Sunday, January 11, 2015

Reading Response 3 - George Grayson

After reading the foreword and the first chapter of “Avante-Garde Videogames: Playing with Technoculture” by Brian Shrank, I have learned that there are much deeper artistically significant themes within video games that I have not even noticed growing up. First, Jay David Bolter starts off Shrank’s book with a foreword regarding how well the book stands out in the importance of video games. Bolter acknowledges that Shrank’s book is distinct in purely emphasizing the history of 20th century art. He is willing to accept Shrank’s view that video games are in fact art, much like movies, music, or really any other form of media that requires skill to master. Bolter makes the claim that traditional art students will not be interested in playing avant-garde video games. I think he his right to some extent, because most students, regardless of their area of study, will mainly gear themselves toward more mainstream games. However, I don’t think that Bolter should jump to assumptions of what art students would be interested in. Simply because someone chooses to study art does not mean that they are subjected to only playing games along those lines. If certain games offer new and experimental takes on society that are unusual, I think it’s ultimately up to the player to decide what he/she wants to play.

            That being said, the first chapter of Shrank’s book introduces multiple video games that Shrank believes would assist in classifying the differences between what “mainstream” is and what “avant-garde” is. The two games he begins with both express real world references and contain very particular themes and elements within their gameplay. The first game he mentions, Heavy Weapon: Atomic Tank (2005), became commercially successful within the mainstream. The second game he mentions, September 12th (2003), did not quite flow as well with what was popular at the time. Though both games contain historical elements, Shrank comes to the conclusion that Heavy Weapon is a simpler, more close-minded game that is straight-forward enough to be fun and enjoyable. September 12th contains complex political ideas and seemed to establish itself too much as an advertisement of the government as it was combatting the war on terror at the time. Shrank concludes his discussion of these two games by stating that Heavy Weapon became prevalent in the mainstream because it had a more singular flow that kept the mainstream strong, whereas September 12th had a more intricate flow that deviated from the simplicity of the mainstream. All in all, I think Shrank believes that avant-garde games are not unnecessary, they’re just a new take on an already vast, established industry.

No comments:

Post a Comment