Showing posts with label Reading Response 3. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Reading Response 3. Show all posts

Monday, January 12, 2015

Reading Response 3 - Brannon Hamm

The expansion of the avant-garde video game has, according to Schrank, pushed the limits of what video games can do.  His definition of “avant-garde” is one that I found very illuminating—I like the idea that the term “avant-garde” is merely a descriptor applied to games that violate the understood contract between the game creator and the game enjoyer.  In that sense there are many games that I myself have played (and enjoyed!) that could be considered avant-garde.  This is surprising to me because the label has always been one of derogatory artistic elitism as I have known it, and the idea that it has merit as a descriptor with no implication toward a game’s artistic value is interesting to me. 
Dark Souls is exemplary of the phenomenon I describe; it is not political or self-indulgent, so when I played it I didn’t think of it as avant-garde.  But it artistically violates the creator-player contract in interesting and innovative ways, and in that way it falls within Schrank’s paradigm.  It doesn’t give the player direction, it gives the player tools; if the player can figure out the story and finish the game, good for them.  It makes discovering the fact of the game’s story a part of the game itself, thereby pressing the bounds of what video games are. 

It’s always interesting to me when the ideas I previously held about a given word are challenged.  I believe in the inherent value of all words, and to be frank the definition that I understood avant-garde to possess dissatisfied me.  I’m happy to attribute Schrank’s definition to it because it now can take an interesting place in any art-critic’s lexicon, as opposed to being merely a tool used to put down works for being perceived to be too self-indulgent.  

Reading Response 3 - Joel Kauth

Avant-garde Videogames by Brian Schrank explored the different ways videogames could or couldn't be defined as "art" throughout their years of formation and evolving from the avant-garde perspective. The article made it clear that as certain games were developed, over time they could not be considered avant-garde as they lost the essence about them that was new and different. To me, the most compelling observation made by Schrank was the parallel drawn between September 12th and Heavy Weapon: Atomic Tank. He was able to differentiate mainstream and avant-garde simply through laying out the game's goals, and my visceral reaction created by my own experience with games similar to Atomic Tank as well as the perspective of the citizens turned terrorists being employed by the game. This comparison separated two games by their applicability, as well as their implications politically and culturally by emphasizing that we are always the "good guys", and subtly dialing in on the reactions of the villagers of the Arab town.

On page 18, I found that Duchamp's incorporation of a urinal into a fountain made a bold statement against the perception of art. The urinal, or fountain's, role could be seen as, "It foregrounds and acsthcticizes the ways in which we normally sense-or more accurately, fail to sense-technology." (Schrank 18). This idea is hugely similar to the argument on whether videogames can be considered art, as the statement made by Schrank as its artistic purpose is to challenge the way that we consider a certain technology to be used. Although Fountain was rejected by the Society of Independent Artists, his action is considered to be a huge challenge to both sides of avant-garde, and was able to be employed regarding whether videogames can be considered art, which I believe that they can.

Sunday, January 11, 2015

Reading Response 3 - Charlotte DeLay

In Shrank’s novel involving video games and the avant-garde of video games, Shrank talks about what defines a video game and how it should be considered a work of art. He claims that there are many ways that video games are able to express an artistic view and how players are able to experience an immersion that is as impactful as other works of art unrelated to video games. With that said, it should be noted that there are some points in his argument that don’t exactly match with his claim. For instance, although now it’s more possible as an outlet for an artistic statement, it should be noted that not all games should be considered ‘art’ based on his definition. There are some games, like pong, which have little to no meaning. Back during the times of early development of video games, there were many people that didn't even know exactly what to do with the outlet. Many were experimental in terms of trying to appeal to the public, but not as an art statement. What should also be made apparent is that the intention of a video game's creator should be put into perspective. Although glanced on by Shrank involving the Sims, there were still others that had little purpose other than to copy a competent movie franchise, or to appeal to an emerging group interested in the medium of video games. By no means does this mark out all video games as being some form of art, but Shrank did neglect to exactly mention those types of games involved to help strengthen his point over how he feels video games should be treated and looked upon.

The other post involving Barnet is able to show the type of reviewing and analyzing style to use for artworks. Although it doesn't mention anything involving video games, it can be applicable for analyzing video games as an artwork as well. In fact, based on the read, it seems as if Shrank from the other reading used these aspects for his novel involving video games as an artwork. Barnet’s book is able to give prime examples on how to examine and analyze a piece of artwork. Through this, many other reviews of what could be considered artwork could be used for analysis, although not what was initially expected of the writer. Both articles are able to correlate to one another because of this common link involving the analysis of artwork.

Reading Response 3 - Sam McManus

Video games as art has been a matter of debate for some time now, with many well established critics both siding for and against the notion. Even some of my friends have had input on the matter, although most agree that video games are not yet an art form. The first article, Playing with Technoculture plays with the idea of video games being a sort of avant-garde art form, something that is new and not yet established, and therefore not widely recognized. To argue this point, author Brian Shrank looks at the subcultures that form around and inside video games, much as previous art forms had their own unique subcultures. Because video games have matured along a similar path as other art styles, and the idea of elite and popular cultures have all but completely fused, it’s hard to distinguish between what can and cannot be classified as art.  Being relatively new to the art scene, only time will tell if video games will eventually be allowed into the exclusive club of art.

The second article, aptly titled A Short Guide to Writing about Art by Sylvan Barnet, is a guide to writing academically about art. Because we have not yet defined video games as art, this is more of a preemptive piece if deciding to write about video games as an art form. It makes itself absolutely clear that when writing about art, there really can’t be one concrete analysis, and it is up to interpretation, “which merely represents an opinion” (Barnet 13). It continues to assess how art is to be analyzed; much like literature, art must be scrutinized, paid close attention to, and be observed from multiple angles, and why it creates meaning within itself. Techniques used are essential in determining the artistic nature of the piece, and how it conveys itself and its style. Much like art, video games possess characteristics that set them apart from each other, even if they appear to be similar at face value.

Reading Response 3 - Jacob Boudreau

This was a great read. It is the most academic read that we have done so far. The premise that Schrank is putting forward is that video games are an art form, specifically an Avant-garde art. Avant-garde is an experimental or an innovative way of doing something related to culture. In this case, video games are the next Avant-grade art.

Schrank makes some pretty compelling cases for video games being Avant-grade art. The most compelling case for me was the September 12th game. Schrank compares it to Heavy Weapon: Atomic Tank and how each one, just as art, comments on a specific point in history. September 12th takes a simple shooter, like Heavy Weapon: Atomic Tank, and critiques America’s war on terror. This made me really think about my stance. I understood that video games critiqued real-world events, such as the Grand Theft Auto games, but to pin those games against another game that doesn’t really do much in the effort of critique is really compelling. Both games were fun but one was an Avant-garde art. September 12th actually uses real life consequences for doing certain things. Like how killing innocents will increase the spite of others. This made me really think about games and whether they are an art form or not.

With Schrank’s compelling evidence of Avant-garde art and video games I think that there is a split in video games. My big counter to Anna Anthropy was that she changed the definition of the word games for her own argument. She left out that games are for pleasure, not experience. Schrank does not openly talk about the nature of games but he does talk about what makes up a game. On page nine, he uses a chart by Jesper Juul that explains what a game is. I agree with all of what Juul says makes a game a game, but I do think he left something out. He left out that a game is played for pleasure. This is where the split is. Games are for leisure while art is an obligation. Bolter says in the forward that art is considered a way of cultural enrichment. If video games are art, then why do some many people say the exact opposite? I cannot tell you the number of times my mother has told me that video games are destroying my mind. Why do people have such an opposite view? I think that there is a split in the things we call games. Schrank uses charts in pages 20, 22, and 25 to show what video games classify under. In each one he labels the mainstream games, such as Nintendo and Minecraft. There is a distinct difference between what is considered a game and what people like Schrank want to be a game. This is where I draw a line, literally. I think those mainstream games are the only games and avant-grade games, like September 12th and the others Schrank mentions, are a new art form. They are not games they are something else. This is not saying that games cannot be art, it is saying that those games that are considered art are not games. There is a split and I think it is where pleasure changes to emotional connection. Games are meant to be played and have fun playing, despite the profanity being shouted from the patrons. Art is not limited to just pleasure. A good pieces of art will not only make you feel happy but also sad, upset, nervous, and everything else.


Video games are just that, video games. Those that are made for the sake of art are something else. I suggest that they be called art, because that is what they are. That game that I played over the weekend, The Entertainment, was not a game. I felt like it should have been in my American Lit class in high school. It was just a story being told through the eyes of a bar patron. It was not a game, but a virtual story. 

Reading Response 3 - Kevin Feller

The Forward starts out talking about how there will be a big debate over the avant-garde videogames and if they are a type of art form in this century or not. I personally think that they are a form of art because the creation of videogames takes a lot of coding and design. These codes are the paint of videogames or the pixels of a camera; they are what gives this form of entertainment life. There are people that this foreword talks about that clearly do not agree with my thinking. People who are older and do not play videogames will never understand the art form like those that actually play these games. Each person has a passion for art and I think that videogames can be an art form.  
            In chapter one I really like how they are attacking the fact that videogames are an art form, and that they were actually first ever created for military purpose such as flight simulators and other devices that help war veterans become better at the area of expertise they are residing in. another important part of videogames is teaching people that even if you fail, you can always keep trying and progressing until you get it right. This can be an art of achievement in ones ability to put aside how hard something is and really focus on the main goal of breaking or accomplishing that specific task. A change in techno culture is also brought up in chapter one and I think this is one of the main reasons that videogames should be seen as an art. Now that videogames can be created, a new culture, this one being of a technological area, makes videogames a new type of art. It is different than that of drawing, painting, or acting. Videogames have a different category of art that has been explored and has been developing since the first ever arcade games.

            Another key point is brought up in this chapter about what are considered artsy games and what aren’t. Games to show a specific goal for the player and have fixed rules with variable outcomes would be a very artistically made game. The counterpart of this would be a game that has none of those attributes.

Reading Response 3 - George Grayson

After reading the foreword and the first chapter of “Avante-Garde Videogames: Playing with Technoculture” by Brian Shrank, I have learned that there are much deeper artistically significant themes within video games that I have not even noticed growing up. First, Jay David Bolter starts off Shrank’s book with a foreword regarding how well the book stands out in the importance of video games. Bolter acknowledges that Shrank’s book is distinct in purely emphasizing the history of 20th century art. He is willing to accept Shrank’s view that video games are in fact art, much like movies, music, or really any other form of media that requires skill to master. Bolter makes the claim that traditional art students will not be interested in playing avant-garde video games. I think he his right to some extent, because most students, regardless of their area of study, will mainly gear themselves toward more mainstream games. However, I don’t think that Bolter should jump to assumptions of what art students would be interested in. Simply because someone chooses to study art does not mean that they are subjected to only playing games along those lines. If certain games offer new and experimental takes on society that are unusual, I think it’s ultimately up to the player to decide what he/she wants to play.

            That being said, the first chapter of Shrank’s book introduces multiple video games that Shrank believes would assist in classifying the differences between what “mainstream” is and what “avant-garde” is. The two games he begins with both express real world references and contain very particular themes and elements within their gameplay. The first game he mentions, Heavy Weapon: Atomic Tank (2005), became commercially successful within the mainstream. The second game he mentions, September 12th (2003), did not quite flow as well with what was popular at the time. Though both games contain historical elements, Shrank comes to the conclusion that Heavy Weapon is a simpler, more close-minded game that is straight-forward enough to be fun and enjoyable. September 12th contains complex political ideas and seemed to establish itself too much as an advertisement of the government as it was combatting the war on terror at the time. Shrank concludes his discussion of these two games by stating that Heavy Weapon became prevalent in the mainstream because it had a more singular flow that kept the mainstream strong, whereas September 12th had a more intricate flow that deviated from the simplicity of the mainstream. All in all, I think Shrank believes that avant-garde games are not unnecessary, they’re just a new take on an already vast, established industry.

Reading Response 3 - Jake Hagan

The piece by Brian Schrank is one that caused me to start asking many questions about what video games actually are and the way we view them. One of the first pieces of the text that sparked this influx of queries in my mind was on page eight after Schrank had just finished talking about the Pollock paintings and Alberti, Denis, and LeWitt. The question that really got me thinking was, “Are paintings illusions, materials, concepts, or something else still?” One question I asked was: Who is to say that all of these characteristics cannot describe what a painting is? I believe that the piece almost seems to try and confine the boundaries of what this art of video games can be. Why is it necessary to try and put a cap on what exactly “games” are? In my mind, it is not necessary. In order for new “avant-garde” games to be created, there needs to be no limit on what defines a game. This could only cause harm to the art form that is games that many have come to enjoy.

 It is easy to see that there is not one single form of “video game” out in the world today. This provides a pathway to the possibility of a greater variety of games that gamers can choose from. The model also located on page eight is one that could cause a little bit of a stir though. The model incorrectly eliminates many different forms of games/video games that do not follow the six guidelines that define a game that Juul’s model depicts. I am not disputing that her six characteristics in fact do not follow what a game is, rather that she is not leaving much room for the different types in the world. In all honesty, I do not see why it is even needed in the first place that people try and argue about what defines a game and what does not. In the end, what does it matter what exactly we call the game (or “not game”)? Personally, if people enjoy interacting with the media then I do not feel it necessary to go any further than that. Who cares then at that point whether it is considered a game or not? It is not like we see Pollock, DaVinci, or Dali disputing what exactly their art is; all they know is that they enjoyed interacting with the medium they chose to work with.

Reading Response 3 - Erin Lupardus



     According to the Oxford English Dictionary, the avant-garde is "the pioneers or innovators in any art in a particular period." Given Schrank's analysis of the current progression of video games, avant-garde games challenge the "prevailing paradigm of flow" (7), but I believe there comes a point when too much revolutionizing creates an entirely new art form. For example, some digital paintings and more traditional mediums mimic similar subjects, but they do not belong in the same category because different tools are used to create them. Yes, they are both works of art and can have the same effect, but just because digital paintings test the boundaries of traditional art does not mean they can still be considered traditional art. Schrank refers to Jackson Pollock's art as an example of paintings that challenged painting itself. However, Pollock did not break the definition of painting; rather, he used the tools of painting to create a different result than what was expected. Schrank aims to explore the "broadest" (7) definition of games as possible, but arguing semantics avoids the idea that video games may have evolved into something new entirely.

     Video games can be interactive art, but not all interactive art are video games. Schrank includes Juul's diagram of what can be considered games and what is not, but he finds the definition too exclusive. I would argue that Juul's definition is correct. Games have "fixed rules, a variable outcome, valorization of outcome, player effort, player attachment to outcome, and negotiable consequences" (9). Interactive art such as "The Entertainment" and "Dys4ia" are thought-provoking, powerful outlets for storytelling, but they are not games. "The Entertainment" has no rules, negotiable consequences or variable outcome. It is essentially a play with a different art style and optional order of observing. "Dys4ia" lacks similar qualities. This does not diminish their effectiveness, but classifying them as video games in order to prove a point is incorrect. "The Stanley Parable" and "How Do You Do It" are both games and art because they have all the qualities of a game along with a unique, beautiful, and interesting message to share. Anna Anthropy similarly argued about the definition of video games in Rise of the Videogame Zinesters, but definitions are important. It is a shame that "literally" literally means "figuratively" now because of the people's misuse of the word in everyday language. Yes, there are avant-garde examples of true video games, but art forms evolve and need not stick to their roots in order to make a point.

Friday, January 9, 2015

Reading Response 3 - Brandon Wright

In Avant-Garde Videogames: Playing with Technoculture Brian Schrank makes the argument that videogames are not just art, but there are multiple avant-garde movements in this medium that challenge the status quo and sometimes even the definition of the medium itself.

To start off though, Mr. Schrank talks about the avant-garde he says it isn't “about negation, and presumably, the more critical and offensive it is, the better, or at least the more avant-garde.”He quotes Hal Foster disputing “... the assumption that “one theory can comprehend the avant-garde.” Schrank continues on to talk about classifications of avant-garde strategies and even includes a very nice graph with some big names that people know of to give them frameworks of where something might lie on the graph. These strategies are formal, and political which he sub divides into radical and complicit. This results in a square graph not unlike a Dungeons and Dragons alignment chart.

In the illustration provided by Schrank, Political is the left wall of a square, Radical the top, Complicit the bottom, and Formal the right, with a portion of the bottom right corner shaded in and labeled “Mainstream” and therefore not avant-garde this includes things like EVE Online, Nintendo and Jesper Juul.

According to Schrank, formal avant-garde games “manifest the irreducibility of play that lives beyond the familiar flow.” they challenge conventional goals and game play through a raw, more essential experience. However Schrank warns that some enthusiasts think that the player has to be able to read intentions or the artists expression in the work but argues “Perhaps the more that formal games are able to “speak” for themselves, the more provocative the experiences of playing them can be.”


The other “form” of avant-garde, Political, is more denial based. Schrank even says “Historically, political avant-garde artists played with the category of art itself, frequently denying that the work they were making could even be categorized as art” and even talks about game artists that don't claim their work is a game.

After explaining the type of avant-garde and their subdivisions and showing where larger names in the artistic fields would lie on Schranks graph I was honestly put off by his placement of Minecraft, I may be biased towards the game itself as I was a backer of the game during its beta development, but I saw it as being at least defined as somewhat avant-garde. During a craze of pushing games into photorealism, Minecraft was released that challenged goal oriented gameplay and photorealism. Instead it decided to drop you into a world with only a few tooltips on how to do things, and then told you to do whatever you wanted. And at the same time represented it in a pixelated form quite the opposite from the current craze.