Wednesday, January 14, 2015

Reading Response 4 - Jacob Boudreau

These articles focused on the realistic nature of certain video games and the impact of these realistic games. The two most common game types mentioned were first-person-shooters and real-time strategy games. I have absolutely no experience in RTS games, so I will focus on my specialty, FPS games.

Two articles talked about the military and capitalism in games. Both articles, however, talked about the military and its part in video games. The main issue was that the violent FPS’s are a way of prepping people for the military. The article in Salon talked about the way the military used Doom and Doom II to train Marines. Charles Krulak, the general in charge of MCMSO said that they “believed that PC-based war games held great potential for teaching Marines critical decision-making skills”. Notice how he said that it was the critical decision-making that was being trained. I’m going to declare that video games and simulations are two entirely different things. I have played FPS’s since I can remember and played them competitively in 2008 with Halo 3 and Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 in 2009. Modern Warfare 2 is the more realistic out of the two, but it is far from a simulation of war. The issues with Modern Warfare 2, and most call of duty games, is that they are very unrealistic, despite the graphics. Sure it may look like real war, but it is far from it. The guns don’t jam, you always reload on the first time, there is no fatigue, there are no ballistics in COD, the blast radii of explosions are diminished, and the list goes on. The only thing that is accurate in the Call of Duty is the military jargon in the campaign. A cool fact that most people don’t know is how stressful a competitive game can get. If you were to listen in on our team-speak during a match you would hear what sounds like chaos. Six players simultaneously shouting out positions, deaths, marked men, help, and more. I guess that can simulate real-time battle confusion. I think that FPS games are not being used to train or prepare players for military service, that’s what boot camp is for.

The excerpt from the book on the game empires talks about video games and violence. It brings up the Columbine Shooting and the possibility that violent video games were the reason behind it. I love video games, especially FPS’s, which, in most cases, are considered violent, so I will defend them. People seem to think that there is a link between playing violent video games and becoming violent. I would just like to put a few points out there. In Call of Duty: Black Ops, as of 2010, 6.9 billion people were killed. Halo 3’s final stats, here, show that over 136 billion people were killed. These are just two games, and yet the murder rate has decreased, shown here. If games had any real effect on the players then would the murder rate go up, even the slightest. I mean 136 billion people is roughly twenty times the Earth’s population.


Now what does this have to say about social realism? I think that just because games look like real life doesn’t mean that they are realistic or show realism. I think that it is hard to think of something as real when I am looking at it on a flat screen. One thing that is an issue is that video games are interactive. When you want to kill someone in Call of Duty, you have to physically push a button. There is a physical connection, but it is very different than actually killing someone. To knife someone in Call of Duty, you, usually, click the right stick in. That is a very different feeling than actually thrusting a knife into a person. Sure games can get really close to realistic, but the fact that they are on a screen and the physical actions do not match up, to me, makes it hard to see the realism in games. 

No comments:

Post a Comment