Showing posts with label Joel Kauth. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Joel Kauth. Show all posts

Thursday, January 22, 2015

Joel Kauth
Professor Evans
Videogames in Art Historical Context
17 January 2015
Life is not a Game
            The human race has thrived in this universe that we inhabit based on not success, perfection, or predictability. Humanity’s most valuable assets have been the flaws, haphazardness, and miscalculation that have been accounted for throughout our existence. The videogame: The Sims2 as well as the movie: The Truman Show1 are both examples of media where the unpredictability and free will of humans is excluded from their production which negates their ability to successfully or accurately simulate humanity. In each form of media, the Sims that one is able to command or the protagonist in The Truman Show can stray away from outcomes desired by the omniscient source of direction for them. The game and movie show similarities in how the characters’ free will pulls them away from the results desired. To set up this comparison, parallels as well as relating themes will be connected to support the argument that humanity cannot be simulated or manipulated.
            The Sims is a computer game designed by Will Wright, whose initial purpose

was “to create a virtual dollhouse after losing his home during the Oakland firestorm of 1991”. The game consists of dictating “Sims”, or simulated people, to interact with themselves, household objects, and computer controlled Sims. The player looks down on their Sims’ family lot, which typically consists of a house, throughout the entirety of the game, and can control whether the walls of the house are transparent or not. This omniscient sense of visibility is similar, yet superior to that of The Truman Show. The Truman Show is a movie about a thirty-year-old man named Truman, whose entire life has actually been a nonstop “reality” show. Adopted by a production company at birth, with the whereabouts of his actual parents unknown, Truman grows up in Seahaven, a television production set created inside an arcological dome4. Scarred by his father’s tragic death in boating accident, Truman never seeks to venture outside of Seahaven until he begins to become suspicious of his surroundings. This suspicion of Truman’s provides a roar of enthusiasm for the TV audience, as his struggle to find out the truth becomes the main focus of the show. Christof, the show’s creator and producer, made it nearly impossible to not see what Truman is up to.
Watching from his command post located in the Dome’s “sun”5, Christof, as well as the production crew, keep tabs on Truman by constantly scanning over monitors that are being fed live feed from five thousand cameras all over Seahaven. From Truman’s bathroom mirror to his car, his surroundings are always under watch. Although Truman is able to escape Christof’s surveillance temporarily near the end of the movie, Christof’s ability to constantly monitor Truman from a bird’s eye view is nearly identical to playing The Sims from the isometric perspective. Both instances of monitoring can also conclude that Christof, in addition to the player of The Sims, both assume the role of God in their respective scenarios.  
            The Sims is an isometric-view3 sandbox style computer game with no absolute end or completion of the game. The game is played by commanding “Sims”, or simulated people, to perform specific actions by manipulating their environment or interacting with fellow Sims. An important aspect to the game are the Sim’s needs levels, which are the meters that display the type of satisfaction a particular Sim possesses with eight different needs: hunger, comfort, bladder, energy, fun, social, hygiene, and environment. These eight needs are the keys to one’s Sims to execute the actions that were commanded. If one or more of the need levels are shockingly low, the Sim is able to cancel out a command and perform whatever action is necessary to bring the need level back up. Yes, The Sims’ ability to replicate the basic needs for happiness and satisfaction is impressive, but so many factors that lead to being content are absent from the game. One can’t limit the factors that go into supplying happiness to just eight needs, yet those are the only ones present in the game. There is an infinite amount of factors that play into happiness, as well as an infinite amount of factors that could satisfy each need. By limiting the Sims’ needs as well their options to satisfy these needs, the game is not able to simulate humanity. Lucian Ghinda created a list online of factors that could lead to happiness. A staggering fifty-four possibilities were listed, and that’s barely scratching the surface.
            In The Truman Show, Truman always followed the path that Christof made for him until a stage light came crashing down from the ceiling of Seahaven’s dome. He begins to become suspicious of his surroundings, and slowly begins to stray away from Christof’s image of the show. On his way to work, Truman spots a homeless man6 who looks exactly like his deceased father who had died when he was a boy. As Truman attempts to pursue the homeless man, numerous obstacles and groups of people slow down Truman. The homeless man is eventually taken away on a public bus, and Truman’s suspicions continue to grow. Truman refused to be lured by the distractions presented by Christof, and by doing so exhibited his free will taking charge against the simulated environment of Seahaven.
 Later in the movie, Truman speaks out against his “wife” when she advertises a drink for the show as a form of product placement in the middle of their conversation. He proceeds to take away the peeler that she then pulls on him, and puts her in a lock hold. Christof urgently sends Marlon, Truman’s best friend, to diffuse the situation. This act of aggression against his wife, Meryl, was a direct challenge to whatever the force was that Truman suspected of controlling his environment. Although he still didn’t know who or what was manipulating his environment, Truman continued to become more suspicious due to these strange events.
In The Sims, Sims are reliant on commands by the player in order to perform any actions. Yet, when given commands while their needs levels are down, Sims have the ability to cancel out actions in order to satisfy their neglected needs. Possibly, someone commanded a Sim to watch TV while his or her hunger level was very low. Typically, the Sim would nix the command, and replace it was the command of going to the refrigerator to eat some food. This ability to abandon the player’s commands in order to satisfy their personal needs is a prime example of a “simulated person” exercising their free will. By doing so, it supports the fact that humanity can’t be simulated or manipulated since Sims are able to stray away from desired outcomes, just like how Truman begins to stray away from the path that Christof has laid out for him throughout his entire life.
The Truman Show is set in Seahaven, the “city” that is inhabited by Truman, and hired actors and actresses. Of the actors and actresses, there are multiple races represented, for example: Truman’s neighbors that are African-American. Yet throughout the movie, mental illnesses, disorders, medical disorders, and physical disorders are not present. The movie fails to represent these different categories, and by doing so is leaving out a huge part of the human race. Dwarfism, schizophrenia, Down syndrome, as well as being disabled (just to name a few) are all aspects of daily human living. Our genetic and mental makeup are each essential pieces to how we make decisions, and in part by leaving these out, takes away from the credibility of how Truman grew up in a perfect environment. Christof is quoted saying, “Seahaven is the way the world should be.” By negating any instabilities or disabilities from the Seahaven community, Christof wipes out any chance that he could possibly be simulating humanity. Yes, he is manipulating everything that Truman interacts with, but all he is doing is simply manipulating an artificial environment.
The Sims shares the same flaw when considering if the game successfully simulates humanity. When customizing your Sims7, there is not an option whether to make your Sim a little person. As far as mental disorders, illnesses, and physical disorders go, there are no examples from the game where it is made apparent that a Sim has any of these. Yes, Sims may exhibit mood tendencies that could point to any certain mental illness or disorder, but it is not a theme in the game. The game excluding these possible qualities of human life is a major shortcoming when it comes to trying to reproduce humanity.
While playing The Sims, the player will confront situations where censorship occurs. While enjoying a shower or using the toilet, a shroud of blurred colors covers the Sim. Although I agree that this is a good feature for younger players of the game, this aspect to the game adds to it’s inability to simulate humanity. A similar scenario arises in The Truman Show. Truman’s wife, Meryl, attempts to take his mind off traveling to Fiji by suggesting they should conceive their first child. While the scene moves to their bedroom, the camera shot transforms into a loop of a curtain blowing in the wind. This is an example of censorship since the scene of Truman and Meryl having sex was replaced with the blowing curtain. Reproduction is essential to survival, so if every time sex instead turned into a curtain blowing in the wind, the human race would be wiped out within two hundred years. By enforcing censorship, both examples of media take away from their ability to attempt to simulate humanity.
The Sims and The Truman Show are two similar forms of media that attempt to replicate the human experience of reality. While both take clever angles to make their simulations legitimate, they both lack key principles that are necessary when attempting to simulate or manipulate humanity.





















Works Cited
6.     www.gonemovies.com

7.     sims.wikia.com



9.     screenrant.com



                                                                                1.
                                                        2.
3.
                 4.
5.
6.
7.



           
           

           

            

Thursday, January 15, 2015

Reading Response 4 - Joel Kauth

Corey Mead's article Shall we play as game?: The rise of the military-entertainment complex provides a structured layout of the upcoming of the link between entertainment and defense when it comes to videogames. I thought the way that the narrative which was set up was intriguing, as Mead's recall of history kept telling of a nerdy small group of guys who could accomplish tasks with an astronomically smaller amount of money and time needed. Yes, this was the actual history, but Mead's decision to deliver his article this way provided a perspective favoring the smart, clever programmers compared to the naive government officials who were willing to dish out insane amounts of money just to insure that their simulators were the best that they could possibly be. I never thought that Disneyworld would be a model to how the armed forces desired to have their soldiers trained, but the "wow factor" behind Disneyworld's simulations proved to be just enough.

Alexander Galloway's chapter on Social Realism in his book Gaming: Essays on Algorithmic Culture focuses on the effects of realism in videogames, along with the presence of historical information.  The interpretation of realism was depicted in one example through the videogame Under Ash, a game that was aimed at young palestinian boys who witness the war around them everyday. The game is a simulation of the siege against Israel progressing from stones to guns. By providing the game to those who are experiencing the game-like situations around them, the game is able to take on a different essence as the palestinian playing group, "Is in fact able to depict it own "restricted code" in a shooter game. By doing this, the game differs only slightly from our perspective as we don't witness the war around us everyday as the palestinians do.

Monday, January 12, 2015

Reading Response 3 - Joel Kauth

Avant-garde Videogames by Brian Schrank explored the different ways videogames could or couldn't be defined as "art" throughout their years of formation and evolving from the avant-garde perspective. The article made it clear that as certain games were developed, over time they could not be considered avant-garde as they lost the essence about them that was new and different. To me, the most compelling observation made by Schrank was the parallel drawn between September 12th and Heavy Weapon: Atomic Tank. He was able to differentiate mainstream and avant-garde simply through laying out the game's goals, and my visceral reaction created by my own experience with games similar to Atomic Tank as well as the perspective of the citizens turned terrorists being employed by the game. This comparison separated two games by their applicability, as well as their implications politically and culturally by emphasizing that we are always the "good guys", and subtly dialing in on the reactions of the villagers of the Arab town.

On page 18, I found that Duchamp's incorporation of a urinal into a fountain made a bold statement against the perception of art. The urinal, or fountain's, role could be seen as, "It foregrounds and acsthcticizes the ways in which we normally sense-or more accurately, fail to sense-technology." (Schrank 18). This idea is hugely similar to the argument on whether videogames can be considered art, as the statement made by Schrank as its artistic purpose is to challenge the way that we consider a certain technology to be used. Although Fountain was rejected by the Society of Independent Artists, his action is considered to be a huge challenge to both sides of avant-garde, and was able to be employed regarding whether videogames can be considered art, which I believe that they can.

Wednesday, January 7, 2015

Reading Response 2 - Joel Kauth

Rise of the Videogame Zinesters started out as an aggressive front regarding how the author, Anna Anthropy, has a very minimal amount of videogames available to her that capture the queer transgender experience. Further into the first chapter, she forms her argument into why games can't be less focused on shooting men in the face, but rather be able to provide a vast collection of differing experiences that apply to everyone? Before the article, I had never devoted much of any thought to the reason of why videogame themes seem to be constant, as well as their storylines. The parallel she drew with the printing press established the credibility I needed to take her absolutely seriously, as the tone leading up to that point was slightly playful in her argument. But seriously, what exactly will be the printing press for video games?

The Odd History of the First Erotic Computer Game was pretty laid back in it's approach. The article was introduced as a "History", and it was just that. The article was laid out as if Nooney was telling a tale rather than the history of something. Rhetorically, the photos taken were meaning to introduce a type of game that had never been seen before in a exaggerative way. I found the perspective of the male finding the computer to be a "sexless tool" and the women instructing computer literacy classes to be very interesting and refreshing since I come from a generation where men exploit computers for sexual relief and women tend to stray away from computers.

The question that bothered me was why didn't Anthropy didn't provide a structure to how global game making could be revolutionized so that all genres and interests could be represented. She was incredibly passionate in her argument, yet all she could do was compare her idea to youtube. Much of her article was spent trying to sway the audience from the norm, yet her idea is the video game version of something that already exists.

Monday, January 5, 2015

Reading Response 1 - Joel Kauth

The IGN and Kill Screen reviews of The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time differed in the way that the game was presented. The IGN review provided insight regarding the incorporation of Link's adventure into the N64 format, while also comparing and contrasting the gameplay of different N64 video games (specifically Super Mario 64). The Kill Screen review instead explicates the story line in the game, emphasizing on Link's coming of age near the conclusion as well as Link's differing perspectives from his youth and adolescent self.

The IGN review was comparable to a teenager showing a "The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time virgin" the game for the very first time. While being very careful not to reveal the secrets of the game, Schneider explained the controller layout as well as the differing nuances compared to other games. On multiple occasions, Schneider continues to reaffirm his stance on why The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time was the best available N64 game at that time by an incredibly large margin. I think that the review can't be considered a critique, as there is no balance between positive and negative aspects of the game, and the author himself seem a tad biased as he continually gushes over the game.

Kill Screen's L.B. Jeffries explored the depths underneath the flash and look of the game, and by doing so uncovered the recurring themes that are present throughout the game. Link jumps between his child and adolescent self throughout the game, and Jeffries identifies the different techniques used to emphasize his his perspective at a certain age. I found this very intriguing, since the last time I played this game was in the first grade. At the time, I was mentally incapable of interpreting this very profound theme, but now I can reminisce on my memories of gameplay and recall the very examples that Jeffries uses.

Playing this game as a first grader, I can distinctly remember the fear that struck me while encountering the challenges of the night during Link's youth. While Jeffries discussed the theme of Link's coming of age, I thought the player's age during gameplay could have been discussed as well, since the game obviously can't be experienced without a person playing it.