Tuesday, January 6, 2015

Reading Response 1 - Jake Hagan

The articles we were assigned to read for class drew many comparative similarities like the two videos we watched in class on our first day. The first article, by Peer Shcneider, gives the utmost amount of praise and respect for the game, saying, "A break-through title from Nintendo that deserves all the hype and praise it's gotten... My highest possible recommendation." The author throughout his article seems to give a very opinionated viewpoint of the game and even the series as a whole. I do enjoy how the article itself is structured though. Mr. Schneider provides different sections including; Gameplay, data management, graphics, and sound. Also by providing these categories, he is providing insight further into the game itself, attempting to attract the reader into liking the game as much as the author does.  

The second article we looked at "Childish Ambitions" by L.B. Jeffries, was certainly much less of a review and more of an evaluation and look into the actual development of the character of Link. It looks deeper into how this new game portrays his journey throughout the game. This article gets into the more minor details of the game, like the fact that Link has a slingshot instead a bow and arrow when he is "Young Link" compared to "Old Link". This is giving deeper meaning to the innocence and vulnerability of the youth. Jeffries wrote a much more detailed piece to support the growth of Link from his youth to adulthood and the many changes and symbolism that was portrayed in doing so.

 While I believe both were well written articles, I had an easier time giving more credit to the second article "Childish Ambitions". The IGN article seemed like even though the author tried to get more in depth by talking about gameplay and graphics, he is really only providing more praise for the game and why it is, "The new benchmark for interactive entertainment." The second article providing a much more "third party view" on the game and gave us more of the facts and information that makes us want to form our own opinions on the game and whether we agree or not. When compared to the other article, which pretty much shoved the opinion in your face yelling, "GO GET THIS GAME!" I would rather be able to form my own opinions on the topic and go from there.

No comments:

Post a Comment