Friday, January 16, 2015

Draft Pages - Jake Hagan

Jake Hagan
1-15-15
Professor Evans
Draft Pages
Grand Theft Auto V: A Joke Gone too Far?
            Grand Theft Auto V provides for us a pathway to make an example out of. Some people claim that the entirety of the game is a satire anyway. But is this satire taking things too far? We could sit and debate the satirical aspects of the game, but in the end, when people are interacting with the game and seeing the gameplay, they might not be looking at it in a joking manner.  GTAV has one very questionable scene from a mission in the game that should not be taken lightly. The effect of these “over the top scenes” is what I am going to get into, looking from a psychological standpoint. Grand Theft Auto V has many elements that would concern people to point to desensitization to violence, crime-related incidents, etc. but the game takes the issue of a “harmless” enjoyable game too far with the torture mission. While I do not believe the playing of the game, or others like it, induces violent acts, I do believe that this part of the mission could have been omitted and pushes the boundaries of what should be included in games being played for entertainment. The media we view, whether we are aware or not, does have an effect on our behavior and we need to be cautious of taking games played for pleasure too far.                          
            People have been playing these types of “senseless” violent games for years, which causes no concern for those who can distinctly discern what is clearly “just a game” vs. “I can do this in real life”. What could be done to avoid people from becoming desensitized to violence is omitting these up-close, in your face scenes, such as physically torturing a man to get him to talk. The makers could have kept some people from discrediting the game along with violent media as a whole by taking out this scene. It puts the integrity of the game in jeopardy and many people could have social and political issues with a scene like this.
            Even though some may claim the game is just a joke, I do not see having to torture a man during the game as a joke. The player still has to torture the guy to get him to talk. The fact that the player must choose his torture technique and then actually move the analog sticks to pry a tooth out, electrocute, etc. is one that puts the player in the shoes of this character who is completely unbothered by this experience of torturing someone and feels no remorse whatsoever. What kind of message does this send to those playing? Whether gamers everywhere want to accept it or not, violence does have an effect on our behaviors, not to the extent some make it out to be, but at the same time, we must be wary of our developments into more realistic games that can cause greater issues in the future for us.



No comments:

Post a Comment