KillScreen focuses on how when Link is younger he cannot do the same things he can when he is older and they apply this to real life situations, I think this is a very deep way to think about a game that possibly is intended for younger audiences. A child playing playing this game would not have the same opinion of the an adult playing this game because a child has not experienced adolescence. Children will probably think that going seven years into the future is just another cool feature of "leveling up." I just think it is pretty amazing on how differently the two website viewed and critiqued The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time.
DePauw University | Winter Term 2015 | Prof. Chaz Evans
Tuesday, January 6, 2015
Reading Response 1 - Ryan Grizzard
The two articles that we read today discussed The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time but they talked about the game in two different ways. IGN was giving more of a review and a description of the game while KillScreen talked more about the maturity level of Link throughout the game. IGN praised this game and they loved all the fun side adventures that are available to you while playing. They even gave it a perfect 10 out of 10 score saying that this was a "flawless victory." I have not played the game myself, but I watched a trailer of the game on metacritic.com and thought the game at best was slightly above mediocre. The graphics were not as hyped up as IGN made them seem to be. I was intrigued by the actual game play and the different abilities that Link was able to do but I do not believe it would be a 10 out of 10. Maybe you have to play it in order to get the full experience and relate to how the critics at IGN feel about the game.
Monday, January 5, 2015
Reading Response 1 - Brandon Wright
Both of the articles
for the reading were reviews of “The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of
Time”. One article was from IGN.com written by Peer Schneider, and
the other from Kill Screen Magazine by L.B. Jeffries and even though
they were reviewing the same exact game, they took completely
different looks at the game.
The article in IGN
was the stereotypical game review with critiques of the graphical
capabilities of the game, the smoothness of the game play, the
inventiveness of new mechanics, etc. Although I wouldn't necessarily
call it a critique of anything. It almost seemed as if IGN was
attempting to write an advertisement for the game. There was almost
nothing negative said about the game in the entire review. It could
do no wrong in the eyes of Mr. Schneider, or if there was a flaw it
was a “little flaw” or “annoying”. For all I know, however,
IGN is right. I have never played Ocarina of Time but from a readers
standpoint that would be thinking of buying the game, I would be
slightly perturbed by the amount of praise and lack of criticism. The
author does openly state “I have to confess that I'm a long time
fan of the Zelda series.”
On the other hand
there is Kill Screen, “Childish Ambitions” (The Articles actual
title) is not a standard game review, it really isn't one. It is an
interpretation of the events of the game to show a narrative of “The
Journey to maturity – and back” as the article is sub-titled.
However, without an understanding of the Ocarina of Time before
reading this article, many of the events and scenes that the article
mentions is unknown. I don't know how accurately Mr. Jeffries is
portraying the scenes mentioned but his connection of maturity and
the weapons used by young Link and old Link, and the Items you gain
access to when aged is an interesting mechanic in the game. It is
similar to a leveling system or a progression lock on items but makes
the player feel much more accomplished in earning the ability to use
the item than just “You are level 4 now, you may use this item.”
Kill Screen and IGN both take a look at the Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time, but Kill Screen ultimately ends up just doing better, even from my ignorant perspective. Kill Screen really fleshed out the underlying themes of the game and even showed some of the mechanics present, such as the item progression after aging 7 years. IGN was just TOO overtly positive and came across as sounding like obsessive fans attempting to sway a new customer to buy their favorite game.
Reading Response 1 - Joel Kauth
The IGN and Kill Screen reviews of The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time differed in the way that the game was presented. The IGN review provided insight regarding the incorporation of Link's adventure into the N64 format, while also comparing and contrasting the gameplay of different N64 video games (specifically Super Mario 64). The Kill Screen review instead explicates the story line in the game, emphasizing on Link's coming of age near the conclusion as well as Link's differing perspectives from his youth and adolescent self.
The IGN review was comparable to a teenager showing a "The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time virgin" the game for the very first time. While being very careful not to reveal the secrets of the game, Schneider explained the controller layout as well as the differing nuances compared to other games. On multiple occasions, Schneider continues to reaffirm his stance on why The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time was the best available N64 game at that time by an incredibly large margin. I think that the review can't be considered a critique, as there is no balance between positive and negative aspects of the game, and the author himself seem a tad biased as he continually gushes over the game.
Kill Screen's L.B. Jeffries explored the depths underneath the flash and look of the game, and by doing so uncovered the recurring themes that are present throughout the game. Link jumps between his child and adolescent self throughout the game, and Jeffries identifies the different techniques used to emphasize his his perspective at a certain age. I found this very intriguing, since the last time I played this game was in the first grade. At the time, I was mentally incapable of interpreting this very profound theme, but now I can reminisce on my memories of gameplay and recall the very examples that Jeffries uses.
Playing this game as a first grader, I can distinctly remember the fear that struck me while encountering the challenges of the night during Link's youth. While Jeffries discussed the theme of Link's coming of age, I thought the player's age during gameplay could have been discussed as well, since the game obviously can't be experienced without a person playing it.
The IGN review was comparable to a teenager showing a "The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time virgin" the game for the very first time. While being very careful not to reveal the secrets of the game, Schneider explained the controller layout as well as the differing nuances compared to other games. On multiple occasions, Schneider continues to reaffirm his stance on why The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time was the best available N64 game at that time by an incredibly large margin. I think that the review can't be considered a critique, as there is no balance between positive and negative aspects of the game, and the author himself seem a tad biased as he continually gushes over the game.
Kill Screen's L.B. Jeffries explored the depths underneath the flash and look of the game, and by doing so uncovered the recurring themes that are present throughout the game. Link jumps between his child and adolescent self throughout the game, and Jeffries identifies the different techniques used to emphasize his his perspective at a certain age. I found this very intriguing, since the last time I played this game was in the first grade. At the time, I was mentally incapable of interpreting this very profound theme, but now I can reminisce on my memories of gameplay and recall the very examples that Jeffries uses.
Playing this game as a first grader, I can distinctly remember the fear that struck me while encountering the challenges of the night during Link's youth. While Jeffries discussed the theme of Link's coming of age, I thought the player's age during gameplay could have been discussed as well, since the game obviously can't be experienced without a person playing it.
Reading Response 1- Natalie Santiago
One concept that arose in "Childish Ambitions: The Journey to Maturity and Back," was interesting to me because i appreciated the fact that what they discussed was the way that Legends of Zelda is not just a video game, but a story about maturity and development from childhood to adulthood. Link is transported seven years into the future and learns how to be a man by engaging in activities he was not allowed to do seven years prior, such as using his shield properly and being able to use his sword. In "Review: The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time," they are mostly praising the game for it's intense and unique qualities and how it was worth the wait because of all the new advancements. It is considered to be one of the best games of it's time because of the graphics and sound quality it contains among it's side projects of solving puzzles and exploring the game. The graphics and layout of the game remind me of Crash Bandicoot in the way its displayed and how the characters move. I don't understand why they chose to leave out manual jumping and how it does it automatically because i feel that gives you more control as the player and to deny the audience access to that deprives them of a certain privilege, as small as it may seem. It also reminds me of the game Jak and Daxter; it was my favorite video game as a kid and what i appreciated from this particular game was the jumping because when Jak jumps to get from one place to the next, he has to hop multiple times in the air. My question is why they didn't talk more about how Ocarina was the first of the series to have 3D graphics because i feel like that was the hype about the game and they could have contrasted it more against the rest of the series.
Reading Response 1 - Charlotte DeLay
Both the IGN review and Kill Screen’s article for The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time are able to provide insight about the franchise as a whole. Although one talks more about the surface of the game and its gameplay, the other takes a deeper approach to truly analyze the narrative that the game’s story weaves. Their main arguments are both trying to analyze the integrity of the game and how it has been different from that of others in the Legend of Zelda franchise. However, it must be noted that both articles are highly opinionated and praise Ocarina of Time because of its difference from other Zelda games.
IGN and Kill Screen are essentially complimenting the same core parts of the game to support their arguments, but what differs is the depth of the analysis of these core aspects. The IGN review is simply gliding over the surface of the Ocarina of Time to give players a brief preview of the game, while Kill Screen decides to talk about how the game immerses the player in order to live through the journey of adulthood by playing as Link. By taking certain sections of the narrative to analyze, Kill Screen is able to create a coherent and meaningful piece than that of IGN. IGN on the other hand, is able to review Ocarina of Time in such a way that not only shows the positive and awe-struck position they have, but also allows them to sell Ocarina of Time. Kill Screen expects its readers to know about Ocarina of Time to a certain extent, while IGN simply nods to those that have, but introduces the game to an audience that hasn’t heard much about it. IGN’s positive feedback allow readers to believe that Ocarina of Time is worth the score that is received at the end of the review because of how much the reviewer builds upon his own excitement for the game.
However, both the arguments from IGN and from Kill Screen are flawed in certain aspects. Kill Screen expects readers to already know much about Ocarina of Time and the Legend of Zelda franchise. It is able to summarize certain points of the narrative for first-timers to understand the story of Ocarina of Time, but fails to explain properly how it “comes closest to making Link a dynamic character” compared with that of other Zelda games. Kill Screen assumes that readers have played other Legend of Zelda games in order to validate its claim. In order to properly prove its positive opinion, Kill Screen should compare other Legend of Zelda games to show how undeveloped of a character Link is. Not only would this amplify Kill Screen’s assertion, but also boost its opinion on why Ocarina of Time is able to break out of the mold from other Zelda games.
As for IGN, its flaw is the sheer amount of positive opinions that it projects from its review of Ocarina of Time. It doesn’t allow for many negative comments, and tries to convey the overall enjoyment that the reviewer had, rather than what flaws might be present in the game itself. If the reviewer was able to take away this bias, his review would be more balanced. As a way to still show the uniqueness of Ocarina of Time, IGN could have been able to have a personal thoughts section so the other sections weren’t overloaded with bias. This way, those sections could be more fleshed out while still being able to have the reviewer portray his own opinion on Ocarina of Time.
Reading Response 1 - Jacob Boudreau
No doubt that The Legend of Zelda series is an amazing series
for both content and mechanics, but it also has one of the most interesting and
confusing official timelines, which adds to the awesomeness.
The articles are both about The Legend of Zelda: The Ocarina
of Time, but both talk about the title in very different terms.
The first article was written by Peer Schneider, an
employee of IGN. This article had mix content of a traditional game review as
well as some personal experiences of the game. Peer went into in depth detail
about many of the aspects of the game. He talked about the graphics, mechanics,
and story, and in each of these he talks about how different they are from other
games. Super Mario 64, GoldenEye, F-Zero
X, and Banjo-Kazooie are all compared to Ocarina. Peer doesn’t simply talk about
how the game is, he also talks about how it was embraced at IGN. He talks about
seven-teen hour gaming sessions and their jaws dropping to the floor. It is a
typical review article with a small twist.
The second article, written by L. B. Jeffries, takes a
different path from the first. This is more of an essay than the first, but it
is still an article in KillScreen issue 0. This article talked about the idea
of maturity and how age played a major role throughout the game. I myself have
never played Ocarina of Time due to my grandmother running over my Nintendo 64
power cable with the vacuum and my parents not wanting to spend the money on
another one. Despite that, I still know of the game, and this article painted
it in a new light. I would have never seen the phallic nature of Ganon’s tail
and how the final battle is a battle of masculinity. This article brought about
new thoughts to an old game.
My one question is why did Jeffries not include all of
the controversy that came along with Ocarina? Despite the game being a
masterpiece, there was a lot of controversy about how the game used Islamic
symbols and songs in an insensitive way. One of the biggest issues is about the
chanting in the Fire Temple. The chanting comes from the holy song Adhan, or
the call to prayer. By using the song in this way, the song is being disgraced.
Gaijin Goombah explains the issue in detail in this video (2:30). For such a big game,
I do wonder why neither author talked about the controversies involved with the
game.
How The Legend of Zelda Changed Gaming - Kevin Feller
The Legend of Zelda - Ocarina of Time showed a new type of game play that had people begging for more. I love the way that Link starts out as a young boy and then starts to become older and older, and then back again to young at the end of the game. This was much different than all games before, such as Mario 64. In Ocarina of Time I liked most that you were able to roam around and do whatever you wanted to. If you wanted to go fish, you could. If you wanted to go kill things, such as skeletons in the darkness of night, you could. You did not have to keep following the main story line the whole time. There was the ability to find the secrets around the map or blaze through as fast as possible to the end.
The graphics of Ocarina of time were much superior than all the other games of that time. The articles talk about the rolling hills, the changing from night into day and vise versa, and you could see the castle in the faint distance. I loved the gameplay when I was young and had a N64. This game reminds me of the likes of Fable 2 and the Fallout franchise. Some things that bothered me in this game were the inability to jump. The Jump was done for you, but that just did not seem right for having so much control of your character. Also I have a love hate relationship for the flute, only because I was never very good at hitting all the right notes and would rage quit at some points. Overall this game was in its own league of gaming because it was so much different graphically and had a very relaxed story line than all other games before. You had the ability control Link in every manor of the game.
The graphics of Ocarina of time were much superior than all the other games of that time. The articles talk about the rolling hills, the changing from night into day and vise versa, and you could see the castle in the faint distance. I loved the gameplay when I was young and had a N64. This game reminds me of the likes of Fable 2 and the Fallout franchise. Some things that bothered me in this game were the inability to jump. The Jump was done for you, but that just did not seem right for having so much control of your character. Also I have a love hate relationship for the flute, only because I was never very good at hitting all the right notes and would rage quit at some points. Overall this game was in its own league of gaming because it was so much different graphically and had a very relaxed story line than all other games before. You had the ability control Link in every manor of the game.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)