly mention those types of games involved to help strengthen his point over how he feels video games should be treated and looked upon.
The other post involving Barnet is able to show the type of reviewing and analyzing style to use for artworks. Although it doesn't mention anything involving video games, it can be applicable for analyzing video games as an artwork as well. In fact, based on the read, it seems as if Shrank from the other reading used these aspects for his novel involving video games as an artwork. Barnet’s book is able to give prime examples on how to examine and analyze a piece of artwork. Through this, many other reviews of what could be considered artwork could be used for analysis, although not what was initially expected of the writer. Both articles are able to correlate to one another because of this common link involving the analysis of artwork.
No comments:
Post a Comment