DePauw University | Winter Term 2015 | Prof. Chaz Evans
Showing posts with label Erin Lupardus. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Erin Lupardus. Show all posts
Thursday, January 22, 2015
Thursday, January 15, 2015
Draft Pages - Erin Lupardus
Papers, Please Outline
Argue
an interpretation:
The “Main Theme” represents a government’s struggle to portray strength instead
of weakness, highlighting the ambiguity of its true intentions. Silence emphasizes
the bleakness of the workman’s day and the sense of isolation in an invasive
environment. The "Death Theme" demonstrates the unsettling, probable
ruin of the everyday citizen. The "Victory Theme” establishes the
cyclical, uncertain nature of political turmoil. (These ideas will likely be
the concluding sentences of each corresponding paragraph.)
Develop
a comparison:
"Main Theme" and Pope's writing style in general vs Shostakovich
Quartet 8 (details in outline)
Develop
a thesis and outline:
Introduction:
background information
o
one-man-show
Lucas Pope developed everything
o
released
on August 8, 2013
o
randomly
assigned work as an immigration officer at the newly-opened Grestin checkpoint
after 6 years of war with neighboring country, Kolechia
·
thesis:
The Original Soundtrack of Papers, Please vitalizes and bolsters the storyline’s
evocative exploration of everyday life and indefinite moral obligations within
a totalitarian system.
"Main Theme":
·
strong
opening, perfect fourth
o
like
marching footsteps, starts the experience off with intense vigor
·
very
few non-chord tones
o
structure,
order, regulations
·
compound
rhythms within simple meter
o
sign
of instability, sounds like accelerando near the piece's end, but does not
speed up
·
ambiguous
chords until pizzicato strings enter, major/minor dominant, intentional absence
of the third in five chords
o
strength
vs weakness, uncertainty
·
quasi-F
Major sections within d minor
o
"happiness"
vs "sadness" within the system
·
repetitive
melody, but underlying chords change
o
consistency
vs change
·
increasing
intensity by additional instrumentation
o
changed
bass line and timpani for emphasis vs solidarity of strings and melody line
Silence:
·
during
the actual workday, the only sounds are shuffling papers, ambience, and
indistinct, harsh voices
o
increases
realism (no soundtrack in real life), immersion (only you, the papers, and the
entrant in front of you), seriousness (no chipper arcade tune to lighten the
mood), and isolation (nothing to distract you from the task at hand--you are
alone with your job)
"Death Theme":
·
plays
for 17/20 of the game's endings--"bad endings"
o
creepy
beginning instantly signals impending doom
·
emphasis
on the second and fourth beats
o
swaying
feeling, like you're in a dream state or something--"this can't be
happening"
·
most
electronic, 8-bit feel with an ominous twist
o
brings
out the absurdity of the situation
"Victory Theme":
·
A
Major, the dominant of the "Main Theme" d minor
o
connection
between government and "victory"
·
emphasis
on first and third beats
o
upbeat,
propelling, moving forward, "spring in your step"
·
sprightly,
uncharacteristically optimistic
o
incredibly
ironic considering the dark nature of the game and the debatably
"happy" endings
·
only
of the three that fades at the end
o
the
happiness continues? or the happiness fades? two possible meanings
Shostakovich Quartet 8:
·
different
interpretation of corrupt, communist government from a person who actually
experienced it, expressed musically
·
dissonance
of second movement vs Pope's adherence to chord tones
o
personal
feelings toward government vs government's outward portrayal of itself
·
militant
march of "Main Theme" vs police knocking on the door in the fourth
movement
o
oppression,
invasiveness
Conclusion:
·
use
of medium
o
why
is the soundtrack paired with a video game so powerful as opposed to just in a
film or by itself in a concert hall? interaction, player choices, immersion
·
just
six minutes in total, yet so effective
Tuesday, January 13, 2015
Reading Response 4 - Erin Lupardus
I don't have a problem with the FPS
genre. I see it as what it aims to be--a game. However, somehow the idea of any
military actually using these games for training purposes is oddly chilling to
me. It is a perfectly reasonable transition considering most first-person
shooters revolve around the military and "shooting the bad guys;"
as Mead explains, the U.S. military even funded and encouraged the development of such games for training purposes. Yet, the enhanced realism of preparing to actually shoot people casts a dark
shadow on the genre in my eyes. War is not a game. There are no respawns,
automatic healing powers, or high scores.
If games aim for realism, why does
the reality that they convey become haunting when real life actually interacts
with them? Maybe we all look to video games as a way of escaping our own
lives--perhaps reliving them in a more exciting yet realistic way. Dyer-Witheford
and de Peuter bring up the idea that video games are "recession
proof" because when the economy makes life difficult, people turn to a fun
activity that they can control (xviii). Second
Life has been used for money laundering and business meetings, very
real-life (albeit illegal in some cases) activities. Because of Toywar,
Etoy actually succeeded in bringing down eToys; thus, a video game's influence
had real-life consequences. No wonder Galloway points out Sony's realism
"fetish" (70). Video games really are more "methectic" than
"mimetic" (72).
However, realism can go so far as to
override reality, and reality can shatter the fun of realism. America's Army uncomfortably mixes
"militainment" (xi) and foreign policy. Shoot a "terrorist"
in the virtual face and maybe it will mean less when you actually kill him. A
Korean couple became so involved in their virtual Prius lives that their real-life baby starved to death. Where does
the line between pleasurable and overbearingly evocative realism lie? There is
nothing inherently harmful about the premises of America's Army, Second Life, or any other "realistic"
game, but sometimes the strive for social realism reveals and encourages the pitfalls
of reality.
Sunday, January 11, 2015
Reading Response 3 - Erin Lupardus
According to
the Oxford English Dictionary, the avant-garde is "the pioneers or
innovators in any art in a particular period." Given Schrank's analysis of
the current progression of video games, avant-garde games challenge the
"prevailing paradigm of flow" (7), but I believe there comes a point
when too much revolutionizing creates an entirely new art form. For example, some digital paintings and more traditional mediums mimic similar subjects, but they do not belong in the same category because different tools are used to create them. Yes, they are both works of art and can have the same effect, but just because digital paintings test the boundaries of traditional art does not mean they can still be considered traditional art. Schrank refers to Jackson Pollock's art as an example of paintings that challenged painting itself. However, Pollock did not break the definition of painting; rather, he used the tools of painting to create a different result than what was expected. Schrank aims to explore the "broadest" (7) definition of games as possible, but arguing semantics avoids the idea that video games may have evolved into something new entirely.
Video games can be interactive art, but not all interactive art are video
games. Schrank includes Juul's diagram of what can be considered games and what is not, but he finds the definition too exclusive. I would argue that Juul's definition is correct. Games have "fixed rules, a variable outcome, valorization of outcome, player effort, player attachment to outcome, and negotiable consequences" (9). Interactive art such as "The Entertainment" and "Dys4ia" are thought-provoking, powerful outlets for storytelling, but they are not games. "The Entertainment" has no rules, negotiable consequences or variable outcome. It is essentially a play with a different art style and optional order of observing. "Dys4ia" lacks similar qualities. This does not diminish their effectiveness, but classifying them as video games in order to prove a point is incorrect. "The Stanley Parable" and "How Do You Do It" are both games and art because they have all the qualities of a game along with a unique, beautiful, and interesting message to share. Anna Anthropy similarly argued about the definition of video games in Rise of the Videogame Zinesters, but definitions are important. It is a shame that "literally" literally means "figuratively" now because of the people's misuse of the word in everyday language. Yes, there are avant-garde examples of true video games, but art forms evolve and need not stick to their roots in order to make a point.
Wednesday, January 7, 2015
Reading Response 2 - Erin Lupardus
Laine
Nooney's "The Odd History of the First Erotic Computer Game" and Anna
Anthropy's "Rise of the Videogame Zinesters" explore the
predominantly male-centric nature of mainstream video games.
I
agree with Anthropy that the major gaming companies mainly produce one type of
game for one type of audience. However, I don't really see this as a problem.
As she points out, there are thousands of independent game developers creating
what they want to see created. Steam and online flash game hosting sites allow
these new ideas to be distributed and consumed. It is unlikely that mainstream
game producers will change their current formula, and why should they? It works
and is profitable for them. As long as there are other options for hopeful game
developers to distribute their work, there is no sense in trying to change a lucrative,
popular system.
I
see Softporn as a fun, creative
satire just as Benton originally intended it to be. The "gawkiness"
that Nooney describes fits Benton's aim perfectly. Despite the game's
provocative cover art, Nooney clarifies that there is no "actual obscenity"
in the game, and this is an important detail. It is fascinating that the naked
hot tub women on the cover are all company employees. It is possible to argue that this
suggestive setting diminishes the women's contributions to the game, but I
disagree with that notion. They volunteered to participate in the photo shoot.
Posing naked is not inherently sexist or damaging to women. Feeling sexy can be
empowering, and pornography does not always degrade women.
Interactive fiction such as Softporn is usually
quite difficult both to play and write. They rely entirely on the author's
ability to create a compelling interactive text with enough clues for the
player to figure out what to do next. However, the cover art does not explain exactly
what kind of "adventure game" it is. Perhaps the lure of an erotic
video game was enough to convince people to purchase the game for a whopping
$29.95 ($77.81 when accounting for inflation.) I doubt there will ever be a
time when sex no longer sells.
Questions: Do you think independent game developers will eventually influence major gaming companies in terms of game content? Is their influence necessary?
Questions: Do you think independent game developers will eventually influence major gaming companies in terms of game content? Is their influence necessary?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)