Showing posts with label Reading Response 1. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Reading Response 1. Show all posts

Tuesday, January 6, 2015

Reading Response 1 - Erin Lupardus



            Although I personally have never played any of the Legend of Zelda franchise, after reading both articles, I better understand the importance of the series and how revolutionary Ocarina of Time truly was in multiple aspects. Peer Schneider of IGN approaches the game from a typical review standpoint, breaking down the game's accomplishments in gameplay, data management, graphics, sound, and replay value. However, his review includes his own emotions playing the game for the first time; his preconception of the game's excellence before even playing could be considered a bias, but it reflects the franchise's overwhelmingly positive acclaim. L.B. Jeffries of Kill Screen focuses specifically on Link's character development and the game's theme of maturity. According to Jeffries, the game demonstrates that "Maturity is not just about being older and bigger, and only by learning to appreciate being Young Link, to appreciate your past and your youth, do you finally attain this status."
            Both authors explore the game's soundtrack. Schneider praises the game's marvelous soundtrack, but seems overly preoccupied with Koji Kondo's decision not to include the "legendary" Zelda Overworld theme. If the gameplay is as revolutionary as Schneider claims it to be, why must the music be restrained by previous musical ideas? Abandoning dated tunes does not condemn the game at all--rather, new music reinforces the game's definition of maturity. Jeffries emphasizes the effect of the changing ocarina melodies based on Link's age, and this design is incredibly subtle yet significant. He also discusses the disparities between Link's weapons as a child and adult, but because the Ocarina is unchanging throughout time, the different melodies highlight Link's maturing mind--he is the sole creator of these melodies from his own imagination. However, Schneider points out that the game does feature old favorites such as the Adagio in Kakariko town. Kondo's choice to incorporate familiar tunes proves Sheik's comment that “A thing that doesn’t change with time is a memory of younger days.” Link grows older, wiser, and stronger, but childish imaginativeness and pluck will always live within him.

Questions: How important is music to the overall impact and experience of a game? Can music history and art history fit in the same category?

Reading Response 1 - Jake Hagan

The articles we were assigned to read for class drew many comparative similarities like the two videos we watched in class on our first day. The first article, by Peer Shcneider, gives the utmost amount of praise and respect for the game, saying, "A break-through title from Nintendo that deserves all the hype and praise it's gotten... My highest possible recommendation." The author throughout his article seems to give a very opinionated viewpoint of the game and even the series as a whole. I do enjoy how the article itself is structured though. Mr. Schneider provides different sections including; Gameplay, data management, graphics, and sound. Also by providing these categories, he is providing insight further into the game itself, attempting to attract the reader into liking the game as much as the author does.  

The second article we looked at "Childish Ambitions" by L.B. Jeffries, was certainly much less of a review and more of an evaluation and look into the actual development of the character of Link. It looks deeper into how this new game portrays his journey throughout the game. This article gets into the more minor details of the game, like the fact that Link has a slingshot instead a bow and arrow when he is "Young Link" compared to "Old Link". This is giving deeper meaning to the innocence and vulnerability of the youth. Jeffries wrote a much more detailed piece to support the growth of Link from his youth to adulthood and the many changes and symbolism that was portrayed in doing so.

 While I believe both were well written articles, I had an easier time giving more credit to the second article "Childish Ambitions". The IGN article seemed like even though the author tried to get more in depth by talking about gameplay and graphics, he is really only providing more praise for the game and why it is, "The new benchmark for interactive entertainment." The second article providing a much more "third party view" on the game and gave us more of the facts and information that makes us want to form our own opinions on the game and whether we agree or not. When compared to the other article, which pretty much shoved the opinion in your face yelling, "GO GET THIS GAME!" I would rather be able to form my own opinions on the topic and go from there.

Reading Response 1 - Sam McManus

The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time is considered by many to be the greatest game ever developed. The score IGN gave it is a reflection of that opinion, as are the scores it got from numerous other reviewers. From an era of video games that were drastically limited by hardware restrictions compared to today, Ocarina of Time is one of the few games that manages to hold its own amongst a flurry of newer, shiner games that comparatively have much more to offer. It is a game that many people grew up with, and I have it sitting both next to my N64 and in my 3DS, a testament to just how well it holds up even today. At face value, it is a very simple game; boy goes on quest to save the world, matures both physically and mentally during his adventures, and destroys the villain, saving the world. But there is so much going on beneath this simple premise that makes Ocarina of Time on of the most enjoyable and intricate games ever created, secrets and adventures lie in wait for every gamer who puts that retro three pronged controller into their hands.

On the scene of video games, there is the ever popular event of "speed running", completing a game as quickly as possible. Inside of speed running, there are categories pertaining to how each game is completed, with the use of outside aids, internal glitches, or completing the game 100% how it was meant to be played. Ocarina of Time is famous for being both notoriously hard to run, but also incredibly enjoyable to watch, as some of the glitches performed allow the incredible completion time of under 20 minutes and make absolutely no sense whatsoever. As the IGN review noted, it takes around 30 hours to run through the game, 80 if you are really trying to get everything done, and yet a handful of people have beaten it in a fraction of that time, and new glitches and routes are being discovered or perfected that allow even quicker completion. Amazing hidden secrets like this continue to give the game longevity, despite over a decade’s worth of new technology and software mounting up against it.

Reading Response 1 - George Grayson

George Grayson
Professor Evans
Video Games in Art Historical Context
5 January 2015
Reading Response #1
       Based on the articles I have read, “Review: The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time” by Peer Schneider and “Childhood Ambitions: The Journey to Maturity and Back” by L.B. Jeffries, it is safe to say that The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time was an extremely influential and well-developed video game. In Schneider’s article, he absolutely praises the game. He does not cease to discuss every aspect and element of it, because in his opinion, every detail is executed flawlessly. There were minor hiccups about the game that got irritating, but he quickly overlooked them. In a historical sense, Schneider begins the article with a comparison of the enjoyment of playing this game to the enjoyment of playing the original Zelda game on the NES in 1987. He then compares some of the gameplay to other classic N64 games, but still boasts about the originality and creativity that went into this game’s production. He goes on to explain the new features that are available for the player to experiment with and he makes a point about the improvement of the overall Zelda franchise and how far it has come based on this game alone. While reading this article, this game truly seemed to be revolutionary for its time period and Schneider did not shy away from discussing the strengths of every feature in its adventurous setting.
       In Jefferies article, his view of the game is slightly contrasting. He in no way says anything negative about the game, he just feels it conveys a slightly deeper message compared to Schneider’s views. If you have played this game, which I personally have not, then I am certain you would no doubt connect to the game on a more personal level after reading this article. Jefferies frequently emphasizes how the aging of Link allows the player of the game to reminisce on his/her childhood and reflect on times in their lives when they felt both inferior and superior to others. This article is more along the lines of a synopsis of the game rather than a review, because Jefferies never explained how he felt about the gameplay, graphics, sound, etc. However, his emphasis on the theme of growing up from adolescence while explaining the plot of the game helped me understand how a frequent player of the game would connect with it on a personal level. I think this shows just how influential this game is, and not only that, it seems extremely well-made and entertaining.
       Questions that arose from both articles:
Schneider – Does comparing some of the elements in this game to games that came before it make it seem like this game cheated off features that have already been utilized in past N64 games?

Jeffries – Does writing an article connecting this game on a personal level market it better with people who have not played it? Or, does it spoil the feeling of playing it for the first time because people are already familiar with the game’s deeper message of adolescence and growing up? 

Reading Response 1 - Brannon Hamm

Both IGN and KillScreen touch on a systematic theme in their respective discussions of 1998’s eminent video game, The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time—but only when viewed in the meta context of a modern-day analyst returning to their aged work.  Their childlike wonder at mechanics that would be deemed simple by today’s standards reveal the source of what some call “nostalgia goggles”.  The game was released when the medium was new and revolutionary, when creative minds had free reign with burgeoning technology to innovate and astound with immediately recognizable leaps and bounds in video game presentation.  In short, the nature of the young genre of video games lead to a fast-paced, rapidly-improving reality that even a layman could appreciate and be shocked by. 
This had widespread effects, especially on the generation that was adolescent at the time.  They came of age in a world where artificial realities were interactive in a way that previous generation could never have imagined.  Where their parents made do with literature or film, the generation of Zelda shaped and earned their own fantasies using nothing but a gamepad.  In the years since 1998 gamers have become accustomed to realistic simulations of wildlife and picture-perfect textures with ridiculously detailed tessellation, but when OoT was released, the addition of an intricate fishing minigame was enough to warrant mention in an IGN review.  The ability to ride a horse boggled the minds of professional video game critics.  A deep, meaningful story rocked the video game world, and “set a new standard”. 

In short, OoT represents the pinnacle of an era where many professed “gamers” thought anything was possible.  It signifies a mythical time that many long for to this day, when technology promised a world that was perhaps better than our own; if not as detailed, then at least more rewarding.  

Monday, January 5, 2015

Reading Response 1 - Brandon Wright

Both of the articles for the reading were reviews of “The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time”. One article was from IGN.com written by Peer Schneider, and the other from Kill Screen Magazine by L.B. Jeffries and even though they were reviewing the same exact game, they took completely different looks at the game.

The article in IGN was the stereotypical game review with critiques of the graphical capabilities of the game, the smoothness of the game play, the inventiveness of new mechanics, etc. Although I wouldn't necessarily call it a critique of anything. It almost seemed as if IGN was attempting to write an advertisement for the game. There was almost nothing negative said about the game in the entire review. It could do no wrong in the eyes of Mr. Schneider, or if there was a flaw it was a “little flaw” or “annoying”. For all I know, however, IGN is right. I have never played Ocarina of Time but from a readers standpoint that would be thinking of buying the game, I would be slightly perturbed by the amount of praise and lack of criticism. The author does openly state “I have to confess that I'm a long time fan of the Zelda series.”

On the other hand there is Kill Screen, “Childish Ambitions” (The Articles actual title) is not a standard game review, it really isn't one. It is an interpretation of the events of the game to show a narrative of “The Journey to maturity – and back” as the article is sub-titled. However, without an understanding of the Ocarina of Time before reading this article, many of the events and scenes that the article mentions is unknown. I don't know how accurately Mr. Jeffries is portraying the scenes mentioned but his connection of maturity and the weapons used by young Link and old Link, and the Items you gain access to when aged is an interesting mechanic in the game. It is similar to a leveling system or a progression lock on items but makes the player feel much more accomplished in earning the ability to use the item than just “You are level 4 now, you may use this item.”

Kill Screen and IGN both take a look at the Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time, but Kill Screen ultimately ends up just doing better, even from my ignorant perspective. Kill Screen really fleshed out the underlying themes of the game and even showed some of the mechanics present, such as the item progression after aging 7 years. IGN was just TOO overtly positive and came across as sounding like obsessive fans attempting to sway a new customer to buy their favorite game.

Reading Response 1 - Joel Kauth

The IGN and Kill Screen reviews of The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time differed in the way that the game was presented. The IGN review provided insight regarding the incorporation of Link's adventure into the N64 format, while also comparing and contrasting the gameplay of different N64 video games (specifically Super Mario 64). The Kill Screen review instead explicates the story line in the game, emphasizing on Link's coming of age near the conclusion as well as Link's differing perspectives from his youth and adolescent self.

The IGN review was comparable to a teenager showing a "The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time virgin" the game for the very first time. While being very careful not to reveal the secrets of the game, Schneider explained the controller layout as well as the differing nuances compared to other games. On multiple occasions, Schneider continues to reaffirm his stance on why The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time was the best available N64 game at that time by an incredibly large margin. I think that the review can't be considered a critique, as there is no balance between positive and negative aspects of the game, and the author himself seem a tad biased as he continually gushes over the game.

Kill Screen's L.B. Jeffries explored the depths underneath the flash and look of the game, and by doing so uncovered the recurring themes that are present throughout the game. Link jumps between his child and adolescent self throughout the game, and Jeffries identifies the different techniques used to emphasize his his perspective at a certain age. I found this very intriguing, since the last time I played this game was in the first grade. At the time, I was mentally incapable of interpreting this very profound theme, but now I can reminisce on my memories of gameplay and recall the very examples that Jeffries uses.

Playing this game as a first grader, I can distinctly remember the fear that struck me while encountering the challenges of the night during Link's youth. While Jeffries discussed the theme of Link's coming of age, I thought the player's age during gameplay could have been discussed as well, since the game obviously can't be experienced without a person playing it.


Reading Response 1 - Charlotte DeLay

Both the IGN review and Kill Screen’s article for The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time are able to provide insight about the franchise as a whole. Although one talks more about the surface of the game and its gameplay, the other takes a deeper approach to truly analyze the narrative that the game’s story weaves. Their main arguments are both trying to analyze the integrity of the game and how it has been different from that of others in the Legend of Zelda franchise. However, it must be noted that both articles are highly opinionated and praise Ocarina of Time because of its difference from other Zelda games.

IGN and Kill Screen are essentially complimenting the same core parts of the game to support their arguments, but what differs is the depth of the analysis of these core aspects. The IGN review is simply gliding over the surface of the Ocarina of Time to give players a brief preview of the game, while Kill Screen decides to talk about how the game immerses the player in order to live through the journey of adulthood by playing as Link. By taking certain sections of the narrative to analyze, Kill Screen is able to create a coherent and meaningful piece than that of IGN. IGN on the other hand, is able to review Ocarina of Time in such a way that not only shows the positive and awe-struck position they have, but also allows them to sell Ocarina of Time. Kill Screen expects its readers to know about Ocarina of Time to a certain extent, while IGN simply nods to those that have, but introduces the game to an audience that hasn’t heard much about it. IGN’s positive feedback allow readers to believe that Ocarina of Time is worth the score that is received at the end of the review because of how much the reviewer builds upon his own excitement for the game.

However, both the arguments from IGN and from Kill Screen are flawed in certain aspects. Kill Screen expects readers to already know much about Ocarina of Time and the Legend of Zelda franchise. It is able to summarize certain points of the narrative for first-timers to understand the story of Ocarina of Time, but fails to explain properly how it “comes closest to making Link a dynamic character” compared with that of other Zelda games. Kill Screen assumes that readers have played other Legend of Zelda games in order to validate its claim. In order to properly prove its positive opinion, Kill Screen should compare other Legend of Zelda games to show how undeveloped of a character Link is. Not only would this amplify Kill Screen’s assertion, but also boost its opinion on why Ocarina of Time is able to  break out of the mold from other Zelda games.

As for IGN, its flaw is the sheer amount of positive opinions that it projects from its review of Ocarina of Time. It doesn’t allow for many negative comments, and tries to convey the overall enjoyment that the reviewer had, rather than what flaws might be present in the game itself. If the reviewer was able to take away this bias, his review would be more balanced. As a way to still show the uniqueness of Ocarina of Time, IGN could have been able to have a personal thoughts section so the other sections weren’t overloaded with bias. This way, those sections could be more fleshed out while still being able to have the reviewer portray his own opinion on Ocarina of Time.

Reading Response 1 - Jacob Boudreau

No doubt that The Legend of Zelda series is an amazing series for both content and mechanics, but it also has one of the most interesting and confusing official timelines, which adds to the awesomeness.

The articles are both about The Legend of Zelda: The Ocarina of Time, but both talk about the title in very different terms.

The first article was written by Peer Schneider, an employee of IGN. This article had mix content of a traditional game review as well as some personal experiences of the game. Peer went into in depth detail about many of the aspects of the game. He talked about the graphics, mechanics, and story, and in each of these he talks about how different they are from other games. Super Mario 64, GoldenEye,   F-Zero X, and Banjo-Kazooie are all compared to Ocarina. Peer doesn’t simply talk about how the game is, he also talks about how it was embraced at IGN. He talks about seven-teen hour gaming sessions and their jaws dropping to the floor. It is a typical review article with a small twist.

The second article, written by L. B. Jeffries, takes a different path from the first. This is more of an essay than the first, but it is still an article in KillScreen issue 0. This article talked about the idea of maturity and how age played a major role throughout the game. I myself have never played Ocarina of Time due to my grandmother running over my Nintendo 64 power cable with the vacuum and my parents not wanting to spend the money on another one. Despite that, I still know of the game, and this article painted it in a new light. I would have never seen the phallic nature of Ganon’s tail and how the final battle is a battle of masculinity. This article brought about new thoughts to an old game.


My one question is why did Jeffries not include all of the controversy that came along with Ocarina? Despite the game being a masterpiece, there was a lot of controversy about how the game used Islamic symbols and songs in an insensitive way. One of the biggest issues is about the chanting in the Fire Temple. The chanting comes from the holy song Adhan, or the call to prayer. By using the song in this way, the song is being disgraced. Gaijin Goombah explains the issue in detail in this video (2:30). For such a big game, I do wonder why neither author talked about the controversies involved with the game.