Jake Hagan
1-19-15
Professor Evans
Final Essay
Grand Theft Auto V: A Joke Gone too Far?
Grand Theft Auto V provides for us a
pathway to make an example out of. Some people claim that the entirety of the
game is a satire anyway. But is this satire taking things too far? We could sit
and debate the satirical aspects of the game, but in the end, when people are
interacting with the game and seeing the gameplay, they might not be looking at
it in a joking manner. GTAV has one very
questionable scene from a mission in the game that should not be taken lightly.
The effect of these “over the top scenes” is what I am going to get into,
looking from a psychological standpoint. Grand Theft Auto V has many elements
that would concern people to point to desensitization to violence,
crime-related incidents, etc. but the game takes the issue of a “harmless”
enjoyable game too far with the torture mission. While I do not believe the
playing of the game, or others like it, induces violent acts, I do believe that
this part of the mission could have been omitted and pushes the boundaries of
what should be included in games being played for entertainment. The media we
view, whether we are aware or not, does have an effect on our behavior and we
need to be cautious of taking games played for pleasure too far.
The psychological aspects of these
violent scenes, like the torture scene, have an effect on people that has been
shown through psychological studies and experiments searching for answers to
why they is correlations between violence and violent media. The first study I
am going to highlight is one done by researchers from the University of
Michigan, VU University Amsterdam and Iowa State University. Their aim was to
test the theory that exposure to violent media reduces aid offered to people in
pain. The first of their two tests made participants play a violent or
nonviolent video game for 20 minutes. The participants were tested separately
and played Carmageddon, Duke Nukem, Mortal Kombat, or Future Cop for violent
games, or Glider Pro, 3D Pinball, Austin Powers, or Tetra Madness for
nonviolent games. They were then asked to fill out lengthy questionnaires but 3
minutes after being done playing their game, a audio recording of a fight was
played outside the room. The researcher was testing how long it would take the
participant to assist one of the people who had been “hurt” in the recording. The
results of this first study show that those who played violent video games took
up to 73.3 seconds longer to respond to the victim than those who had just
played a nonviolent video game. This adds up to upwards of 450% longer time
than those who played the nonviolent game. Participants were also asked to rate
the severity of the fight, and those who played the violent game rated the
fight as being not as serious.
In the second study that the
researchers conducted, participants were observed at a movie theatre either
before or after seeing a violent or nonviolent film. The researchers used a
confederate, someone who assists the researchers and knows what is happening,
to fake a fall because they had an injured leg and were walking with crutches.
The researchers were testing how much time it took for the participants to
react and help the fallen confederate in need of assistance. There was no real
difference in the amount of time it took people to react before seeing the
movie, but the results after having seen the movie were intriguing. Those who
had just seen a violent movie on average took up to two seconds longer than
those who had just seen a nonviolent movie. This means that the violent
moviegoers took 26% longer to respond.
What does this research say about
GTAV, more specifically the torture scene in the game? This research shows that
exposure to violent media has an effect on those who view it, and it affects
helping delay and reaction to violent situations. But what does this mean for
those who claim that Grand Theft Auto V in itself is entirely a satire and that
it’s just a game and should not be taken seriously? To those people, I claim
that even though the game itself might be a joke with numerous examples of
different criticisms of the world we live in today like our political system,
criminal justice system and so on an so forth, but that is not the point here.
Imagine you are playing Grand Theft
Auto V for the first time, or even it is the first video game you have ever
played. You have not read anything previously about the game, nor have any
prior knowledge of the game. Playing the game now would not be taken as a joke.
In order to view and play the game in a satirical way means that one has prior
knowledge of the work being a satire. In my personal experience, I had no
knowledge that the game was meant to be a satire. While I did not believe
everything in the game to be real or that I should attempt anything that
happens in the game, I was still affected by the gruesome torture scene in one
of the missions of the game.
You are Trevor Phillips, one of
three main characters available to play with during gameplay of GTAV. Trevor is
a “redneck/hillbilly” white male, who lives in the rural part of the city in a
trailer park like living area. Has aggression issues and has a long criminal
record. He is the most aggressive and unremorseful character in the game. He
has a quick temper and is not afraid to cross anyone who is in his way. On this
specific mission, Trevor and the other two playable characters have teamed up
with a federal agency in order to track down a large criminal organization and
its leader. There has been a man that was captured and taken into custody of
the federal agency and this man was brought to an abandoned warehouse scene,
tied with ropes to a chair in the middle of the room. You get orders from the
federal agent with you, “Choose your instrument, and go to work on him.” The
man tied in the chair pleads with you he does not know what you are talking
about, to let him go, and so on. Then pops up the possible “tools of torture”
available to use on this man in order to get him to talk and reveal an address
that will assist the feds in shutting down the criminal organization. You can
select one of four instruments; these tools ranging from pliers, used to yank
out teeth, an electric battery, used for electrocution, a large wrench, used
for beating the man senseless, and lastly a jerry can full of water, used for
water boarding. If you so choose to use all for instruments, this scene can
last up to around 15 minutes of constant torturing of this man in order to get
him to speak. Does this seem like a joke now? While those who argue on the side
that this scene is a satirical representation of what is being done by the USA
in regards to Guantanamo Bay, I do not dispute that. But so what if it is? Just
because something is meant to be taken as a joke, does not mean it will be
taken that way because regardless if that is the truth or not, the fact is that
the gamer still sees and has to physically torture a man with buttons on the
controller. I have not found any research on anything having to do with this
phenomena of the gamer actually having to cause the violence directly, but my
hypothesis would be that it only intensifies the effect it has on the
desensitization to violence.
With the realness of the graphics,
this scene and the violence in the game in general, can be compared to other
violent games of the sort. Using another example from a game, Call of Duty
Modern Warfare 2 campaign mode has a mission in it that requires the player to
load up with large amounts of armor, high-powered weapons, and effectively shoot
up an airport terminal (which is also used in the online multiplayer as a map).
Many people were outraged at this mission and caused quite a stir with some
people in remembrance of 9/11 and other terrorist attacks that have happened in
this country. But the main and crucial difference between these two games is
quite simple actually. Before this mission in Call of Duty Modern Warfare 2,
there is a pop-up on the screen asking the player if he or she wants to
continue with this mission because of the graphic nature of the mission. The
player must then select yes or no and choose whether or not to play the
mission. There are no consequences for choosing not to play the mission. This
crucial difference is one we do not see in GTAV the torture mission. It would
not be possible to continue the story mode of the game without playing this
mission and going through this scene, thus essentially, the player must play
the mission or be punished by not being able to finish the story mode. While I
am not stating that there should be a screening before every mission or scene
of the game, there should be some sort of way that the player is able to know
exactly what he or she are going to encounter during the game. Whether that be
by putting it in the rating on the case or some other manner, each and every
player has the right to know what they are playing.
Going along with other related games
having questionable scenes, the game “The Last of Us” portrays a way that GTAV
could have done it differently. In this scene from “The Last of Us”, the player
is not in control of the actual torturing and only sees a portion of violence
before the scene cuts out and goes onto the next screen. This game effectively portrayed
that people were being tortured without the player themselves having to conduct
all of the torturing process and without moving the controller to torture. This
is one example of a way that GTAV could have gone at its torture scene differently,
they could have shown a little bit of violence while at the same time giving
the same message to the player without having the same effects that come from
GTAV.
People have been playing these types
of what some would call “senseless” violent games for years, which causes no
concern for those who can distinctly discern what is clearly “just a game” vs.
“I can do this in real life”. What could be done to avoid people from becoming
desensitized to violence is omitting these up-close, in your face scenes, such
as physically torturing a man to get him to talk. The makers could have kept
some people from discrediting the game along with violent media as a whole by
taking out this scene. It puts the integrity of the game in jeopardy and many
people could have social and political issues with a scene like this.
Even though some may claim the game
is just a joke, I do not see having to torture a man during the game as a joke.
The player still has to torture the guy to get him to talk. The fact that the
player must choose his torture technique and then actually move the analog
sticks to pry a tooth out, electrocute, etc. is one that puts the player in the
shoes of this character who is completely unbothered by this experience of
torturing someone and feels no remorse whatsoever. What kind of message does
this send to those playing? Whether gamers everywhere want to accept it or not,
violence does have an effect on our behaviors, not to the extent some make it
out to be, but at the same time, we must be wary of our developments into more
realistic games that can cause greater issues in the future for us.
Works Cited
Comfortably Numb. S.l.: Book On Demand, 2013. Web.
"Desensitizing the Mind to Violence - Dave
Grossman, Author."Desensitizing the Mind to Violence - Dave Grossman,
Author. N.p., n.d. Web. 22 Jan. 2015.
Dictionary.com. Dictionary.com, n.d. Web. 22 Jan. 2015.
"Grand Theft Auto 1." GTA
Wiki. N.p., n.d. Web. 20 Jan. 2015.
No comments:
Post a Comment